14 ms·
I’ve never considered GitHub to be “fun.” It’s a great tool, though. Most of my GH interaction is through my desktop system, not a browser (pushing and pulling
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
I’ve never considered GitHub to be “fun.” It’s a great tool, though.
Most of my GH interaction is through my desktop system, not a browser (pushing and pulling checkouts).
I’ve been using some form of source control for nearly 30 years (since Projector, in the 1990s). It’s a tool. A very, very important tool.
I appreciate many of the “glossy” features of GH, like hero images and GH Pages, but this shows how “out of touch” I must be, because I have never considered it to be a social venue or competitive arena.
It’s just a place I keep my code. I’m quite grateful for it.
- 0x402DF854 6y agoNever had any "fun" with github either. I have had my account since 2013 and I've just learned about this "trending page" thing. Can anyone explain what's it useful for?
- Insanity 6y agoYMMV, but for me it does tend to show interesting projects that I otherwise would not have learned about.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThis may also highlight one of the contrasts between my approach, and that of many of today’s engineers. I am almost exclusively a Principal author of my work; with dozens of repos, and six figures of LoC (probably seven figures, if we include the code not available in public repos). I think I may have one forked repo; an embedded Web server library that I needed to tweak a bit to make work for my ffmpeg wrapper project. This is not necessarily a good thing. By authoring my own code, I limit my scope. People who rely heavily on dependencies can have awesome results. But they need to be very careful about the provenance and quality of these dependencies. Dependency discovery is an important part of the vetting process. If we have choices, we don’t need to settle for second-best. Also, I know that, for many folks, learning is a driver for repo discovery. A lot of forks can indicate an inquisitive and open-minded approach to software development. I do support it; but it is not how I work.
- Insanity 6y agoThat's a fair point - and indeed I like those projects, not not just for finding good dependencies. I don't actually use that many external libs - but it's basically a version of "Show HN". The projects can have interesting code to read or just show off a cool idea or a different way of implementing something than I'm used to.
- rapsey 6y agoI find github search to be immensely useful. Filter by file extension and you can pretty much search the open source world for some API in a language.
- narengowda16 6y agoTalking about search: Our company uses GitHub enterprise. We have 1000+ repositories, each repo for a serverless function. Github's search is pathetically broken, I had to download all 1000 repositories in my Mac and search for a dependencies via Vscode. Surprisingly Vscode is blazing fast.
- jyriand 6y ago1000 repos seems a bit much. Does it mean that when developing a feature you have to change code in tens of repositories And then create separate commits and PRs for each of those? It just seems way too microscopic.
- roblabla 6y agoI use sourcegraph[0] for most of my searches even on non-entreprise github to work around how broken github search is. Sourcegraph has the ability to search in forks, in a specific commit, or in a set of repos that you define. It's really quite good at doing github-wide searches of arbitrary query. I'm pretty sure its self-hosted solution can be made to work with github entreprise, you might want to check it out :). Disclaimer: Just a happy sourcegraph user. [0]: https://sourcegraph.com https://sourcegraph.com
- sighol 6y agoText search in vscode is done by ripgrep[1]. [1]: https://code.visualstudio.com/updates/v1_11#_text-search-improvements https://code.visualstudio.com/updates/v1_11#_text-search-imp...
- pmontra 6y agoThe Trending page is news to me too. I discover GitHub repositories by googling for solutions to my problems or by following links in the sites of package managers (Ruby, Python, Node, Elixir.) I seldom check the other repositories of an account unless I have reasons to believe they do something else I need. What they follow, maybe never.
- glouwbug 6y agoWell, I wrote a couple projects that gained a couple hundred (and thousand) stars. I've made the front page of Hackernews three or four times. I've been featured on HackaDay and I've been spoken about on Linux Gaming Podcast. I have received cryptic Russian emails, and I have had blogs written about my work. The thrill I got from the attention was huge. I felt validated to no end, and my "collection of stars" has sent recruiters haywire. I landed my most recent job with my github portfolio. But that's just it. It's a bit of limelight. I'm thankful for the interest I've received, but that's all it is, really; it's validation from fellow programmers. It furthers your career in one or two aspects, just like Instagram fuels your self image, or prospects of influencing. But like Instagram, one can chase the limelight their whole life. Ego stroking is addictive. I urge those who come into a bit of limelight to enjoy it, but to stay humble and focus on delivering what you set out to do, not to bask in your temporory moment of glory.
- pjmlp 6y agoSame here, it is just a place to dump a couple of stuff I very seldom work on, as means to provide something to HR. I also interact mostly via desktop tools.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI work on GH-hosted code every day. My GH profile activity log is solid green. But I have been writing open-source code for twenty years. An open repo site is quite useful for that workflow.
- pjmlp 6y agoSorry I didn't intent to mean that you also just dump code there, was actually thinking about the interaction via desktop tools.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoNo offense was had. I am quite aware that we all have different approaches and workflows.
- 6510 6y agoleafpad & filezilla here. If I need organization I make a text file. Old versions are deleted.
- jfkebwjsbx 6y agoGit can be used locally!
- p2detar 6y agoI kind of do have "fun" with GH. I follow people and see what repos they have starred, or code/issues they're working on. I also follow repos and check the source code that's being committed from time to time. Just for fun, to learn new stuff. The "Explore repositories" option did help me to find a couple of interesting repos. I feel that at some point GH decided to distance themselves from the social aspect of the platform, but I still cling to it.
- xgenecloud 6y agoCannot agree more on this. There are two sides to github consumption - active and passive. On passive side - we are happy to stick to basics of git on CLI / IDE and get the job done of a version control. And the site is usually to configure CI/CD and so on. However on active consumption of open source - it is all about discovery of repos relevant to tech you are into and people behind them. It is so amazing to go and find a good committer profile and see what repos he follows. And the new github trending is simply axing their own feet here.
- paulchap 6y agoYour clash with the conventional usage and connotation of these terms was probably intended, but how is browsing repos active consumption (and vice versa)? Isn't creating and collaborating on projects much more active than just looking at interesting stuff?
- neutronicus 6y agoIn grad school I used GitHub as 1. A git-aware Google Drive, where I could stick version-controlled code I wanted to sync between computers and possibly share with colleagues (and also create a paper trail if someone beats me to the bunch publishing something, ha) 2. As a CDN serving open-source projects I depended on, but discovered almost exclusively by other means None of my GitHub-hosted code ever had a README.md, I never starred anything, and I often never even visited the repos I depended on (their documentation would be hosted elsewhere and copying-and-pasting the GH URL from there was all I needed to do to depend on it). If I visited an Issues page, it was because I got there through googling an error message, not because I went there through GH's UI. This Drive / CDN usage pattern is sort of the baseline, "passive" level of engagement with GH imo.
- artsyca 6y agoIf it ain't fun why do it?
- mihaaly 6y agoBecause it is important? Well, actually doing important things is kind of fun, so never mind.
- artsyca 6y agoThat's the spirit mihaaly. Now follow this line of reasoning a little deeper like good little knowledge worker my dearest colleague.
- CydeWeys 6y agoFor many of us SWEs on here, it's literally our job ...
- artsyca 6y agoIt's only a job if you treat it like one. But then again you most likely refuse to dress up for it, amiright? And you'll throw every prevarication in the book at me as to why dressing up for work isn't necessary. And I'll tell you that's employee mentality talking. And you'll say but I'm an engineer. And I'll say dressing up is fun, for children and adults alike And you'll say fun has no place at a job. And try as you might despite all of your engineer's training you won't be able to see there are more than three ways to frame any context. CydeWays, I like you don't get me wrong. We go about claiming that we're not saving lives and then we invest our entire existence on this earth towards things that aren't fun? We're going further than not saving lives bro, we're wasting lives.
- artsyca 6y agoAnd what's worse, you wouldn't consider a dress up job to save your career, nor does it strike you odd that there are no dress up jobs to be had. By now you still haven't noticed that casual culture is a poor substitute for no fun and you're stuck treating your job like a job, so what exactly is the upside?
- lqet 6y agoTangential: what is up with this inflationary expectation that everything should be "fun" and "exciting" and "thrilling"? I feel like western society as a whole is thinking more and more in terms of a six year old. For adults, there lies incredible satisfaction in mastering any but the most exploitative professions or jobs and fulfilling them dutifully, even if they are be no means "fun".
- chrisandchips 6y agoTBF, I don't think the author is saying that Github needs to be fun, but rather that it used to be and now isn't. It's lost a nice quality that it had.
- blondin 6y agohaving a hard time understanding what the author is saying. i never considered github to be a place to have fun at. and i am surprised by this article and curious how other people see or use github... by the way, the trending page is not everything about github! i keep discovering and bookmarking github projects every now and then. for example, this repository where the author has implementations for trigonometry functions in k&r c: https://github.com/richgel999/triglib https://github.com/richgel999/triglib i don't believe github has lost its quality either! they recently pushed that new layout preview that made the app usable when my zoom level is at 150%. i was very happy about that. i can't wait for github to provide a better search engine. and i have the feeling that they are totally working on it :)
- chrisandchips 6y agoI don't use trending often enough to know that I'm correct in saying this, but I get the impression that the author is describing a shift from "most star-ed projects each day" to some new algorithm which seems to resemble "most interesting projects as of late", with the later being less dynamic. I suppose that's in part why they feel less excitement and less value in the tool. I agree that a lot of the recent changes to GH have been really cool. This article sort of makes me wish that features like the trending page were more configurable.
- cushychicken 6y agoI’ve never considered GitHub to be “fun.” It’s a great tool, though. Yeah, seeing the headline of this article made me think of how I've never heard a carpenter exclaim what fun it is to use a cordless drill.
- stonemetal12 6y agoThen you are using the wrong tools. I still remember the first time I got to use a drill press. I totally could have drilled holes in stuff all day. Two thumbs up, would drill again!.
- LocalPCGuy 6y agoFor some reason I read that as "Two thumbs ago, would drill again" and was sad for you and your drill press accident(s).
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> Yeah, seeing the headline of this article made me think of how I've never heard a carpenter exclaim what fun it is to use a cordless drill. Strange analogy. Many people go into carpentry because they like working with power tools. It's fun. Programming is the same. Many of us were drawn to it because we like it. It's fun. If you go through life doing a job that you don't enjoy a tiny bit, you're going to be miserable. Why not have some fun?
- theamk 6y agoTry drilling a bunch of holes using 3v ikea drill with dying batteries.. And then switch to a nice 14v bosh. It ia really a lot if fun!
- zoomablemind 6y agoI'd argue, it _is_ fun to use a well-made tool. As opposed to using an ok tool that just does the job. For example, Fossil SCM as mentioned on HN few times. GitHub is a well-designed tool for multiple use cases. One aspect was the 'Social Programming' as they were marketing it back then. Trending, stars, fork counts were feeding into that aspect. Even the Issue tracker is a kinda social feature. I find GitHub as a tool is still a fun/joy/handy to use...if only they fixed the odd bug in mobile view that requires me to refresh several times before it loads the styling files.
- zackees 6y agoIt was fun in the same way hacker news is fun. It has a trending section of relevant information. It's clear that Github has changed the trending section to push api's of the big players.
- programmarchy 6y agoDid you read the article? It was all about the camaraderie created by the Trending page, which has become useless. Git is a tool, yes. But GitHub is “social coding”, which should at least be a little fun.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> Did you read the article? Umm...yes. Yes, I did. Be nice. I understood what the author was saying. I never wrote that I disagreed with it; just that I viewed it through a different lens. It appears that I am not alone in using this lens. MS used be "new, shiny," but now, they are "blue chip." I don't equate their properties with "fun," but I do believe they are serious about "let's get some work done," which jives with my lens.
- programmarchy 6y agoHaha, ok, fair enough. FWIW, I see GitLab and Bitbucket as more focused on the tooling and business-first aspects. And since creating my first repo there, I’ve always seen GitHub as a social platform for gaining notoriety within the open source community.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI feel that GH plays an important role in exactly that (I have been writing open-source software for more than twenty years, but I'm not particularly "notorious." It has never really been one of my goals). That said, I have never thought about it as the fulcrum for social networking along those lines. I have considered developer communities, like this one, or specialized ones, as places to connect, and GH as a "gallery," where we can send people to view our portfolio, after we have connected, or to "vet" contacts, like employers. My experience with GH, is that the folks that really generate the most energy, are the JavaScript/Python/Full-Stack communities. I am an Apple software specialist, and there's not really the same energy, in that community, on GH, so it shouldn't be a surprise that I don't see it the same way as JS folks.
- closeparen 6y agoThat’s not Github in particular though, that’s any git remote.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoNo, GitHub has some aspects that make it very useful for me. It's the de facto standard for sharing code, or presenting a portfolio. It also has a great API, and people have written some nice tools for it. The API is probably not unique (or even the best one), but it is well-supported by third parties.
- garfieldnate 6y agoHe's just specifically talking about the "trending" list though, right? Sure, source control is just a tool, but an internet score board showing you new open source projects? That sounds like fun, to me! Showing you things that are inspiring and interesting is part of the functionality.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoYup, but there's waaaaay too much variety in software development to make this work for all disciplines and languages, so I will bet that it has always been optimized for JS/Full Stack. I'm an Apple native developer. We aren't usually high on anyone's list.