3 ms·
Your last point is a huge one too. I read something ages ago which stuck with me ever since - a scalpel is sharper than a bread knife, but that doesn't mean it'
by taneq 6y ago
Your last point is a huge one too. I read something ages ago which stuck with me ever since - a scalpel is sharper than a bread knife, but that doesn't mean it's better. Sometimes you just need to cut bread.
A lot of companies chase highly skilled, creative, motivated developers and then stick them with routine, grindy jobs until they quit or lose the will to live. It doesn't matter how sharp your scalpel is if they're being wasted maintaining some enterprise CRUD app.
- shostack 6y agoWithout trying to push the analogy too far, I think the point holds without ascribing superiority to any particular job (or cutting tool). Case in point, I have a nice Japanese knife set. My chef's knife (your scalpel) sucks at cutting bread compared to the set's serrated bread slicing knife. Both of those knives such at spreading peanut butter and jelly to make a sandwich. The right tool (or person) for the job is what matters.
- ivanhoe 6y agoAll jobs turn into a routine after a while, but IME when it becomes a problem is usually not because of the job itself, but because you loose motivation to do it anymore. And that (to me at least) usually happens because of the bad management and/or unpleasant team environment, not the work itself. Give me the sense of purpose and I'll fix CRUD api for the rest of my life, no problem. That's what adult life is about anyway IMHO, not everyone gets to launch rockets or cure cancer, some of us work to pay bills and that's OK... and beside launching rockets and curing diseases includes a lot of grindy work, too. But if I feel unappreciated or the work seems pointless then I just disconnect from the project and don't care anymore, and then any work becomes just grinding, until you're ready to quit.
- cbsmith 6y ago...except you have to ask yourself, if you had a team of talented software engineers, how is it that their primary work remains building the same CRUD apps time and again? A good software engineer would recognize they're doing the same thing over and over again and write some software so that they didn't have to. Maybe there'd still need to be some minor adjustments to get things right, but it'd take up a modicum of their time.