3 ms·
> > Their commonality lies in the same impulse for vacuous, petit bourgeois taste to launder itself in narratives of nostalgia and cultural legitimacy. When thi
by airstrike 6y ago
> > Their commonality lies in the same impulse for vacuous, petit bourgeois taste to launder itself in narratives of nostalgia and cultural legitimacy. When thinking of minimalism, one can only wonder what the once-avant-garde cadre of artists and musicians would think about this hyper-commodified end product of their ethos, practice, and even their living circumstances.
> You can't just say the equivalent "man I can't believe the suburban normies found out about farmhouse lofts -- look at what they took from us"
I really don't see how you got that from the quote you shared
- yowlingcat 6y agoSure, maybe some more explanation would help. Let's consider what the phrase "once-avant-garde cadre" is supposed to mean in this context. What is the valuable part about this "cadre" -- is it that they were avant-garde and this is no longer the case? Or is it the functional minimalism that they pioneered? To phrase it a different way, is a good Apple laptop from the golden era of Apple laptops (which is good because it is minimal and functional) any less good once many people start using it and it stops being avant-garde? Or is its popularity simply a vindication of its successful product design, reflected by the market? If it's the latter, then I'd be inclined to agree with that definition of good. But if it's the former, I'd be inclined to question whether the definition a slick attempt to hide someone's opinions, and maybe their desire to gatekeep.