3 ms·
I think there is functional minimalism which basically just want to get out of your way and provide function but there is also a kind of pretentious one which p
by mc32 6y ago
I think there is functional minimalism which basically just want to get out of your way and provide function but there is also a kind of pretentious one which provides form over function which is overbearing, in your face minimalism that is just because it can.
- voisin 6y agoCan you provide examples of both for those of us less clear about the distinction?
- mc32 6y agoExamples of the former are the furniture and whatnot you can buy from your modern furniture store... the latter things you might see at chic museum shops (these are smaller items) but it can be things like a headrest that looks nice, but in practice doesn't work. Aesthetically it might look balanced and have a wow look but don't try sitting in it kind of thing.
- com2kid 6y agoTraditional furniture had the same problem but being too ornate instead. How many fancy hand carved wood chairs with 90 degree straight up backs exist? Painful to sit in, but they looked wonderful! It is possible to get unusable either way. :/
- sidpatil 6y agoEasy. Command line interfaces are function over form. Overly-flat UIs are form over function.
- com2kid 6y agoI mean sure. I used to own a couple of chairs that looked cool and sleek but only the cats enjoyed sitting in them. But the article starts bad-mouthing minimalism hard. I wonder if the author ever bothered asking anyone why they like having less stuff? I personally thing it is a yo-yo effect from the previous generation having too much stuff. My Dad considered cable TV to be 100% necessary and there was always at least 1 TV on in the house at all times. I've never paid for cable TV. The TV I do have is not in any of the main living spaces, and it is off 95% of the day. Heck I primarily use it to pump audiobooks through from my phone.
- mc32 6y agoYeah I think part of her rant she’s just mad common folk are cramping her style. So obvs it’s déclassé now; dégueulasse.
- kens 6y ago> pretentious one which provides form over function Looking at the minimalist kitchen photo at the top of the article, I don't see how it could even work. There are no appliances other than the stove and oven: no refrigerator, dishwasher, or microwave. And the shelves hold (literally) four dishes and 5 spices. Is everything hidden in the drawers? Not to mention the lack of electrical outlets, which violates code. The more I look at that photo, the more it puzzles me.
- zerocrates 6y agoThe link to the source for the image [1] has just a jumble of keywords as a description, but would seem to indicate that it's a 3D render and not a photo. Possibly explaining the mysterious glowing staircase as well. See also the similarly tagged images such as [2] which seems to also include a non-kitchen over in its back corner. [1] https://pxhere.com/en/photo/1056201 https://pxhere.com/en/photo/1056201 [2] https://pxhere.com/en/photo/599832 https://pxhere.com/en/photo/599832
- Symbiote 6y agoThe 8-person table and the children's toys are inappropriate for what's probably a 1 room apartment. (That kitchen isn't big enough to store food for a family.) Otherwise, it looks fairly similar to any modern apartment in Denmark. https://www.realmaeglerne.dk/bolig/115-0836-store-kongensgade-23a-2 https://www.realmaeglerne.dk/bolig/115-0836-store-kongensgad... https://portal.newsec.dk/bolig/ledig-privat-bolig/historisk-perle-paa-amaliegade-39-35087-315 https://portal.newsec.dk/bolig/ledig-privat-bolig/historisk-... (unfurnished, but presumably includes an integrated dishwasher and fridge)