4 ms·
IOS is probably closer to 50% marketshare in the US and perhaps near 90% in younger demographics. Anti-trust doesn't require a perfect monopoly, only consumer h
by paulryanrogers 6y ago
IOS is probably closer to 50% marketshare in the US and perhaps near 90% in younger demographics. Anti-trust doesn't require a perfect monopoly, only consumer harm.
- namrog84 6y agoI think you might be surprised.
- scarface74 6y agoHow is the consumer harmed? If Apple’s “walled garden” was harming consumers we should see lower prices for Android apps.
- zaroth 6y agoRight, I buy an Apple device for myself and my whole family exactly because the ecosystem is a tightly integrated walled garden. There’s nothing anti-competitive or anti-consumer about walled gardens per say. Walled gardens are consistently chosen by consumers because they make devices easier to use and maintain and the user experience more predictable through actual enforcement of consistent UI standards.
- harpratap 6y agoThere is a consumer harm when Apple Music doesn't have to pay 30% cut to App Store while Spotify and the likes have to. That's a huge competitive advantage to Apple. Not to mention Apple can simply advertise their own Apple Music Subscription inside the default Music app and gain market share just like Internet Explorer did.
- scarface74 6y agoSpotify hasn’t allowed in app purchases for years. It doesn’t pay a 30% cut.
- harpratap 6y agoThey don't do that because Apple doesn't allow you to do that. Not because they don't want to.
- scarface74 6y agoI’m sure every company would like to sell stuff for free and bypass the retailer’s markup.
- harpratap 6y agoThey already get charged $100/year for doing that.
- scarface74 6y agoA whole $100 a year? How much do you think the slotting fee is for your typical grocer? Do you think wholesalers pay retailers only $100 a year and then get no markup?
- harpratap 6y agoNot a developer's problem if $100 isn't enough for Apple. They are free to charge a fair price and get rid of their anti-competitive behaviour.
- zaroth 6y agoGoogle makes billions of dollars as the gatekeeper to advertising on their Search engine. Apple makes (fewer) billions of dollars as the gatekeeper to their App Store. Google probably takes more than a 30% cut on the ad revenue that they place on 3rd party sites. I’m not saying it’s a perfect analogy (that would be a contradiction). But in general companies make a product, they get to derive revenue directly by selling the product, and/or they can derive revenue by selling access to the users of that product. Google gives the Search engine away for free because they can make way more money selling advertisers access. Apple increasingly is giving their phone away free-er (lower margin) because they can derive more revenue by selling access to services like App Store. It’s their store. They created it. They sold it with the rules they created being clearly displayed on the package. They actually believe those exact rules to be a huge competitive advantage for them. I believe the rules should be clear and evenly enforced, and they should not discriminate based on things like political/religious viewpoint or basically content beyond maturity rating/obscenity/hate speech.
- Marsymars 6y agoTough to find good, recent data on this, but by and large, the trend skews in the other direction. iOS is proportionally more popular than Android among older people. Old (2013) data: https://www.statista.com/statistics/271228/android-vs-iphone-mobile-owners-age/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/271228/android-vs-iphone...
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoI hate to be the [citation needed] guy again, but the iPhone came out in 2007 and the first Android phone came out in 2008, and you're citing data from 2013. Those phones were five to six years old when that data came out, and that data is now seven years old. In 2017[1], the iOS/Android market share between people 18-29 and people 30-59 seems to be almost identical, and while the market share of people 60+ shows a bit more of a bias toward iOs, it's not a super dramatic difference. In any case, I think this mostly reflects that there are way, way more Android phones available at a huge range of price points than there are iPhones, and if you don't have a whole lot to spend on a new phone you're more likely to get an Android. Because it's pretty difficult to get a new iPhone for less then $350[2] and most of them are in the $600+ range, its audience tends to skew older just because older people tend to have more money. [1]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/911113/smartphone-os-share-by-age-group-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/911113/smartphone-os-sha... [2]: The iPhone 7 is currently on sale for $350 through carriers, but the cheapest iPhone Apple admits to still making is the iPhone SE at $400.
- Marsymars 6y agoI sadly can't view your statista link at all, it seems entirely behind a paywall. > its audience tends to skew older just because older people tend to have more money. Yeah, I didn't comment on the cause, but I expect that's a big reason for it. In any case, it's still a far cry from near 90% iOS use in younger demographics. (I edited my other reply slightly - I didn't mean to imply that Android has a 90% marketshare in younger age groups, just that it's proportionally more popular than in older age groups.)
- 6y ago