3 ms·
> What they are doing is changing a known transparent standard Unfortunately, the standard is a bad standard and I'm fully in support of abolishing the SAT as
by dheera 6y ago
> What they are doing is changing a known transparent standard
Unfortunately, the standard is a bad standard and I'm fully in support of abolishing the SAT as a requirement.
For engineers, the SAT math section basically amounts to measuring how many mistakes you make doing stupid easy math under 90 minutes of stress. The SAT verbal section basically measures how well you memorize word lists. Let's not BS ourselves -- I memorized word lists in high school and I almost never use any of those words.
For liberal arts, vocabulary knowledge is rarely the bottleneck in their ability to succeed, and the math is largely unimportant.
Neither part of the test is a good indicator of one's preparedness to receive a high quality university education, and much less an indicator of the type of
education most people look for at Harvard.
Someone who wants to major in East Asian studies, for example, really doesn't need to know what "obstreperous" means, let alone an engineer or scientist.
Harvard doesn't need standards. They need a bunch of unique, bright people that are prepared to make change in the world in their own unique ways.
I went to "the other school" down the street from Harvard and from what I remember the application was heavily focused on extracurricular activities. I think that's a much better qualitative indicator of one's motivation and ability to go beyond courses and exams in their desire to learn and make impact.
- dheera 6y agoBased on the downvotes, I guess HN is a bunch of adamant test-loving folks. I guess this kind of open discussion isn't welcome here.