3 ms·
>No, this is not true. If it were, the star's mass would be zero. All it means is that if we were to take all the constituent particles in a star and spread th
by simonh 6y ago
>No, this is not true. If it were, the star's mass would be zero.
All it means is that if we were to take all the constituent particles in a star and spread them out at 'infinity' from each other (effectively all across the universe), pushing them apart working against the gravity of the star holding it together, the energy required would be equal to the energy in those particles (from their mass, nuclear forces, etc).
The energy cost of disassembling a star equals the energy in the star, so the net energy of the star is zero. It's just a matter of doing the relevant calculations to see this, which was first done by Pascual Jordan in the 1940s.
I realise it's a ridiculously counter-intuitive result. Apparently when Einstein was told this, he stopped dead in his tracks while crossing a busy road.
- saagarjha 6y agoIt doesn’t actually make much sense to do that for each individual particle, because the strong force will prevent some of them from being separated due to color confinement.
- pdonis 6y ago> f we were to take all the constituent particles in a star and spread them out at 'infinity' from each other (effectively all across the universe), pushing them apart working against the gravity of the star holding it together, the energy required would be equal to the energy in those particles (from their mass, nuclear forces, etc). This would require that all of the particles in the end state of the disassembly were massless (so all of the rest mass goes away in the disassembly process); but if they are massless, they can't also have zero kinetic energy (the only kind of energy a massless particle can have in the absence of gravity) or they don't exist at all. So I don't think the scenario you are implicitly relying on here is possible. > It's just a matter of doing the relevant calculations to see this, which was first done by Pascual Jordan in the 1940s. Do you have a reference? (And no, I don't mean the pop science references in the "Zero energy universe" Wikipedia article, I mean an actual reference to the published paper by Jordan where he makes the calculations you refer to. Or a more recent paper where someone else makes similar calculations.)
- simonh 6y agoThe particles in the end state would be the same mass they were in the star, and at rest in the star’s frame of reference. Why do you think simply moving them would make them massless? As for references, the Wikipedia article explains the publication history of the idea and has references to the relevant papers. Jordan didn’t publish as it was during the war, as I understand it he just discussed it in his correspondences but there has been work done on it since.
- pdonis 6y ago> The particles in the end state would be the same mass they were in the star, and at rest in the star’s frame of reference. Then the energy remaining at the end of the process would not be zero. Rest mass is energy. > Why do you think simply moving them would make them massless? Because you said "the energy required would be equal to the energy in those particles (from their mass, nuclear forces, etc)"; you included "mass" in the energy that would be required to overcome gravity, and would therefore be gone at the end of the process.
- simonh 6y ago> Then the energy remaining at the end of the process would not be zero. I didn’t say it would be. The final energy would be in the rest mass of the particles, and that’s all the energy there would be, despite just having pumped an entire star masses worth of energy into it to counteract the gravitational energy of the star. You’re reading what I wrote and then filtering that into something completely different. You’re not actually replying to what I’m saying, but some bizarre distorted misunderstanding of it. To illustrate... > Because you said "the energy required would be equal to the energy in those particles (from their mass, nuclear forces, etc)"; you included "mass" in the energy that would be required to overcome gravity, and would therefore be gone at the end of the process. I didn’t say anything about using the mass of the particles to move them about. That is utter nonsense. I just said that’s how much energy it would take. It’s a general point about the amount of energy in the system.
- 6y ago
- D-Coder 6y ago> I realise it's a ridiculously counter-intuitive result. Apparently when Einstein was told this, he stopped dead in his tracks while crossing a busy road. For a smart guy, that's not very smart.