5 ms·
The best thing about setting up Google wifi routers for your relatives is you can set yourself up as the manager of them, and manage them with the Google Wifi a
by jeffbee 6y ago
The best thing about setting up Google wifi routers for your relatives is you can set yourself up as the manager of them, and manage them with the Google Wifi app from anywhere. So before Uncle Bob calls you about the wifi you'd already have got the notification that his cable service is down again.
- thoraway1010 6y agoI do this with my elderly parents. Doubles as a "powers gone out - are they freezing" alert.
- londons_explore 6y agoI've had a pretty disappointing run with those Google Wifi routers... It started with the lack of ability to have an open guest wifi... Like - it's for my guests, I want anyone to be able to connect, and I don't want to be faffing with passwords or guests having to ask me... I have to name my network "My House - Password Is password" Then every month it seemed to do some kind of update and disconnect wifi devices... Sure - it's only for 30 seconds, but a disconnection is a disconnection. Thats going to boot you off whatever game you are playing... And now I've got the trouble that as you have a bunch of mesh points, you can't walk between them without glitches in a video call... Like seriously - I should be able to start facetime and walk round my house without random freezes for 5 seconds while it reconnects to a different mesh point. Google Wifi has been out for years now, and not a single one of these bugs is any better than it was at launch. Not really acceptable for a $400 router setup!
- jeffbee 6y agoGoogle Wifi just released a new version in June 2020. The one before that was October 2019, and June 2019 before that. That's only 2 updates per year. How disruptive is that?
- ndesaulniers 6y agoIf it means the software is up to date, then I can live with an interruption. It might be nice to have power controls, but I think they do a fair job keeping the UI simple. That's not to say a power user UI couldn't be added, but it certainly increases the testing burden to add new features that need to be tested for regression.
- antsar 6y agoSorry to be "that guy", but how about not giving an advertisement company access to all your network traffic (while paying them for the privilege)... Almost every router supports some form of remote management (or just put TeamViewer on their machine). Most also support dynamic DNS so you can set up a ping check for the "its down" notification.
- jeffbee 6y agoSorry to say that you are "that guy" and your comment, in addition to adding nothing to this conversation, also detracts from HN generally and contributes to the perception that it is an unserious place haunted by the deranged and irrational. "Google Wifi and Nest Wifi devices do not track the websites you visit or collect the content of any traffic on your network."
- antsar 6y agoDisagree about "adding nothing". We're talking about hardware for nontechnical family/friends, who might not understand the conflict of interest. It's not nice to project your apathy/disbelief that Google would abuse the access onto those people. The name-calling is really not necessary. Why not make your point on its own merits? The doc[0] you're quoting continues to list a bunch of things they do collect, including some with no opt-out. Way to cherry-pick. Even the part you quoted does not exclude traffic metadata. [0] https://support.google.com/wifi/answer/6246642?hl=en https://support.google.com/wifi/answer/6246642?hl=en
- Sodman 6y agoThe fact that I've paid them for the hardware gives me more confidence that I'm not the product. Ironically, the fact that I can get TeamViewer for free and use it to get remote access others' computers makes it feel like a higher threat attack vector for me. Before I bought the Google mesh wifi, I already had android, chrome, project Fi, and Google's DNS (router level) at various levels of my request stack. That's not even counting search, gmail, and calendar. If Google are playing shady games with my network traffic, whatever marginal gain they get from having software on my router is negligible. Especially compared to the awful PR backlash they'd get once somebody hooks some monitoring gear up to their hardware and exposes it.