4 ms·
It's often good to question assumptions. I happened to do well on SATs/ACTs, so I could be biased in their favor. But, I was curious--what is the actual predi
by ylem 6y ago
It's often good to question assumptions. I happened to do well on SATs/ACTs, so I could be biased in their favor. But, I was curious--what is the actual predictive value of SATs/ACTs on college outcomes such as say GPA or graduation rate. This study would suggest that it's actually more predictive (at least in Alaska) than test scores:
https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/edlabs/projects/project.asp?projectID=4546 https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/edlabs/projects/project.asp?projectI...
Has anyone else found other studies? I would be shocked if there isn't some kind of meta-analysis. Before getting into any discussion about social issues, let's see whether the tests are actually predictive. Or, if it's just a cargo cult.
My intuition was that these tests (ACT/SAT) would help to normalize for different levels of schools, but I will go with data over intuition.
In some sense, this move by Harvard will allow for a natural experiment to see if there are actually changes in outcomes when GPAs are/are not considered.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoThe UC system has dropped SAT/ACT as well because the Regents determined them to be racist. In spite of internal studies at UC schools that determined that the way the test scores are being used is not racist or discriminatory.