5 ms·
> Or did we never get confirmation that it was effective? The reverse, there's confirmation it's ineffective. It may not be dangerous (I don't know) but it's n
by Nursie 6y ago
> Or did we never get confirmation that it was effective?
The reverse, there's confirmation it's ineffective. It may not be dangerous (I don't know) but it's no longer allowed as treatment in the US as the evidence has shown it's not useful.
Can we stop talking about this and move on yet?
It was only ever really of interest because Trump was flailing about for anything to make it look like he had a plan earlier in the year.
- gfodor 6y agoNo, there was interest because this was used in South Korea. Then, trump said a thing, everyone lost their minds, studies were rushed, the press lied about intermediate statistically-insignificant results, and it was a complete embarrassment to the medical community. The politicization of a medicine has been one of the stupidest things I’ve ever seen in my lifetime.
- Nursie 6y ago> The politicization of a medicine has been one of the stupidest things I’ve ever seen in my lifetime. Couldn't agree more. It's insane that medical science gets turned into a partisan pissing match.
- pjc50 6y ago> The politicization of a medicine has been one of the stupidest things I’ve ever seen in my lifetime. This seems to have been going on since Wakefield and the anti-vaxers; and one of the big reasons for rejecting chloroquine was exactly that it was being promoted by a whole infrastructure of dodgy quack websites. Which is undoubtedly where Trump got the idea from.
- WillPostForFood 6y agoIt may not be dangerous (I don't know) but it's no longer allowed as treatment in the US This is not true. It is still allowed as a treatment, and there are still studies going on using it in the US. The FDA emergency approval has been removed, which is more of a technical status. You can no longer acquire it from the government stockpile, and it is no longer recommended.
- Nursie 6y agoFair enough, as a non-American I presumed the withdrawal of approval meant something stronger than a recommendation. Regardless, the point stands, evidence of efficacy is lacking, evidence of lack of efficacy appears to be coming in, this whole thing has turned into a political canard and is likely distracting from real progress.