40 ms·
Currently the FDA has the unchecked power to create federal felonies, because failure to comply with FDA regulations is a felony. This is false. The FDA can o
by gamblor956 6y ago
Currently the FDA has the unchecked power to create federal felonies, because failure to comply with FDA regulations is a felony.
This is false.
The FDA can only issue regulations within the specific statutory authority given to it by Congress.
Moreover, a violation of an FDA regulation is not a felony. At best, the FDA can refer a case to the Justice Department for an investigation of whether federal laws were violated when violating the regulation. In many cases, it is possible to violate a regulation without violating the law authorizing that regulation. In others, violating the regulation is synonymous with violating the statute because the regulation just restates the statute.
- ashtonkem 6y agoYou’re confusing the ability to create a felony vs. the ability to prosecute one. The fact that they still have to refer to the justice department to prosecute is a different thing. I’m not saying that the FDA has unlimited regulatory authority, they could not for example regulate financial securities, but they have an unchecked authority. This is subtly different.