3 ms·
Given how messed up I think that whole system is, having to send kids to segregated schools instead of integrated ones would rank pretty low on my list of thing
by scarface74 6y ago
Given how messed up I think that whole system is, having to send kids to segregated schools instead of integrated ones would rank pretty low on my list of things to complain about. I'd be far more worried about how the school was trying to indoctrinate kids than what the demographics of the student body were.
You really don’t know much about how bad that whole “separate but equal” thing worked out in practice? I bet a years salary that your parents never told you how bad Jim Crow laws were for minorities. Nor did they have to grow up under them.
This is what happens when courts try to make policy: you get a symbolic victory without the substance. I think most people, if they thought about it, would prefer the substance; but the only way to get that in a democracy is by doing the hard work of changing how citizens are willing to vote.
It’s easy to argue theory when you aren’t personally effected. No matter how much money I made, I wouldn’t have been allowed to buy a house in the area that I now live because of racial covenants 50 years ago. I wouldn’t have been able to move into the “good neighborhoods” where I could send my son to the “good schools”.
Sorry, I’m not fond with waiting for the “democratic process” and beg racists (speaking hypothetically if the court hadn’t overturned the laws) to vote to outlaw Jim Crow laws.
- pdonis 6y ago> You really don’t know much about how bad that whole “separate but equal” thing worked out in practice? I never said "separate but equal" wasn't bad. Remember I said that I think the whole US public school system should either not have existed at all, or should have developed along very different lines. > I’m not fond with waiting for the “democratic process” Then you don't want to live in a democracy. Democracy means that you change the law using the democratic process, and that all the people, even the ones whose views you abhor, have a voice in that process. If people who take your view would admit straight up that they don't want democracy and want to abolish our democratic form of government and replace it with something that better suits them, that would be one thing. But, as I pointed out upthread, the very same people call themselves "Democrats" and say democracy is wonderful and argue that everything they are doing is perfectly consistent with the form of government we are supposed to have according to our Constitution and laws. What they mean is that democracy is wonderful as long as it does what they want, and the Constitution and laws can be set aside whenever necessary in order to achieve their policy objectives. That's not democracy, and it's not the rule of law. It's just arbitrary exercise of power according to personal opinion.
- scarface74 6y agoSo I should want to live in this great theoretical democracy where the will of the majority means the government can legally discriminate against me? Or as late as 2013 , there were cases where gay people were being arrested for “sodomy” because they were having sex in their own homes? (https://slate.com/human-interest/2013/08/gay-people-are-still-being-arrested-for-having-consensual-sex-in-some-red-states-like-louisiana.html https://slate.com/human-interest/2013/08/gay-people-are-stil...) just because those are the laws passed by the “democratic process”? I have a strange feeling you wouldn’t feel the same way if the Democratic process infringed on your liberties. Do you agree that I shouldn’t have been able to buy a house in a certain neighborhood because the “Democratic process” allowed racial covenants? Or that my son shouldn’t have been able to go to the school that he was zone to and instead wait on people to decide that it was okay with them even though I was paying taxes too?
- pdonis 6y ago> So I should want to live in this great theoretical democracy where the will of the majority means the government can legally discriminate against me? What kind of society you want to live in is up to you. Just don't pretend that you want to live in the kind of society that our Constitution and laws describe, if you actually don't. > I have a strange feeling you wouldn’t feel the same way if the Democratic process infringed on your liberties. According to our Constitution and laws, it can't. The fact that it often does is a sign that our so-called "Democratic process" is actually not respecting our Constitution and laws, but is instead based on arbitrary exercises of power. Adding more arbitrary exercises of power to the mix does not help fix that problem. > Do you agree that I shouldn’t have been able to buy a house in a certain neighborhood because the “Democratic process” allowed racial covenants? Do you think such covenants are allowed by the Constitution and the Bill of Rights? > Or that my son shouldn’t have been able to go to the school that he was zone to and instead wait on people to decide that it was okay with them even though I was paying taxes too? Do you think that policy is consistent with the Constitution and the Bill of Rights?
- scarface74 6y ago