6 ms·
Oh ffs. Get some education: https://www.google.com/search?q=dictionary+master&oq=dictionary+master https://www.google.com/search?q=dictionary+master&oq=diction.
by exabrial 6y ago
Oh ffs. Get some education: https://www.google.com/search?q=dictionary+master&oq=dictionary+master https://www.google.com/search?q=dictionary+master&oq=diction...
These are just distractions from real issues. This isn't even incremental progress; it's a conscious choice to do nothing while looking good like you're actually "doing something".
- bnj 6y agoThe first definition reads, “a man who has people working for him, especially servants or slaves.” Wouldn’t that seem to justify moving in a direction of updating these terms?
- exabrial 6y agoI would recommend a guide on parts of speech and expanding and reading all definitions.
- arielserafini 6y agoIf we're being sticklers, in this context you have to take the meaning of the word "master" in relation to its counterpart, "slave"; the other definitions are irrelevant.
- Proziam 6y agoThe first definition is marked historical. The other 3 definitions google offers make no reference to slavery unless you really want to stretch "in charge of an organization or group" just to be offended.
- bnj 6y agoPersonally, and perhaps I should have said this in my first comment, I would challenge the premise that the dictionary definition should be a controlling factor in responding to this whole question. For me, it's more about looking at the potential for harm. I happen to be a white man with no particular harm one way or another associated with terms like these, but I can understand how people with other experiences might feel impacted by being surrounded by terminology like this. It doesn't hurt me at all to change the terms I use, and if other people with other backgrounds think it's important to do it, I don't have any problem with that.
- Proziam 6y agoMy issue with this approach is this: it drags attention and headlines away from real issues. We need serious reform in our policing and prisons in the US. Every time serious reform is demanded in any real way, the distractions get brought up and the real issues are minimized. I don't believe for a moment that this is accidental. As someone who has black siblings who are now having children of their own, I am infinitely more offended that the real issues get strategically minimized. Look at the reactions to these threads for an example. Look at how many people (black and white) are saying it's an [0]"obvious distraction" or a non-issue. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/h8w36t/github_will_no_longer_use_the_term_master_as/ https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/h8w36t/github_...
- bnj 6y agoI absolutely respect that, and honestly I'm not sure how much energy needs to be spent on these terms. I agree that it would be an overall negative if we allowed something that might be insignificant like these systemic terms to distract from things like legal reform. Personally, I would settle on the side of updating the terms and not being too worried about it or expending further thought, because the use of these specific master/slave terms isn't something I'm attached to. It's a habit I don't mind updating. I also think, tentatively, that it's not really for me to decide how big a deal this is. I just don't have the experience to understand how big an impact these terms might have. It seems plausible that distractors would get thrown around at a time like this to expend energy without attacking any real structures which would make life more uncomfortable, and I appreciate your bringing it up because I might not have thought about it in those terms. For myself, I'm happy for these terms to get updated, and I intend to do what I can to focus on continuing to educate myself and try to learn how I can be more effective in deconstructing things that cause harm to people, and to trying to learn more about what it means to be anti-racist. In terms of values, that's how I think I want to approach something like this, and I respect that other people have a different approach-- I don't mind, as long as the approach people take isn't rooted in things that will perpetuate violence and harm toward people.
- 6y ago
- stdbrouw 6y agoLet's grant that a terminology change like this is just a distraction. If so, why do you get so worked up about it? Why not just say to yourself "heh, much good that'll do, but whatever" and move on?
- exabrial 6y agoIt's exhausting watching companies that have enough capital and resources to educate, train, and employ disadvantaged Americans and give them a better life resort to pandering of the lowest level during a crisis to promote their brand. I don't wish to participate or support their ruse.
- stdbrouw 6y agoBut Peter Kirn, the author, is not a company, he's a musician. He's not selling music software so he can't (as per the sibling comment) racewash it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- elif 6y agoThe case that could be made is that the energy, time, and attention of a movement are finite, and those resources can be allocated in a way that makes us /feel/ like change is happening while, in fact, no substantive change is occurring. It can function like a pressure relief valve. An immediate example that comes to mind is the firing of 6 APD officers that discharged tasers at protestors. Subsequently, nothing structural in the police department changed, but protests dissipated because of the 'victory' and then an even worse botched arrest occured because nothing fundamental had changed.
- jjeaff 6y agoMerely firing officers for wrongdoing is itself a huge departure from the norm and starts to set a precedent. Of course, it must continue even when riots aren't gathered outside the precinct.
- kspacewalk2 6y agoWhat's the term that's equivalent to greenwashing here? Racewashing?
- happytoexplain 6y agoWhile at first glance I don't see any value in changing these terms, I do think pushback of this angry tone serves to illustrate the shocking degree of negative emotional energy that people have for the topic, which ironically serves as evidence that the terms do matter, and strengthens the argument for the change.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- exabrial 6y agoNo, not at all. Read my other comment below.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kibibu 6y agoThe article explicitly says that Master on its own is not a problem. So, for example, creating a CD master, or remastering, is fine. The issue is with the master/slave pairing.
- tartoran 6y agoYeah, I always wondered who came up with this master/slave terminology and what they had in mind. Was it a joke?
- notajoke 6y agoNo, I don’t think so anyway. It’s a very literal, very accurate abstraction for reasoning about the way two components in a system interact. Consider devices connected on an i2c communication bus. One device is literally acting as the master and dictating to the slaves, who have no choice in the matter. To argue that the terms should be changed is to deny the reality of the situation - some of those devices are enslaved. Not followers, slaves!
- arielserafini 6y ago"very accurate"? so a "master" hard drive issues commands to a "slave" drive?
- notajoke 6y agoYes, exactly. Take IDE drives for example. To use two drives with a single cable, one is set to be the master, the other to be the slave. From that point onwards, the slave cannot write to the bus until the master gives permission.
- arielserafini 6y agoI was referring to newer ATA drives. Nevertheless, in your example no orders (or ownership!) are implied.
- 6y ago
- slumpt_ 6y agoAre you a person of color? It may be relevant to whether or not you could or would likely understand adequately why this might bother someone. Edit: Downvotes won’t make this inconvenient reality go away.
- AdrianB1 6y agoI live in a country where slavery is something we read about from books, the master/slave terms have no race conotations. Changing established technical terms just because less than 5% of the world population has some sensitivity to history before their grand-grand parents is excessive. Don't make me remember what Italian's ancestors did to my ancestors, or else I will have to ask current Italians for reparations. Well, this sounds extremely stupid, is it?
- slumpt_ 6y agoIt doesn’t sound extremely stupid to me. I’m not a person of color but can imagine how it might feel like the right time to shrug certain terms out of our public discourse. That it does not upset you is of no consequence. That it may be hurtful to others has consequence. It’s very little skin off our backs in the grand scheme. If it is a hill you’d like to die on though, do as you must. I’d just suggest that there may be times things frustrate you that you do not understand, and it is then that it can be better to simply listen. Take care.
- asjw 6y agoAs Italian, I'm sorry for what we did And I add to what you said: don't make me remember what other Italians did to my Italian family, no more than 75 years ago.
- AdrianB1 6y agoDo not be sorry for what some people 2000 years ago did to some other people; it was not you, there is nothing to be sorry about. Collective guilt and collective punishment are bad ideas.
- bJGVygG7MQVF8c 6y agoIndeed. I'm glad people are fixing racism (read: assuaging their white guilt) by renaming things instead of agitating for health care reform (or, closer at hand: for interview process reform). Why it's almost as if this is all a distraction that effectively benefits the already comfortable...