3 ms·
While WD's mismanagement of this is incredible, saying "WD knew about ZFS Issues" because one employee of WD said DM SMR was inappropriate for ZFS at a conferen
by aidenn0 6y ago
While WD's mismanagement of this is incredible, saying "WD knew about ZFS Issues" because one employee of WD said DM SMR was inappropriate for ZFS at a conference a few years ago overstates things.
Even at relatively small companies, not all knowledge disseminates equally through the company, and WD isn't exactly a small company. It's almost certain that the team that was responsible for the WD Red SMR release was not aware of this issue or this wouldn't have happened. What probably happened was something more along the lines of:
1. Traditional wisdom says SMR can't be used in raid
2. DM-SMR firmware has gotten much better at hiding the performance issues of SMR since traditional wisdom
3. Let's actually measure this in some RAID setups and see what happens
4. Hmm, those numbers look reasonable, we can ship this!
At no point did anyone think very hard about ZFS being an edge-case for DM-SMR.
All that being said, the drives absolutely should have been represented as DM-SMR, along with some nice benchmark numbers to show that the performance hit isn't as bad as one might think. In the right RAID setup, these drives are at a reasonable performance/value point in the curve.
- syshum 6y agoIt is not just ZFS edge cases seeing issues, ZFS was just the bell weather. Synology does not use ZFS at all, and they are seeing issues Also ZFS being an "edge case" is not going to be true long term as alot of SMB and Home NAS vendors (the very customers the WD Red Line targets) are starting to use ZFS on Linux more and more
- boomboomsubban 6y agoI haven't seen the data for a few years, but I believe random Synology and other premade NAS dominated the market. To the point where ZFS would always be an edgecase.
- syshum 6y agoSynology and QNap are probably the 2 biggest in this market segment, Synology already has issues and QNAP is bringing ZFS to market in their latest line of NAS devices Synology also has used btrfs in the past which I would suspect may suffer the same kind of issue as ZFS but dont know forsure
- boomboomsubban 6y agoMy point here was that ZFS will continue being an edge case, as the premades dominate the market and do not provide ZFS. QNAP may offer it on home devices in the future, but may also limit it to premium devices. I am not making a statement about any compatibility here.