3 ms·
An indictment sets forth the government’s allegations regarding the charged crimes. The government’s case is that Assange crossed the line from receiving illega
by rayiner 6y ago
An indictment sets forth the government’s allegations regarding the charged crimes. The government’s case is that Assange crossed the line from receiving illegally leaked materials to facilitating the illegal leak. The content of the email isn’t relevant to the charged crime except that the information needs to be classified.
The fact that the leaked information contained evidence of arguable war crimes is at most a moral (but not legal) justification. There is a good argument that the government should have exercised its prosecutorial discretion not to pursue this case in that basis. But an indictment does not need to include evidence that might be morally exculpatory. (It doesn’t even have to include legally relevant exculpatory evidence; the prosecutor is just required to disclose that to the defense attorney.) Assange will definitely raise this video and other evidence in his defense.
The Guardian article twists the narrative—alleging the government “failed to include” to evidence, as if it had a duty to do so—to artificially bolster its premise. You can say that the government should hold back in a prosecution because conduct, though technically illegal, was justified. But reasonable people may or may not agree with that. So instead, the author takes it a step further to try and make it look like the government “failed” to disclose information it was obligated to include (conduct that’s much harder to agree with.)
- fit2rule 6y agoIt is highly dangerous for citizens of the 5-eyes' War Coalition states to investigate their own governments war crimes. THAT is the message being conveyed. And the point of the article is to demonstrate that, indeed, the USA doesn't care about war crimes. It does care about its own PR, however - and that is a very curious conundrum. One wonders why it is so important for the US government to hide their war crimes away and distract the public from the real issue. It surely isn't for benign purposes. Someone is on the run, here. I wonder when we'll catch them, again ..
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]