5 ms·
> Which is great for Democrats (like myself) I find it rather grimly ironic that a political party that calls itself "Democratic" endorses explicitly non democ
by pdonis 6y ago
> Which is great for Democrats (like myself)
I find it rather grimly ironic that a political party that calls itself "Democratic" endorses explicitly non democratic means for making reforms, on the grounds that, in your own words, "Voters cannot be relied upon to enact these kinds of changes themselves".
- erichocean 6y agoPolitical labels are almost meaningless; always judge politics by actions, not words. The Democrat Party today is as far from Andrew Jackson (it's first President) than North Korea (the Democratic People's Republic of Korea) is from being a democracy, or a republic.
- pdonis 6y agoYou called yourself a "Democrat". Even if you want to disclaim association with the political party that calls itself that, you still have the same problem I attributed to them.
- erichocean 6y agoJudges are nominated and confirmed by elected officials, which are determined by the voters. Which part of that is "undemocratic"?
- pdonis 6y ago> Which part of that is "undemocratic"? The part where judges make political decisions that are supposed to be made by voters and their elected representatives. The fact that some busybody believes that voters "can't be relied on" to enact particular policies that the busybody favors does not justify getting those policies enacted by judges instead. Judges are not supposed to enact policies. They are supposed to say what the law is, not what someone believes it ought to be.
- erichocean 6y ago> Judges are not supposed to enact policies. They are supposed to say what the law is, not what someone believes it ought to be. I think that was true at the country's founding, but is no longer true today. The entire purpose of Civil Rights legislation was to enable the courts to "enact policies", which they have done continuously since. They are literally doing what Congress asked them to do. If you don't like Civil Rights legislation, fine. But don't blame the courts for using it as the basis to do what Congress has clearly empowered them to do.
- pdonis 6y ago> The entire purpose of Civil Rights legislation was to enable the courts to "enact policies" Congress cannot change the structure of the government by passing a law. The Constitution makes enacting policies the job of Congress (and the President, for either signing or vetoing bills passed by Congress), not the Supreme Court. If we want the Supreme Court to be able to enact policies, we would need to amend the Constitution. As I said in another comment upthread, I think you have a highly idiosyncratic (and wrong) view of how law in the US works.
- scarface74 6y agoWould you have preferred that judges didn’t rule the way they did in the case of Brown vs Board of Education? The “busy bodies” are the people who want to deny employment to people just because who they share a bed with.
- pdonis 6y ago> Would you have preferred that judges didn’t rule the way they did in the case of Brown vs Board of Education? As a matter of law I would have preferred that political decisions about public schools were made by legislatures, not judges, as they are supposed to be. The idea that the purpose of government is to get our favored policies in place, by hook or by crook, is going to be the death of our republic sooner or later. The government is supposed to uphold the rule of law, and the law of the land in the US, the Constitution, does not give judges the power to make political decisions. As a matter of policy, I would have preferred that the whole public school system in the US have either not been developed at all, or developed along very different lines. The people who put the US public school system in place were quite explicit that their purpose was to indoctrinate children. I think the government has no business indoctrinating children. But that policy question is way past any hope of repair.
- redler 6y agoThe term "Democrat Party" (and, more generally, "Democrat" as an adjective) is both a shibboleth signaling opposing tribal membership, and an epithet signaling contempt for the Democratic Party — the actual name of the organization. It's adult name-calling. The usage is widely understood to be an intentional discourtesy.
- scarface74 6y agoMaybe it’s because the majority should never have the right to impinge on basic liberties because of religious beliefs — see also, laws against “sodomy” (non heterosexual sex) and laws against “miscegenation” (interracial marriage).
- rayiner 6y agoWhat’s a “basic liberty?” Who gets to decide? What happens if the majority literally believes that God will punish their society if it condones “sinful” behavior? You can say that religious beliefs shouldn’t be the basis of law, but who put you in charge? And what happens when people’s “basic liberties” conflict? Isn’t freedom of association a “basic liberty?” Is there somewhere in the constitution that says it doesn’t apply to employers? I view the legal process like arguing with your spouse. Every win has a cost. Every victory for individual self determination achieved through litigation chips away at the right of collective self determination, and that’s not cost free.
- scarface74 6y agoSo we can argue theory all day long. Do you think a “democracy” should have the right to imprison someone who marries someone of a different race or if two consenting adults decide to have sex? In this case at hand. Do you think someone should end up dying because they can’t get healthcare because of prejudice against the trans community?