3 ms·
I think his argument is more of the form 'people are trying to pass legislation to [explicitly] add these protections, therefore the existing legislation does n
by notahacker 6y ago
I think his argument is more of the form 'people are trying to pass legislation to [explicitly] add these protections, therefore the existing legislation does not afford these protections' than trying to derive any
principle from the current legislature's [un]willingness to pass it.
That argument has its limitations as legislation is often drafted intended to further clarify stuff which already exists (e.g. the Seventh Amendment affirmed a right to trial by jury already mentioned in the original constitution) but it's using the fact some legislators think the Bill is necessary to pass rather than the assumption some object to it to justify his interpretation of the existing law. Ultimately constitutional law is always the status quo, plus things the legislature or sometimes the judiciary are willing and able to follow the procedures to change, and not just in the United States)