3 ms·
Title VII prohibits employment discrimination against someone “because of” their “sex.” Supreme Court precedent holds that this phrase includes discriminating a
by rayiner 6y ago
Title VII prohibits employment discrimination against someone “because of” their “sex.” Supreme Court precedent holds that this phrase includes discriminating against someone for not conforming to sex stereotypes. For example, in Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins the Court held that it was Title VII discrimination to fire a woman because she had masculine behaviors. She wasn’t fired because she was a woman, but because she was a woman who did not conform to stereotypes and norms applicable to women.
In view of that precedent, Title VII can be seen to prohibit sexual orientation and sex discrimination. You can’t fire a man for failing to conform to the male norm of dating women. You likewise can’t fire someone whose sex is male, but whose gender identity is female (i.e. she does not conform to the gender expression expected of biological men).
- dahfizz 6y agoThat makes a ton of sense, the precedent about sex stereotypes was the missing piece for me. Thanks!
- thisiszilff 6y agoAlso, In the article I believe the reasoning is outlined that given you wouldn't fire a woman for dating a man, then firing a man for dating a man is discriminating on he basis of sex. The behavior alone isn't objectionable, it's only when sex comes into play that you start discriminating which cases are ok and which aren't.