11 ms·
A better title would be “Supreme Court holds that Title VII prohibits gay, transgender employment discrimination.” Titles like these make people think that the
by rayiner 6y ago
A better title would be “Supreme Court holds that Title VII prohibits gay, transgender employment discrimination.”
Titles like these make people think that the Supreme Court is “endorsing” or “rejecting” gay and transgender worker protections. But the difference between the majority and minority here wasn’t about “should we have a law protecting gay and transgender workers from employment discrimination?” It was “do we already have a law protecting gay and transgender workers from employment discrimination.” The majority, in an opinion authored by Justice Gorsuch—a dedicated textualist—said that such discrimination violates the 1964 Civil Rights Act’s prohibition on discrimination “because of sex.” I happen to agree, being in the camp that believes “the law says what it says, not want Congress wanted it to mean.” But it’s important to understand that the upshot of this decision is that “Congress, in 1964, already prohibited employment discrimination against gay and transgender people.” That’s a pretty remarkable outcome!
In one of the appellate decisions leading up to this, Judge Lynch of the Second Circuit dissented, agreeing with the positions that Alito, Kavanaugh, and Thomas would take, that Title VII does not protect gay and transgender workers. He’s an Obama appointee, born in Brooklyn. His take: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/15/us/gay-transgender-workers-supreme-court.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/15/us/gay-transgender-worker...
> “Speaking solely as a citizen,” he wrote, “I would be delighted to awake one morning and learn that Congress had just passed legislation adding sexual orientation to the list of grounds of employment discrimination prohibited under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. I am confident that one day — and I hope that day comes soon — I will have that pleasure.”
> “I would be equally pleased to awake to learn that Congress had secretly passed such legislation more than a half-century ago — until I actually woke up and realized that I must have been still asleep and dreaming,” Judge Lynch wrote. “Because we all know that Congress did no such thing.”
- js2 6y agoBased on the reasoning used by the dissent in this case, they would have similarly dissented in Loving v. Virginia.
- rayiner 6y agoThis is superficially true, but very different considerations applied in the two contexts. Loving was a 14th amendment case, while this was a statutory case. In statutory cases the Supreme Court is more deferential to what Congress intended to say, because Congress can easily change the statute if it wants to change the outcome. Moreover, in Loving there was the issue that marriage has long been considered one of the most fundamental rights in the Anglo-American tradition.
- scarface74 6y agoAnd the right to work and provide a living for yourself isn’t?
- tptacek 6y agoNo. We extensively regulate commerce.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 6y agoUntil this ruling passed, employers were legally allowed to discriminate against LGBTQ in many states because the “majority” elected officials that thought that was okay.
- tptacek 6y agoI'm not sure what that has to do with my point or anything upthread.
- kenjackson 6y agoThank you for clarifying. I haven’t read the opinion yet, but have read some of the lower court rulings. I really thought they might split on orientation vs transgender. Orientation does feel like the bigger leap logically. Curious, historically what typically has stronger lasting power — a Supreme Court ruling or a law enacted by Congress? I feel like it would be the Supreme Court because the personnel churns more slowly, but there’s probably data on this.
- cosmie 6y agoIt really depends. In this case, the Court interpreted an act of law enacted by Congress[1]. Congress has the authority to set statutory law as they see fit, and are fully within their rights to pass a bill that clarifies their intent, by either cementing the interpretation of the Court or by contradicting it. After which, that is the new law of the land, superseding the previous opinion of the court where it may have differed. It's different if the opinion were based on Constitutional grounds. Congress can rewrite laws they've passed as they see fit, potentially rendering Supreme Court rulings based on them moot in the process. They don't have the luxury of rewriting the Constitution though, so Court rulings based on Constitutional law have significantly more lasting power. Once the precedence of that opinion is set, the freedom of Congress to do what they want in that area becomes heavily constrained. They can still pass laws that contradict that opinion, but will likely end up with a fast track in front of the Supreme Court having to convince the Court on why their law shouldn't be stricken down as unconstitutional based on that prior precedence. [1] Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964
- dahfizz 6y ago> I happen to agree with Justice Gorsuch’s majority opinion (the existing law already covers such discrimination, in view of the text and existing judicial gloss on the text). Could you expand on this a bit? I'm genuinely asking. The article sums up the contention pretty well: > The legal fight focused on the definition of “sex” in Title VII. The plaintiffs, along with civil rights groups and many large companies, had argued that discriminating against gay and transgender workers was inherently based on their sex and consequently was illegal. At first glance, I think I agree with Judge Lynch. Its great that these protections extend to more people, but I think the argument is tenuous. A gay man and a straight man have the same sex, so discrimination against the gay man is not really based on sex, but on sexual orientation. And, as I understand it, the difference between sex and gender is very important to transgender people. Biological sex != the gender you identify as, that's why we say trans_gender_ and not trans_sex_ . How does a MTF trans person who has not undergone surgery / hormone treatment / sex change answer if asked what her sex is? Again, genuine question. I guess this is a "spirit of the law" situation, where "sex" doesn't just mean "sex", but all sex /gender/orientation/ groupings of people. Personally, I think it would have been ideal to amend the law and explicitly add gay / transgender people as a protected class. This avoids the possibility of another case in a few years overturning this one. But the current congress would never write such a law.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- defen 6y agoThe crux of the argument is: "Pretend that you could magically change a person to the opposite sex but leave everything else the same. If that changes your decision to fire the person, it's sex-based discrimination."
- rayiner 6y agoI don’t think that quite explains it—try applying that thought experiment to a man or woman fired for being bisexual. I think the Price Waterhouse precedent of conforming to sex-based norms is an indispensable part of the puzzle.
- jawns 6y ago> Titles like these make people think that the Supreme Court is “endorsing” or “rejecting” gay and transgender worker protections. As one of the dissents pointed out, when the liberal wing of the Supreme Court just happens (time and again) to interpret a statute in a way that advances liberal ideological objectives, and the conservative wing just happens (time and again) to interpret a statute in a way that advances conservative ideological objectives, it is not unreasonable for the general public to assume that the Court is indeed endorsing or rejecting based on ideology, rather than interpreting the law. Here's an interesting analysis of how and when ideology comes into play: https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/supreme-court-justices-become-less-impartial-and-more-ideological-when-casting-the-swing-vote https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/supreme-cou...
- sterlind 6y agoAh, but Gorsuch is not liberal - at least, he was installed by the Republicans, and looked up to Scalia a lot, and was proposed by the Federalist Society. That's what makes this decision such a welcome surprise to me. Maybe textualism isn't a lie.
- jawns 6y agoThat's quite true, although not totally invalidating my point, because the terms "liberal" and "conservative" as they apply to the Supreme Court tend to be too one-dimensional. Gorsuch and Roberts are definitely conservatives in some respects, but when it comes to social issues, they're more moderate/libertarian, in the vein of Anthony Kennedy. In fact, if you look at all of Roberts' opinions on social issues, outside of maybe abortion stuff, it's a little surprising that Roberts did not join in with Obergefell. Given that he _did_ dissent from Obergefell, it's also a little surprising he didn't dissent in Bostock. His rationale in Obergefell was that regardless of what he would like the law to say, he did not find that it said what the majority wanted it to say. That's essentially what Kavanaugh said in his dissent today. And to the extent that both cases could be characterized as determining that a right has been hidden in plain sight this whole time, I'm not really sure why Roberts went one way with Obergefell and the other way with Bostock.
- bhupy 6y agoIMO I find Alito's argument interesting, but dubious: > Last year, the House of Representatives passed a bill that would amend Title VII by defining sex discrimination to include both “sexual orientation” and “gender identity,” H. R. 5, 116th Cong., 1st Sess. (2019), but the bill has stalled in the Senate. An alternative bill, H. R. 5331, 116th Cong., 1st Sess. (2019), would add similar prohibitions but contains provisions to protect religious liberty.3 This bill remains before a House Subcommittee. > Because no such amendment of Title VII has been enacted in accordance with the requirements in the Constitution (passage in both Houses and presentment to the President, Art. I, §7, cl. 2), Title VII’s prohibition of discrimination because of “sex” still means what it has always meant. Unless I'm missing something, I can't see how this principle can be consistently applied since there are so many laws that have been passed, that may not pass if the current iteration of the Legislative branch were to vote on it, eg. First & Second Amendments (as is), New Deal, etc. It seems like a more roundabout way of saying that the US has strong status quo biases baked into its system, but that's about it. IANAL, so shrug. EDIT: I'm not sure why this is getting downvoted, I'm making an argument affirming the majority decision and attacking the logic of the dissenting opinion.
- rayiner 6y agoAlito’s argument is basically: Title VII can’t already confer these protections, or else Congress wouldn’t be trying to enact them.
- bhupy 6y agoRight, but it's hard for me to see how that argument proves anything since it ignores the slow and deliberate nature of judicial review and how events can occur out-of-order. A policy opportunist would try to simultaneously appeal a law through the appellate court system while also trying to circumvent that process through the legislature. If the appeal were to eventually pass judicial review before Congress were to finally enact the clarification of the law itself, does that render the judicial opinion inaccurate? Put another way: if Congress had tried (and failed) to pass a law that clarifies the interpretation of the First Amendment per Citizens United before the Citizens United decision happened, does that make CU any less "correct"?
- oldsklgdfth 6y agoYou seem pretty well read on SCOTUS. A while back I listened to a podcast called 'First Mondays', that was very insightful. It not longer airs. What resources do you use to follow SCOTUS? other than reading the decisions.
- basch 6y agohttps://www.scotusblog.com/ https://www.scotusblog.com/
- dang 6y ago> A better title would be “Supreme Court holds that Title VII prohibits gay, transgender employment discrimination.” If someone wants to suggest a better (more accurate and neutral) title that fits in 80 chars, we can change it above. We can't use the phrase "gay, transgender employment discrimination", though, because someone will complain that it's an ambiguous noun phrase.
- rayiner 6y agoSorry, I didn’t mean the HN title, since that reflects the Reuter’s title. I was taking a dig at Reuter’s.
- dang 6y agoOh no, that was totally clear. But we always try to change misleading titles—indeed the guidelines say to (as you know): https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- nojito 6y agoTextualism is a meaningless distinction. Back in the Lockner era, textualists did nothing but legislate from the bench. Which lead to the switch in time to save nine.