4 ms·
It's possible today but not economically practical. You could get low-latency messages, but you would miss most of the bits coming through.
by whatshisface 6y ago
It's possible today but not economically practical. You could get low-latency messages, but you would miss most of the bits coming through.
- Ciantic 6y agoInteresting, care to elaborate more? I haven't found that it's even possible with long distances like that. If corporates are literally blowing holes to mountains to get faster and more direct data links between trading places. Then it sounds like just a question of time when the technology matures enough (if it's possible already).
- Evidlo 6y agoHere's an article about communicating with neutrino beams: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/message-encoded-in-neutrino-beam-transmitted-through-solid-rock/#:~:text=Neutrinos%20are%20having%20a%20moment.&text=Neutrinos%20have%20been%20proposed%20for,screen%20out%20most%20other%20particles https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/message-en.... In short, they were able to achieve about 0.1 bps with hardware that costs hundreds of millions of dollars.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoAlso note that the distance transmitted is a mere kilometer. Carrier pigeons are more practical
- est31 6y agoThat's only two orders of magnitude away from a 100bps line, which would incur 10 ms latency due to the transmission method (in addition to the latency of the neutrinos actually having to get there), and that's for reliable communication. Unreliable communication that gives you an advantage over mere chance 1% of the time can already be advantageous, you'll be right 51% of the time.
- afthonos 6y agoThat image was captured over 503 days of exposure, with a detector the size of a swimming pool. I won’t claim it’s impossible, but I’ll give you fantastic odds against it in the next, say, twenty years.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoBlowing holes in miuntains is junior league for nuclear physics. The exact same factor that allows neutrinos to pass through a planet make them impossible to work with. The detector here weighs 50,000,000kg, and still like 99.9..% of neutrinos pass though it without being detected - imagine that kind of signal loss in a data link. This detector does not notice tiny amount of neutrinos produced at particle accelerators. It would have to placed right next to a 4GW nuclear powerplant to detect neurinos at any kind of reasonable rate. The only man made source of neutrinos you could detect from another continent is a massive thermonuclear blast. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2405601415010494 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S240560141...
- prawn 6y ago"The only man made source of neutrinos you could detect from another continent is a massive thermonuclear blast." So, you're saying there's a chance?
- cryptonector 6y agoAll you need is one bit: silence -> neutral!, 0 -> buy!, 1 -> sell! Or two: 00 -> neutral!, 01 -> sell!, 02 -> buy!, 11 -> wait! Plus error correction... When you add error correction and consider the number of missed bits and the need to retransmit / keep transmitting, it's probably not possible to realize a latency win here.
- close04 6y agoThink about it like this: the absolute vast majority of neutrinos pass through the whole planet without interacting with a single particle. One descriptive saying is that a neutrino can pass through 100 light-years of steel without interacting. This puts in context how hard it is to detect them (have them interact with your detector). So your communication turns into some random string of detections where you never know if the absence of a detection means there was no neutrino, or it was just missed.
- mhh__ 6y ago> latency win Perhaps, but if you consider the probability of missing an individual neutrino your error correcting scheme will have to be either very long or very clever because your odds of collecting the right neutrino at the right time will go down very quickly as the packet gets longer. On top of that, if you used some kind of pulse scheme (i.e. morse code with neutrinos) it has to be slow enough to be detectable, but fast enough to beat the latency of a cable (let's say 100ms - speed of light + processing and errors) and also fast enough not to use enough power as to be unprofitable.
- cryptonector 6y ago> Perhaps, but ... Isn't that what I wrote: > > it's probably not possible to realize a latency win here ? > On top of that, if you used some kind of pulse scheme (i.e. morse code with neutrinos) it has to be slow "slow pulse" == long pulse. It will be "fast" in that it will go faster than the speed of light in fiberoptics and the path will be shorter, but it will be slower because error correction will demand a great deal of redundancy which, among other things, means long pulses. I think we're in agreement.