7 ms·
A thousand times no. Just like a stock market is undermined by insider trading, so insurance markets are undermined by fraud. Insider trading and fraud don't m
by crazygringo 6y ago
A thousand times no.
Just like a stock market is undermined by insider trading, so insurance markets are undermined by fraud. Insider trading and fraud don't mean stocks or policies are mispriced. Insider trading and fraud are breaking the social contract of what the products are meant for, which is why they're illegal.
The article quotes:
> "she was able to receive relevant information beforehand that tells her if the flight was going to be delayed or cancelled."
Which sounds exactly like the insurance equivalent of insider trading. Buying insurance on something you already know is going to happen or not is fraud, plain and simple.
The insurance company had loopholes too, but the loophole that prevented the company from finding out sooner was that she got payment from the airlines directly, rather than the insurance company. That's not mispricing. She was arrested because she committed insurance fraud, plain and simple.
- ytdytvhxgydvhh 6y ago> Buying insurance on something you already know is going to happen or not is fraud, plain and simple. I don’t think that’s quite the right definition. I know I’m going to die. I bought whole life insurance. I have not committed fraud.
- mdpye 6y agoThere's actually a different term for that - assurance is to compensate for things which are known will happen (e.g. you will die, at some point), insurance is for things which you don't (you will die during the finite term of the policy). So technically you bought life assurance. Perhaps consumer products are playing fast and loose with the technical terms because everyone says they want "insurance".
- derefr 6y agoIs there a third term for something like "flood insurance", where there will definitely be a flood at some point—you're building on a floodplain—but not necessarily one within the lifetime of the policy, such that in theory profit can be made off of e.g. business that open, get insured, operate for years, and then close, without the flooding ever happening. ...but where there is a legal requirement for everyone in the area to "get insured" so that they don't have to lean on FEMA, and therefore in practice there's the opposite effect to the distribution of risk under public healthcare: rather than forcing healthy people who will get negligible benefit from their policies to get insured, such a requirement forces the insurance company to not be playing the lottery by offering only short-term policies that can maybe avoid a flood, but instead fixes them into always ending up covering a resulting flood (and therefore almost always defaulting in such cases and needing reinsurance coverage.)
- kemitche 6y agoException that proves the rule, there. The insurance company knows you'll die too.
- mxscho 6y agoNo. You don't know, that you'll die before the average time on which people die that was used to calculate the insurance fees.
- oceanswave 6y agoSo it’s more like gambling then, but if you beat the house, that’s fraud
- saxonww 6y agoIn this case, the better analogy would be beating the house by exploiting a flaw in slot machines that you knew about because you used to work for the manufacturer.
- codingdave 6y agoThat isn't how whole life insurance works. You are thinking of term life insurance. Whole life is basically an investment package that invests your premiums and pays out to your beneficiaries upon death.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jiveturkey 6y ago> Buying insurance on something you already know is going to happen or not is fraud, plain and simple. what's the statute, or regulation, please. i'm not aware of that.
- jandrese 6y agoIsn't that the definition of insurance fraud?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- freeone3000 6y agoNo, that would require making false statements or false assurances, neglecting to disclose information when asked, or stating something happened when it didn't. Buying flood insurance when you know it's going to rain isn't fraud.
- gdhbcc 6y agoNo, you're not making a false claim (the flights did get delayed) nor did you cause the claim in the first place (you didn't cause the delay to the flight). I fail to see how this is in any way fraudulent.
- drdec 6y agoWe'd better all cancel our life insurance in that case.
- smolder 6y agoInsurance companies don't exactly respect their social contract when refusing to pay out legitimate claims on technicalities. She was arrested because she angered a wealthy institution, not because she did wrong by a virtuous one.
- mxscho 6y agoSo you're saying as long as someone else did something illegal I am free to rip him off whenever I want to? Wtf?
- DoctorOW 6y agoPretty clearly saying that if it was the other way around, an insurance company defrauding customers for the same amount, nobody would be going to jail.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoYeah. Isn't this almost literally what Goldman did during the financial crisis. Seems like what is counts as a financial crime or fraud has a lot to do with how much purchase you have with your respective countries powerful and wealthy.
- pgwhalen 6y agoIn what sense did Goldman Sachs do something similar during the crisis?
- DubiousPusher 6y agoTrading derivatives which are essentially a form of insurance on assets they had plenty of inside dope to know where rotten.
- jedimastert 6y agoThat still doesn't make it morally or legally right. An inequity? Yes. Relevant to this discussion?
- joshuaissac 6y ago>Which sounds exactly like the insurance equivalent of insider trading. Only if the information she was using was non-public, e.g. if she were getting information from former colleagues, or had access to such data herself that a normal person would not have. Otherwise, it is not comparable to insider trading.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- narrator 6y agoThe difference between insurance and gambling is insurance is when the event that triggers the insurance is something one doesn't want to happen. In this case, she was indifferent to the outcome, so it was essentially just gambling.
- efsavage 6y ago> Buying insurance on something you already know is going to happen or not is fraud, plain and simple. Is it though? Isn't this just arbitrage based on asymmetrical information (i.e. exactly what insurance companies do)? If she caused the flight to be delayed somehow, that would certainly be fraud, but so would anything the insurance company did to make the delay less likely without adjusting premiums.
- Voloskaya 6y ago> Is it though? She had to use 20 different identities do to this. That should answer your question.
- throwawaygh 6y agoThat doesn't really answer the original question at all. The question wasn't "is this particular case fraudulent for any reason what-so-ever". The question was "is buying insurance on something you already know is going to happen" plain and simple fraud? The identity fraud isn't really relevant to that question at all. FWIW I'm not aware of any law in the USA that makes it illegal to buy insurance when you know the policy will pay. Knowing more than the insurance company's actuaries is not fraud. Making false statements is fraud. Intentionally causing damage to collect insurance payments is fraud. But the hypothetical oracle who knows when the next flood/fire/car accident will hit due to divine inspiration is free to buy a relevant insurance policy the day before. AFAIK.
- smithza 6y agoNovemberwhiskey (above) makes the solid point about entering into the contract in good faith. It is a sound counterpoint and appeals to the more important "spirit of the law" vs "letter of the law". I am not sure how this would stand up to a court ruling.
- throwawaygh 6y agoI don't think uberrima fides is super helpful here: a) I have a really, really, REALLY hard time understanding how hiring an army of PhDs to build highly proprietary risk models based on extremely expensive (or not-even-for-sale) datasets does not run a foul of uberrima fides. The doctrine only makes sense if it forbids both parties, not just the insured, from concealing information. If I were on a jury and the entire case hung on a reasonable man's interpretation of uberrima fides, I would have a hard time ever finding in favor of a modern insurer who's unwilling to share their models and data with the world. I mean, I might agree that the insured hid information. But I'd be nearly 100% confident that the insurer hid information. Maybe in 1766 this principle made sense. It aint 1766 anymore. b) In this case specifically, it would be quite hard to convince me that using publicly available information (e.g., weather reports and history of on time / delayed / cancelled flights) runs a foul of uberrima fides. You can't honestly expect me to believe the insurance company didn't have access to that information. It's equally hard for me to believe that an army of PhD actuaries didn't think to use that information to build their pricing models. c) In the case of travel insurance, the doctrine has a really big bright-line problem. When I buy any ticket into or out of Boston during the winter months, I tend to buy travel insurance. I never buy travel insurance for flights into or out of Boston in the summer. That is clearly not fraud (or, if it is, that insurance product needs to be regulated out of existence). Now, what if I choose particular weeks? days? Where's the bright line? d) Even supposing some obligation to share information, how in God's name am I supposed to inform the insurer that I estimate a flight will be almost surely be cancelled/delayed? Call up the 1-800 number? Because I know exactly how that would go: you'd get a first-line support person who's incentivized to sell policies. If I were running a similar scheme, I would definitely record myself calling up the insurance provider and point-blank stating "I think this flight will be cancelled, should I buy your insurance?" I guarantee the answer from the T1 support folks would be "yes, that's what it's for!". It seems totally unreasonable to assume bad faith of anyone who buys an insurance product with large positive expected value, especially when the insurance company is consistently making 10 figures in net income and is unwilling to engage in individual dialogs about "who knows what and when". If I can't get on the phone and talk to the actuary who built the pricing model to figure out if X is shared information, and if there's no list of check-boxes for me to look through in order to determine the same, and if the only company representative I can get access to is probably going to explicitly tell me to buy the policy, then... what the hell? All of these things taken together: if I were on a jury and uberrima fides was the only reason to find in favor of the insurer, I would certainly do everything I could to sway my fellow jurors toward favoring the insured. It seems like the right solution here is either a) more sophisticated pricing models, or b) some very clear and well-dilineated bounds on what information is/is not allowed to be used when purchasing travel insurance. TL;DR: uberrima fides as a fuzzy legal doctrine seems... just... utterly impossible to apply to consumers. The relationship is fundamentally asymmetric, so the insurer should have a burden to explicitly ask about any relevant information (as is done for, e.g., health and life products). As a fuzzy doctrine for deciding on a case-by-case basis, this doctrine seems more relevant when the insurer and insured are more symmetric (e.g., insurance products aimed at large corporations, reinsurance, etc.). (Of course identity fraud is a problem and this happened in China which doesn't use the same legal system, so this is all just a hypothetical conversation.)
- air7 6y agoOT but I never understood the issue with insider trading. Obviously it's unfair to unknowing traders but isn't this essentially just making the market more reflective of reality? How does it undermine the market?
- sukilot 6y agoThat is the main argument in favor of insider trading. But why would I ever invest in a company if I knew that my gains would be stolen by people with secret knowledge? If you allow insider trading, then you eliminate the incentive for outsider investing And that means that we don't have public companies, only private companies.
- derefr 6y ago"Eliminating the incentive for outsider trading" is one way to think of it. Another way to think of it is that it creates an incentive for corporate espionage, so that outsiders may gain insider information. In a world where corporate espionage is not itself illegal, the market would then be composed of private companies plus external "auditors" who are slipped in by all interested shareholders whether the private companies like it or not. ...which is oddly similar to governments performing intelligence on allies.
- diydsp 6y agoimagine an insider knows a product is going to tank, so she sells all of her shares before everyone else. at that point of sale, the reality is the product sucks. but the market still reflects the price of a good product. so they know reality before everyone else, keep everyone else in fantasy, and trade at the fantasy price. it further undermines the market bc no one will invest in companies who bail out with at the high price and leave them holding the bag. e.g. if someone asked me to buy 1k shares @ $100 each and i buy them: the product is a dud in R&D. the insiders all sell near the $100 price, the product is a dud in the market, share prices tanks to $30. Next my "friend" asks me to invest I tell him to pound sand.
- skybrian 6y agoMatt Levine writes about this sometimes: > In insider trading, famously, nobody quite knows what “legal” means. There is no statute defining or prohibiting insider trading, and the Securities and Exchange Commission rules on it are slim. But there are some judicially created rules that more or less make sense, that focus, roughly speaking, on whether insiders are using someone else’s information for their own gain. (A question that has nothing to do with market fairness, by the way.) But those rules are hazy and much disputed, and they aren’t written down in one place. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-10-15/insider-trading-isn-t-so-simple https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-10-15/inside... When a company employee is told something that's a secret and they trade on it or tell someone else then that's betraying that trust. If someone outside the firm figures it out, say from satellite photos or something like that, then it's not.
- SilasX 6y ago>Which sounds exactly like the insurance equivalent of insider trading. Buying insurance on something you already know is going to happen or not is fraud, plain and simple. Well, from the description of the events, it sounds like she didn't "know" the events were happen, just that they were more likely in a way that's not captured with a sufficient premium. That's not the same as e.g. insuring against your car getting dented, knowing you plan to dent it. So what she did was more analogous to reasoning that, "Oh, man, people always seem to rear-end you when you're driving a red sports car. Since I drive one, I guess I'll pay extra for the no-deductible option for accidents involving getting rear-ended." She doesn't know she'll be one to get rear-ended, she didn't cause the rear-ending, she just recognizes it as being super-likely and thus a good deal. With that said, I think there is a sense in which this is fraud. Generally, insurance requires you to have an "insurable interest" -- i.e. independent reason to value the insured thing -- to prevent the kind of asymmetric info/moral hazard situation that breaks their ability to model the risk and which leads to cases like this. So the contract almost certainly had a clause like, "I am going on this flight for business or pleasure reasons" (or something more lawyer-screened). That would establish the insurable interest: the insured wants to go on this trip, and wants it to go well. So she'd be entering the contract on fraudulent terms if she bought the trips/insurance solely to profit off the payouts. Still, I have to agree with the OP's comment. If someone is this good at assessing risk, you should hire them to tune your risk model. She did pretty darn good with far less info than the insurer had to work with!
- smithza 6y ago> With that said, I think there is a sense in which this is fraud. I don't think that is a strong enough statement. She used multiple identities in attempt to keep police off of her trail. The analogy to the red sports car is helpful but lacking in this obviously nefarious effort in its innocence.
- mcphage 6y ago> She used multiple identities in attempt to keep police off of her trail. If you do well enough at a Casino, they can ask you to leave, and ban you from the premises, even if you're not doing anything illegal.
- fulldecent2 6y ago> "insurance equivalent of insider trading" Do you have a citation for that law? --- Yes, weather matters, and people can benefit by predicting it.
- atleta 6y agoWasn't the problem here that the insurance company didn't know these facts as opposed to she knowing them? While it sounds like insider trading, the situation here is quite a bit different. With insider trading, the company has very real and legitimate interest to keep some information private. Private from the general public, including their competition. In this case, however, the airlines wouldn't have to share this info, apparently known inside the organization, with the general public, but with a single (set of) well defined actor(s). Also, I'm not 100% sure if publishing all the available information on possible delays and cancellations wouldn't benefit their business. (Though, if cancellations happen because of say not enough tickets sold for a flight, it may, because maybe that would induce a self-reinforcing process. Who would want to buy a ticket that is likely to be cancelled?)
- dbatten 6y agoUnfortunately, this article leaves the exact nature of information she was relying on vague/confusing. > "she was able to receive relevant information beforehand that tells her if the flight was going to be delayed or cancelled. Thereafter, she would purchase the tickets to the flights that are likely to be delayed or cancelled, before checking if there is any extreme weather along the route the flight is going to take that day." Specifically, I'm not sure what the "before checking for extreme weather along the route" bit is supposed to mean, especially since it seems to imply that she checked for extreme weather after she already purchased the insurance? Something is odd with the grammar here. Furthermore, the quote never specifies what the "relevant information" actually was. So... does this mean that she received inside information (e.g., from a former coworker) that the flight had been cancelled? Or does it mean that she was looking at publicly-available information (e.g., weather data) to make the call? I think the ethics and usefulness of some aspect of this are dependent on the answer to that question, and I'm not sure the article says definitively one way or another. With that being said, I think the ethical problems with the fake identities seem more clear...
- ellisv 6y agoI agree. Google Flights will warn you if a flight is often delayed -- does that count as "receiv(ing) relevant information beforehand"?
- ohyes 6y ago> before checking if there is any extreme weather along the route the flight is going to take that day. The travel insurance wouldn't pay out if the flight was cancelled due to weather that was already known about.
- jpollock 6y agoRelevant information could have been a weather report. If the pricing on insurance isn't dynamic, and gets within the weather window, you can use a 3-day prediction to place a high-likelihood bet that the flight will be cancelled. Particularly if the insurance sticks with the ticket such that it can be moved if unused. 1. See a bad storm coming in. 2. Buy a fully refundable ticket for the day the storm is going to hit. 3. Buy insurance on that ticket. 4. Storm hits? Cash in. 5. Storm doesn't hit? Change the date on the ticket and the insurance moves with it.
- empath75 6y agoI don't think there's enough information in the article to determine that she committed fraud. What was the nature of the inside information, exactly?
- FireBeyond 6y ago> Buying insurance on something you already know is going to happen or not is fraud, plain and simple. Better cancel all life insurance policies then. Buying insurance on something you're going to cause to happen (cut down a tree so it falls on your car, leave flammable substances in a hazardous place in your home) is fraud. Buying insurance on things you think are likely to happen isn't inherently fraud.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoYou don't know it's going to happen. Life insurance is about when you die, not if you die. Or else it's a tax scheme where you only profit based on the tax-free nature of life insurance proceeds.
- smabie 6y agoinsider trading is about theft, not about social contracts or whatever. It means that someone stole information that I could trade on. Since it's stolen from me, they can't trade on it. That's what makes it illegal. It's similar to intellectual property, in a way