4 ms·
This article completely misses the point. Instead of citing outlying cases, maybe it should have dealt with the elephant in the living room: Vietnam College
by edw519 18y ago
This article completely misses the point. Instead of citing outlying cases, maybe it should have dealt with the elephant in the living room:
Vietnam
College students in the 60's weren't "playing politics". They were protesting an illegal, immoral, and unwinnable war. Hell, half the men on campus were there so they wouldn't have to go to Vietnam.
I imagine today's generation of professors would feel a little differently if TV news showed maimed soldiers in Iraq every night, their classes were full of young men who didn't want to be drafted, and their campuses were occupied by armed National Guardsmen who shot unarmed students.
[Prediction: This will be voted up by those who actually experienced the absurdity of the 60's and voted down by those who can't imagine it could have been that bad. Since the average age in this community is probably below 40, this post will end up negative.]
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoProfessors have always been more liberal and left-leaning than the general population. This goes back further than a hundred years in my reckoning. For instance in the 20s and 30s there was a large percentage of academics who thought communism was the best choice for western civilization. Vietnam has little to do with it. Interesting (to me) is the tendency for left-leaning progressives to continue to live and fight battles from the past. The recent Iraq war has caused some to try to replay Vietnam. The coming nomination of Obama is very JFK-ish. We're having a very 60-ish discussion on how man is immoral in his treatment of the environment. I always thought the conservatives were the ones who lived in the past, but I think that has changed over the last five years or so. My opinion only. Do not operate heavy machinery after reading this comment.
- edw519 18y agoVietnam affected everything in the 60's. The only popular media (TV news) was broadcast from there every night. It changed popular culture, economics, and politics. And it spilled over onto college campuses, the only refuge for young men 18 to 21 who didn't want to go to Vietnam or Canada. This was the environment that produced today's retiring generation of professors cited by OP, which never even mentioned Vietnam. Vietnam and Iraq have little in common stateside by design. Today's political leaders weren't about to make the same mistake twice. So no TV news and no draft. Amazing how well it's worked, huh?
- yummyfajitas 18y agoI don't think it's so much a left-progressive thing as a baby boomer thing. They are about to retire, and want to relive their glory days. As I recall, it was primarily baby boomers describing Iraq as "another Vietnam!!!" 2 weeks into the invasion. "We haven't won yet? It's a quagmire!" Oddly, when comparing Obama to JFK, they never seem to remember that JFK stole an election, fought one war incompetently and started another one that turned into a quagmire ("the original Vietnam!!!"). JFK does compare reasonably well to a contemporary politician, but not Obama...
- davidw 18y ago> This goes back further than a hundred years in my reckoning. Galileo apparently said that some of his best years were those at the University of Padova: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_Padua#History http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_Padua#History ... which, as the article says, had more freedom and less influence from the Catholic church. However: this strikes me as not really being hacker news. (PS, check out this guy, who came out of Padova: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federico_Faggin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federico_Faggin )
- xlnt 18y agoAre you really denying that your view on Vietname is a political position, on the basis that you think you're right really strongly?
- edw519 18y agoNot at all. I'm just questioning the veracity of an article from a supposedly credible source that makes conclusions based upon outlying cases while completely ignoring the central issue. I offer no personal view of Vietnam. I'm just saying that it was the central issue affecting the breeding ground of the subjects of the article.
- xlnt 18y agoYou say "I offer no personal view of Vietnam." but you said it was an "illegal, immoral, and unwinnable war" Are you really unaware that people disagree on all 3 of those points? They are political positions.
- edw519 18y agoThat was the argument of the protesters, not mine. Sorry. If only I could write prose as well as I could code. :-)
- hugh 18y agoAh, well all you need is a "what they saw as". And for the most part, I don't think any of those other points was nearly as important as the draft. It's one thing to think that a current war is a bad idea, it's quite another to know that you might be forced to go and fight in it.
- xlnt 18y agoIf that was their argument, and it's a political argument, then they were "playing politics". That's all.
- 18y ago
- jfornear 18y agoI agree. Iraq is no Vietnam. Iraq doesn't affect anyone in the US except for the volunteer military made up of mostly people who are more than happy to be there, so the harsh reality is that no one cares. I know if you asked the students at my campus if America was at war, they would probably give you a funny look before continuing on to their frat party. This doesn't mean they are stupid or apathetic to politics in general, but only that nothing is threatening their way of life right now. People participate in politics for selfish reasons. I would say it's a good thing that college students aren't erupting into protests every day. That means they must be content and happy, right?
- noonespecial 18y agoIraq doesn't affect anyone in the US except for the volunteer military made up of mostly people who are more than happy to be there,.. Because there's nothing quite like 2 back to back extended tours in third-world hell while they foreclose on your house back home and kick your wife and 3 year old out on the street to put a smile on your face and a song in your heart. Sheesh.
- jfornear 18y agoEmphasis on mostly. I'm just speaking from my personal experience with friends who are marines that describe the Battle of Fallujah as the best video game ever. Don't get me wrong, I respect those who serve in the military. I could never do what you do.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]