6 ms·
“However, densely packed active devices with minimum safety margins are required to realize advanced functionality requirements. This makes them more susceptibl
by Animats 6y ago
“However, densely packed active devices with minimum safety margins are required to realize advanced functionality requirements. This makes them more susceptible to reliability issues caused by self-heating and increasing field strengths."
We're going to have very short-lived electronics.
The Ford EEC IV engine control unit from the mid-1980s was designed for a 30 year lifespan. Which it delivered. Can the industry even make 30-year parts any more?
For automotive, a key issue may be to turn stuff off. All the way off. Vehicle lifespans are only around 6,000 hours of on time. But too much vehicle electronics runs even when the vehicle is off.
- remotists 6y agoShorter-lifespans mean more frequent sales. Phones used to last 6 years now they they are made and branded to be used for less than 2 years.
- m12k 6y agoThis seems to be a fundamental economics issue: Things are only valued when they are sold. It's much more profitable for companies to sell me the same thing over and over again every couple years, than to sell me something repairable that will last for decades. Most measures, like GDP, don't capture the inefficiency of this, because they don't capture the value of the things in my house that don't need to be replaced, they only capture the value of the new stuff I buy when the old crap breaks. I think this has many detrimental side effects: There's the opportunity cost, because the money I spend on planned obsolescence could have been spent on other products that added more value for me and the world. It wastes natural resources with more stuff ending up in landfills and CO2 ending up in the atmosphere to manufacture and ship the replacements. And finally it helps reinforce the need to work stressful jobs to have enough money to keep buying these things that keep breaking - it's harder to have 'enough' money. How do we as a society encourage products that last?
- kwhitefoot 6y ago> How do we as a society encourage products that last? People are attracted to novelty. While you and I might value the old and functional things that we have and use everyday there is a substantial number of people who will get rid of things like toasters, food mixers, etc., simply because they don't match the colour scheme of the kitchen; the suppliers only care about those people, not us because we don't make any money for them. If you want products that last you will somehow have to moderate the human desire for novelty. I think that this could be done but it would mean dismantling our educational systems and replacing them with education in the old fashioned sense of producing people who can think and analyse, people who have a sense of history and an understanding of how the world came to be the way it is. But what use are such people to a society based on, not merely conspicuous, but also excessive consumption?
- noir_lord 6y agoInteresting that you got down voted this. FWIW I think you are right, we are trained and raised by society to buy and buy all the time. I know people who think I'm odd for having a Nokia 6 which is nearing 3 years old (but has current Android) and no intention of replacing it - it's partially the circles I move in via work but everyone earns decent money and replaces their phone every year when the new models come out. More generally I don't replace something unless it's uneconomic to repair, I'm rocking my 2012 road bike, I just stripped and rebuilt it for about 50 quid - I've friends who buy a new one every 18mths. I like fixing things maybe that is the difference.
- clarry 6y agoI don't think people are as attracted to novelty as you think. Sure, everyone has a gadget (or garment) or three that they buy just for novelty, but the vast majority of household items and appliances are bought just to fulfill their purpose. And they won't get replaced unless they break, deteriorate, or reveal design flaws or something else that makes them unfit for the purpose. What most people do care about is price. And what most suppliers care about is.. yeah, it's a race to the bottom. I would assume that people would also care about quality and durability if it were something they were informed about. Like, if you're buying a toaster, one sells for $30 and the label says that will break in two years.. the other sells for $40 and the label says it will last for five years or more. I'm pretty sure most people would pick the latter, unless they're exceptionally poor or there's some other major aspect of the design or functionality that draws them to the cheaper option. Of course, this is not the world we live in, and toasters in $25 to $100 range can last a while or not. Quality or durability is not on the label, and price is not an indication of quality. The trend seems to be that lots of "race to the bottom" companies fill their lineup with premium priced products that are made of the same crap quality as their bottom tier, but they have some silly gimmick (bluetooth in a toothbrush? goodness gracious).
- Angostura 6y ago> now they they are made and branded to be used for less than 2 years. Happily using a 5 year old iPhone, which is still receiving software updates, Just because companies release new phones doesn;t make your old one obsolete.
- jacquesm 6y agoYou don't actually have to play that game. I'm still using a dumb phone and perfectly happy with it. Doesn't distract as much as a smartphone and much better battery life.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoPhones never really lasted 6 years. A phone being unusable after a few years is usually a matter of battery wearing out combined with super slow and bloated apps and web pages.
- tails4e 6y agoWe make ICs and target 20 year lifespan. A lot of cost and over-design goes into achieving that MTBF, especially if a device only had a typical usable lifespan much shorter. ECU should be 30 years, but a GPU, probably not. Will you be gaming on a 30 year old card?
- achairapart 6y agoProbably not, but for history purposes it would be a pity.
- simion314 6y agoIt would suck if you own a special console/electronic device and it just expires. The number of people affected is not large but still it will suck. Also this days TVs and other electronics have some computer inside and this "expiration" would affect second hand market and increase the e-wate more.
- isoprophlex 6y agoAgree completely, but we are already entering a market of rapidly expiring products and 'e waste as business model' See: DRM'ed water filters, iot devices dying when their companies shut down, mountains of unusable electric scooters left over when a startup folds.
- swinglock 6y agoThis is the time ramp up waste, we must exit that market instead, by law if necessary.
- jack_pp 6y agoDoesn't it expire from use? If you care that much about preserving history, buy one and don't use it for 30 years LE: although considering most stuff built today wouldn't work without an internet connection the problem isn't just hardware expiring
- 6y ago
- zrm 6y agoThis clearly spells the beginning of the end for transistor scaling. If every node makes the reliability worse, eventually the lifetime gets too short and you're through. The interesting question is going to be how much faster the unreliable parts are than the more reliable nodes once we're at the limit. If they're only 30% faster then in many cases that's a small price to pay for reliability. If they're 30 times faster then what you want is an increase in modularity and standardization, so that the chip that wears out every year can be a cheap fungible commodity part that you can replace without having to buy a new chassis, screen or battery.
- tomxor 6y ago>This clearly spells the beginning of the end for transistor scaling. If every node makes the reliability worse, eventually the lifetime gets too short and you're through. Transistor scaling (dennard scaling) already ended over a decade ago. Even up to that point there have been a variety of reliability challenges at each shrink, some revisited again and again requiring different techniques at each level. We haven't been making significant progress over the last decade in terms of process size, instead we're just shuffling towards the edge of a cliff (single atoms), the closer we get the more extreme the challenges will get with less return. We don't have a long road ahead with gradually decreasing reliability, we are already at the end of the road, we aren't going to get much closer to the crumbly bits if it's not worth it.
- CyberDildonics 6y ago10 years ago 32nm was at the cutting edge. Transistor counts have risen by around 9x in that time frame.
- tomxor 6y agoTransistor count is the wrong metric because we've been increasing die area as well as shrinking process nodes... It's not sustainable to keep increasing die areas, so it's not a pivot for moores law.
- me_me_me 6y ago> Can the industry even make 30-year parts any more? Absolutely. Will they make it, absolutely not. Planned obsolescence is not a conspiracy theory, its a widely popular business strategy. Spare part business is a additional revenue stream for car manufactures. They fought hard and dirty trying to monopolize it, via lobbing harmful to public laws.
- jug 6y agoThe short-lived electronics could be passable for the manufacturers if it was just about that (hey, obsolescence with plausible deniability for free!) But I think their real problem will be that this will cause even more chips to be discarded during quality assurance and this rate will bleed into electronic prices. If we'd be looking at 20% or 30% more expensive electronics _beyond_ the pricings warranted by performance improvements themselves (otherwise eating into their profit margins from R&D costs etc), will consumers keep purchasing these without batting an eye? But a sense of scales is also necessary here. If a modern CPU lasts for 15 years and this might be a reduction to 8-10 years, I think many will swallow that. If we're however talking reducing lifespans from 10 years to four, well then we are going to see complaints.
- rcxdude 6y agoThe microcontrollers in an ECU are built on far, far different processes to modern CPUs and GPUs. Microcontrollers are usually >90nm, and if designing for robustness probably a lot larger than that. These processes are optimised for many different things, but speed is usually lower on the list than cost, power consumption, and even lifetime (which the automotive industry are still extremely keen on). And given the strong (generally exponential) dependence such aging processes have on temperature, time spent in a low power mode while the engine isn't running as opposed to off is basically irrelevant as far as lifetime is concerned.
- hwillis 6y ago^^^ This affects servers, personal computers, and phones. That's pretty much it. <10 nm is only used for the applications most demanding of computer performance. You know what the limiting factor on your phone and laptop's lifespans are? Because it's certainly not the CPU. Even for the relatively narrow applications in which aging will have noticeable impacts, I doubt it will be a big deal. >90% of people will get a new laptop, phone, or PC long before they see clock reduction due to aging. There are plenty of people who are still on CPUs as old as sandy bridge, but even that is inflated due to the awkward phase where it seemed like parallel utilization would never improve. 15-20 years from now the number of devices using CPUs from the 2020s will be at least as small as the number of people currently using devices from 2010. Not that those devices aren't important, but "we're going to have very short-lived electronics" is just not true (or at minimum, it's already true). On top of that aging in future processors will be a gradual reduction in performance and efficiency, not sudden failure, and it'll still take many years. Design issues are the real concern here; something like underspec'd AVX instructions that suddenly see massive increases in utilization. Aside from that CPUs will not be noticeably different, and the vast majority of consumer electronics and infrastructure will not even be on a relevant technology.
- mark-r 6y agoIs anybody else scared that we're heading for a self-driving car future where the critical components wear out in only a couple of years?