6 ms·
Popular Pirate Sites Slowly “Disappear” from Google’s Top Search Results
- The_Founder 6y agoI don't know how or why (exactly) but my site (https://audiobookreviews.com https://audiobookreviews.com) has also been scrubbed from google but is top result on Duck Duck (we allow users to post torrent magnet links). Google needs to die.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoI mean, it's quite obviously a piracy website. That there's a Mega.nz / Magnet link next to each book is the whole value of the website for users and it's why I've added the site to my bookmarks. Though I can empathize with both sides of the argument over how much Google should be filtering its results. I've built something that is commonly pirated and it was pretty annoying when a direct search of my creation ranked the free pirated version next (or above) my main site.
- adamhearn 6y agoGoogle has shown time and time again that it is not in the search business, but the ad business.
- belval 6y agoI don't think Google should be removing torrent sites from their search. That being said, as highlighted in the article they should at least do a thorough job and remove the fake torrent sites as well. There is nothing good coming out of sending people in scam paradise because you don't want to give them what they are looking for.
- plerpin 6y agoI believe they're legally compelled to remove them from the search listing. Write a letter to your congressperson?
- traverseda 6y agoI mean I'm not American.
- belval 6y agoThe article implied that this was not a DCMA takedown so it's different from the usual "one result it missing...".
- eddhead 6y agoAll one has to do to show up on Google is turn those keywords into an ad. Google's top results are mostly ads. No idea why they're still the top search engine.
- rowanG077 6y agoOne of the main reasons I jumped to duckduckgo. Google only directs you were it wants to and doesn't actually offer the real search result.
- the_omegist 6y agoI can "understand" this from a legal perspective. I can "understand" that ads appear higher in the results. What is less forgivable and more dangerous, and what pushes me more & more toward other search engines, is their socio-political biases. I stopped expecting google to show me the "most popular" results but a distorted view of reality of what they decided is good for me to see.
- nebolo 6y agoDo you have any examples of socio-political bias relevant to the discussion at hand?
- touristtam 6y agoso called piracy is bad according to what western society's moral and legal values are. That should be sufficient clear to anyone remotely familiar with the topic. It is a bias compared to technical discussion on where the result showing in the ranking of specific search engine on a purely technical view.
- aargh_aargh 6y agoAt first I misread "piracy" as "privacy" in your comment. It still checked out.
- nebolo 6y agoI think the key here is that it is bad according to society's legal norms, rather than any "socio-political norms". I think it is absolutely justifiable that Google filters based on legal norms, given that it is a company operating under a given legal system (or multiple). If the result was purely "technical" it would need to show a lot of content that you don't want it to show.
- guerrilla 6y agoThe legal norms obviously originate from socio-political norms and moreover law is literally political, so the scare quotes are quite unnecessary.