4 ms·
The author has missed a few important points to paint a picture that ultimately misses reality. First, Hertz isn't worthless because it has restructured. Even
by LatteLazy 6y ago
The author has missed a few important points to paint a picture that ultimately misses reality.
First, Hertz isn't worthless because it has restructured. Even if hertz is ultimately wound up because its debts exceed its assets (something very very unlikely historically) its shares today are worth something because there is still the chance thelat may not happen (including the chance the company will be saved by a bailout)
Second, the traders he refers to are speculators. Speculators fulfill a role that is a well understood and widely agreed to be important for both liquidity and price discovery.
Third, if other people are bidding price up (or down), who cares? You're not a share holder in a "worthless" company, so let them run their casino in that little corner of the market and you can invest in the other 99.99%.
Ge should also Google what a "dead cat bounce" is to better understand crashed stocks' behavior...
- atombender 6y ago> First, Hertz isn't worthless because it has restructured. Hertz has not restructured yet. They filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy on May 22.
- LatteLazy 6y agoTrue, but chapter 11 means they will restructure and that’s the value you’re buying...
- aembleton 6y agoWhat stops their creditors taking the company? They don't have enough to pay them off.
- sgerenser 6y agoAn extra billion dollars from a stock sale might go a long way in paying off creditors.
- LatteLazy 6y agoWell first, what makes you so sure they don’t have more assets than liabilities? The filed for chapter 11 (restructuring) not chapter 7 (liquidation). And second, even if their liabilities exceed their (physical) assets, creditors are very reluctant to actually liquidate larger businesses. I don’t know exactly why but just looking historically, creditors tend to be much more willing to take a haircut and keep at least parts of the business operational than to demand their full pound of flesh...
- blueblisters 6y ago> its shares today are worth something because there is still the chance thelat may not happen Doesn't equity go to zero (and reset), if the new capital is not enough to cover the debts?
- LatteLazy 6y agoNo, weirdly enough that’s actually very unusual. They’ll get no dividends for a while and they will be diluted, but they almost always end up with some value. I can’t say I understand it totally, I’m just speaking historically... Plus that’s assuming it even gets that’s far. Hertz may get a fat cheque from the federal government or the companies it’s been buying cars from or some other source. Maybe a competitor will offer something for some locations and stock? This is the thing about stocks that take a tumble. If it’s trading at 5% what it was last month, and it’s actually worth 6%, you can buy at 5 and sell at 6 and make a 20% profit.