3 ms·
On it's face the hypothesis that riders are optimizing for aerodynamics on descent is suspect. The peloton breaks up because the critical limit is the performan
by brudgers 6y ago
On it's face the hypothesis that riders are optimizing for aerodynamics on descent is suspect. The peloton breaks up because the critical limit is the performance envelop of the bike's steering geometry, braking and contact patches. It's not that aerodynamics don't matter at all, it's that good enough is good enough. The margins are elsewhere. Everyone can go fast enough to carry too much speed into a turn and have a bad day.
Other positions...provide more equal distribution of body weight over both wheels
This is a suspect optimization premise. Weight distributed to the rear wheel means less weight on the steering wheel and greater eccentric forces when steering...i.e. a reduced front wheel contact patch required to resist higher eccentric loads.
An interesting difference between the photographs and the 3D models is pedal position. The photographs show high-low. The models use a midpoint. The high-low position puts the high foot next to the seat post where weight shift steering will create the least torque on the frame and the feet stay "under" the rider as much as possible shortening the levers creating stiffness.
It looks like Froome's position maximized the amount of force he could exert to keep the handle bars steady and center of mass low -- when going downhill the further forward the rider, the lower their center of mass (all things being equal).
- gameswithgo 6y agogetting your center of mass low and forward like froome does, doesn’t result in steady handling at all, its quite bad you just deal with it. none of this weight torque stuff on the cranks has any meaningful impact when descending in mostly straight lines
- loeg 6y agoSome big races are starting to take measures to try and discourage dangerous crashes on descent stages, like not timing those parts.
- discreteevent 6y ago> Everyone can go fast enough to carry too much speed into a turn and have a bad day. But if you want to beat someone going downhill you need to get to the turn as fast as possible and then brake. On a steep enough hill aerodynamics are the only thing that determine how fast you go on the straight - you don't even pedal because your legs can't keep up.
- jhrmnn 6y agoWhat matters on curvy descents is how much speed you can bring out of the turn. And that mostly depends on how efficient lines you can pick.
- tokai 6y agoThey don't do the supertuck through hard corners of course. That would be absolute madness. Here is a video of Frome descending.[0] There are some hard corners by 6km. He's back up in the saddle and choosing lines through them. [0] https://youtu.be/zojjIghKQoM?t=143 https://youtu.be/zojjIghKQoM?t=143
- brudgers 6y agoAt 3:04 in the video Froome takes a corner in his tuck.
- tokai 6y agoYeah, a left kink. Not a hard corner.
- jimlikeslimes 6y agoFrome is a pretty average descender though. I've heard him talk about struggling on descents, especially in his early career or bad weather.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoThat depends on the gearing. I remember pedaling madly up to 80kph in 12th gear, and after reaching that sliding into that Pantani thing, to coast out as long as possible. Which wasn't that long where i rode, 2 minutes max, maybe.