4 ms·
I have read a lot about Jung and Ramana Maharshi when I was younger. Carl Jung had very strange inner life. He could create hallucinatory beings to talk and i
by nabla9 6y ago
I have read a lot about Jung and Ramana Maharshi when I was younger.
Carl Jung had very strange inner life. He could create hallucinatory beings to talk and interact with, while still fully understanding that they were inside his mind. Very atypical mind. Interesting person to read about and influenced western thinking about psychology.
As a scientist and psychologist he gave new ideas, not better scientific understanding. Probably because his unique psyche. His ideas are too much influenced by what is to be Carl Jung.
Ramana Maharshi was another atypical person, probably had some neurologically interesting going on in his mind. As a young boy he could sleep so deep that his friends could drag him outside and beat him without waking him up.
One Buddhist teacher described Maharshi as the most realized person he ever met, but his method of teaching was not as good as what other meditation practices can achieve. He gave some rudimentary instructions, but if you are not a worshipper type there was no reason to stick around him. Mostly people just gathered around to worship and hear him talk.
- kaybe 6y agoConcerning the hallucinatory beings, if you're interested it it have a look at the tulpa subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/Tulpas/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Tulpas/ edit: I'm browsing that place again and am still not sure what to make of it. It's.. weird. (The link was not a recommendation to try btw, just have a look.)
- kumarvvr 6y agoNothing about his teachings is rudimentary. The feel like that because they look as simple thoughts. But those simple thoughts are enough to attain realization of the self, according to hindu philosophy. However, they are not suited for the normal layman, because realization through Ramana Maharshis teachings involves a certain level of knowledge and thought. I highly encourage you to read "Talks with Sri Ramana Maharshi" by his disciple. In those talks, maharshi breaks down how the elaborate hindu cultural and vedic literature ultimately boils down to utter simplicity.
- nabla9 6y agoI have read it. The point is that for committed practitioners reading books and listening teaching talks is not is not enough. It helps only so much. Buddhist teacher was someone who had meditated and studied decades. He recognized Maharshis was very realized. His point was that Maharshis was not able to teach more than that was in his talks in personal contact. Well known fact in these circles is that medicore person who has struggled his whole life can teach his way to other in personal contact much better than someone who is just amazing.