4 ms·
> But regular exercise all else equal does have a significant effect. Yes, nothing is all else equal... Right, and that's the problem. Even if you do avoid "c
by kelnos 6y ago
> But regular exercise all else equal does have a significant effect. Yes, nothing is all else equal...
Right, and that's the problem. Even if you do avoid "cheating" and "I ran X miles so I deserve this" type things, your body will still mess with your metabolism to compensate for the added exercise, and that works against the weight loss plan.
I went from near-zero exercise to ~10 miles of running per week, and maintained that more or less for 2 years without experiencing any significant weight loss (it was/is definitely valuable for general cardiovascular health, though). Only changing my diet helped, and even then it was difficult to lose weight and keep it off (took a year to lose ~7 lbs, and less than half that to put them back one). But now with COVID-19 and sheltering in place, I've been cooking nearly every day, and in less than three months have lost 15 lbs, and I've been running less than usual.
But really, everyone's individual experience differs. It seems like nutrition and exercise advice really needs to be tailored to each person, and sometimes there's a bit of trial and error involved.
- bonoboTP 6y agoI find it easier to eat right when I do cardio and weight exercise. Maybe it's about practicing tolerating discomfort in the moment. Or about hormones. But I just don't crave junk when I exercise. Or it's because I don't have time to sit around on the couch and be bored because I fill the time with exercise. Not sure why. But I've never really been more than 5-10 kg overweight, so slow and steady was good for me. My issue was rather body composition, not pure weight. You need to train to gain lean mass. Losing weight at all price is only the very beginning of the journey. Also I rather like to track things like waist circumference rather than weight. Your weight may stay the same, while becoming more lean. Of course if you start as overweight as the average American, your first goal may reasonably be to just lose weight and figure out leanness afterwards. Still exercise may help so many other aspects like mood, energy,sleep quality etc. (even if not in the moment but with an hour or day or two delay) which are all helpful to keep oneself on track in the kitchen. It can be a concrete motivational goal to be able to lift this or that much, run so and so far, and it's straightforward to see how you will need to pay attention to your food it you want to achieve that.
- kelnos 6y agoAs I said, everyone's experience differs. I find that my desire to snack and eat junk food does not change at all depending on how much or how little exercise I get. > Still exercise may help so many other aspects like mood, energy,sleep quality etc. (even if not in the moment but with an hour or day or two delay) which are all helpful to keep oneself on track in the kitchen. So, in other words, my initial statement is correct: you're not going to make meaningful progress weight-loss-wise without changing your diet. If exercising makes that easier for you as a second-order effect, that's great. But that's by no means universal.