7 ms·
This article starts with a correct premise: > The retail food chain links one set of farmers to grocery stores, and a second chain links a different set of far
by crazygringo 6y ago
This article starts with a correct premise:
> The retail food chain links one set of farmers to grocery stores, and a second chain links a different set of farmers to institutional purchasers of food, such as restaurants, schools, and corporate offices. With the shutting down of much of the economy, as Americans stay home, this second food chain has essentially collapsed. But because of the way the industry has developed over the past several decades, it’s virtually impossible to reroute food normally sold in bulk to institutions to the retail outlets now clamoring for it. There’s still plenty of food coming from American farms, but no easy way to get it where it’s needed.
Pollan identifies the representative problem:
> One chicken farmer interviewed recently in Washington Monthly, who sells millions of eggs into the liquified egg market, destined for omelets in school cafeterias, lacks the grading equipment and packaging (not to mention the contacts or contracts) to sell his eggs in the retail marketplace.
But the article then goes on to attack all of Pollan's usual bugbears: mergers, globalization, corn, and soybeans. Which have nothing to do with the problem he posed.
He claims:
> Local food systems have proved surprisingly resilient. Small, diversified farmers who supply restaurants have had an easier time finding new markets...
But, frankly, citation needed. Small farmers can't just call up their local supermarket and say "hey can you take a field's worth of arugula off my hands? No sorry I don't have any way of packaging it into retail portions, I've always sold in food-service size bags to restaurants."
And for cities of a certain size, "buying local" is an impossibility anyways. I live in New York City. The land required to feed us would stretch hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of miles around... where there are already smaller towns and suburbs that mostly fill the space. Which is why we source our food from all over the country and world.
So unfortunately, this article completely fails to find the sickness or cure.
- roenxi 6y ago> One chicken farmer interviewed recently in Washington Monthly, who sells millions of eggs into the liquified egg market, destined for omelets in school cafeterias, lacks the grading equipment and packaging (not to mention the contacts or contracts) to sell his eggs in the retail marketplace. Also worth noting that none of those impediments matter to a hungry consumer; if the farmer trucked the eggs in and sold them on the sidewalk there'd be buyers. It is entirely possible that the reason the commercial food chain has collapsed is it is straight-up illegal to sell the food directly to consumers, so it gets destroyed. Farmers are not the sort of people who encounter a minor difficulty then think "welp, I'm just gonna destroy my produce, that seems like the best option". If that is what they are doing then there are some mighty impediments in their path.
- omgwtfbyobbq 6y ago> Farmers are not the sort of people who encounter a minor difficulty then think "welp, I'm just gonna destroy my produce, that seems like the best option". If that is what they are doing then there are some mighty impediments in their path. I agree for the most part, especially with what's happening now. On the flip side, there are times when farmers do destroy produce to manage supply and stabilize prices. https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/michigan-farmers-destroy-cherries/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/michigan-farmers-destroy-c... It kinda sucks for consumers, but if supply swings can bring down prices too far, they're exposed to significant financial risk.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> Also worth noting that none of those impediments matter to a hungry consumer; if the farmer trucked the eggs in and sold them on the sidewalk there'd be buyers. It is entirely possible that the reason the commercial food chain has collapsed is it is straight-up illegal to sell the food directly to consumers, so it gets destroyed. Not true, their are models that allow for that with many caveats (Rawsome in California comes to mind), but you can buy shares in a Farm via a CSA that entitles you to the harvest. Its just that most farms are so large and understaffed that his cannot be done. Moreover, they're incentivized not to do so (see below). > Farmers are not the sort of people who encounter a minor difficulty then think "welp, I'm just gonna destroy my produce, that seems like the best option". If that is what they are doing then there are some mighty impediments in their path. Having been a farmer myself, apprentice and then Manager, I agree with your sentiment. The problem you seem to be negating is that crop insurance and livestock insurance via Ag subsidies are masking these culling(s) that turn losses into compensated (albeit low) actions. Its a horrible system that leads to these things, its baked into the system and its not just in the US and Europe, its everywhere. That's how this system is in just about every country with a semblance of a 'stable government' in the World, including the developed World.
- vector_spaces 6y ago>Small farmers can't just call up their local supermarket and say "hey can you take a field's worth of arugula off my hands? No sorry I don't have any way of packaging it into retail portions, I've always sold in food-service size bags to restaurants." Speaking as someone who has done buying for both supermarket chains and smaller independent stores for about a decade: they absolutely can. Maybe not to Safeway/your local Kroger-owned chain, but certainly to everyone smaller than that: large regional chains like New Seasons Market in the PNW, smaller chains like Bi-Rite in SF and Berkeley Bowl -- in other words, they still have a good chance with roughly 40% of the grocery retail market. And when I would get a call like this, I nearly always converted. Also, produce doesn't generally need to be packaged into retail ready portions -- that's hardly a problem most of the time. Maintaining availability and quality, managing inventory and buying, and keeping prices computerized and margins reasonable are much harder problems, particularly with produce, and having a direct relationship with a small producer who can be more flexible than a larger distributor can address many of those.
- omgwtfbyobbq 6y agoThis! There's a Korean grocery store chain around here (Zion) that brings in all kinds of produce and the majority of it is significantly less than anywhere else local. Some of it is near it's expiration date, so due diligence is required, but at other times I think stuff is incredibly affordable because it's in season and there's a ton of supply. I've seen prices for some things hit ten cents a pound.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> This! There's a Korean grocery store chain around here (Zion) that brings in all kinds of produce and the majority of it is significantly less than anywhere else local. Some of it is near it's expiration date, so due diligence is required... That's a workable model, provided very strict guidelines are put into place, temp controlled and freezing before expiration date etc... It just makes sense to do that than let it go to a dumpster and landfill given all the hidden costs it takes to raise animals for meat. > but at other times I think stuff is incredibly affordable because it's in season and there's a ton of supply. It is. That's the added benefit to seasonal menus in restaurants, it helps re-direct the supply to value added models, but also creates a direct benefit to the consumer. > I've seen prices for some things hit ten cents a pound. This is a bit hard to believe, nothing that requires any amount of labour to grow can realistically be sold that low and not be done at a loss for all involved. I mean even growing herbs requires resources, labour, transport that require a higher price. Even if Ag went entirely automated I doubt we'd see that price for anything remotely called 'food.' Perhaps a promotion to get people in the doors? That's typical in grocery stores business models.
- bsder 6y ago> Which have nothing to do with the problem he posed. The problem is that he touches the details while avoiding the big problem: capitalism. Or, possibly more appropriately, capitalism that marches toward absolutely, positively maximum profit with no regard to any other concept. This is the paperclip maximizer problem but on a smaller scale. And this affects everything, not just food. It's why we had such a disaster about medical equipment--manufacture it where we can extract the last penny vs. manufacturing locally to increase resiliency. The discussion needs to be "How do we inject some inefficiency into capitalism in order to get some other benefits?"--resiliency, local employment, consumer responsiveness, etc. are all things to consider. Up until Covid-19, nobody cared even the slightest iota about anything other than pure, unadulterated profit.
- kortilla 6y agoCapitalism is not the thing preventing farmers from easily selling this stuff directly to consumers.
- bsder 6y agoSure it is. It is more profitable to sell to a middleman who then sells to the grocery store chains because of volume. If you only sell to consumers, then the amount of food you can sell is significantly lower unless you put together your own nationwide distribution network. Why haven't these companies reconfigured to switch chains? They CAN do this. It is a matter of time and money to do so, and they would clean up after doing so. The problem is that everybody is assuming that we will be going back to normal in about 6 months, so anything at that time scale or longer is wasted money from the point of view of profit. Nobody will reoptimize anything until they are absolutely FORCED to as part of an existential threat. This is all about optimizing for profit at the expense of anything else.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> Capitalism is not the thing preventing farmers from easily selling this stuff directly to consumers. > Sure it is. I think its exactly because Free Market Capitalism doesn't exist in the gatekeeping process we currently call the 'The Market' that makes selling directly to consumers an anomaly rather than standard and is quite contrary to your argument. You have to setup a share system to try and have a chance to lower your overheard and CapEX with a farm. Even Farmer's Markets are tightly regulated in some States, and they force you to accept SNAP/Food Stamps to be admitted into the program that allows you to rent a spot for a season. Which presents a whole other set of issues to be paid for your goods/services. There is nothing about Free Market Capitalism in that. And your complex supply chain system is the symptom and byproduct of that perversion. > Why haven't these companies reconfigured to switch chains? They CAN do this. It is a matter of time and money to do so, and they would clean up after doing so. Because since the late 80-90s there has been a systematic eradication of small farms in the US by large Chemical and Biotech Multi-nationals; its a lot harder to petition Monsanto (now Bayer) to stop doing the things that have made them trillions in profits than it would a small and pop 15 acre operation and adapt to this model. I highly recommend this book written by a local journalist in Boulder, CO, called Harvest of Rage [1], and he talks about the cascade effects of ruining rural America as the food belt became the rust belt and led to extremism. > The problem is that everybody is assuming that we will be going back to normal in about 6 months, so anything at that time scale or longer is wasted money from the point of view of profit. Nobody will reoptimize anything until they are absolutely FORCED to as part of an existential threat. I disagree, I'm currently in discussion for a position with a startup that is going even further to capture the food loss from this kind of myopic short sighted-ness, I hope I get it as it would be a good project to really sink my teeth into. > This is all about optimizing for profit at the expense of anything else. Agreed. But that doesn't mean we cannot include a value system in that narrative that helps find a middle ground. We have to be flexible and understand things won't happen over night, I've been trying to tackle this very issue for nearly 15 years, hence my background. And while I always want to see more progress I cannot deny we've come a long way, especially since I was a 90s kid in the US and we didn't even know we were eating pesticide leaden vegetables: we were lab rats! Its no surprise my generation continues to have all these food-bourne illnesses like obesity, diabetes and heart disease. So rather than opine of what should be, try to make a difference in your community. Start a community garden program and plant fruit trees around your area. This was typical during WWII and should come back in my opinion. Now that people are now able to go outside. 1: 1: https://www.amazon.com/Harvest-Rage-Oklahoma-City-Beginning/dp/0813332931 https://www.amazon.com/Harvest-Rage-Oklahoma-City-Beginning/...
- a3n 6y ago> I live in New York City. Vaguely related. I'm a truck driver. I recently drove a 53 foot trailer full of Campbell's tomato soup from Findlay OH to a grocery distributor in Brooklyn. You're welcome. :)
- airstrike 6y agoThank you!
- sampo 6y ago> > Local food systems have proved surprisingly resilient. Here a historian blogs about the origins of the term 'food system': https://www.rachellaudan.com/2020/05/looking-for-the-origin-of-the-term-food-system.html https://www.rachellaudan.com/2020/05/looking-for-the-origin-...
- Melting_Harps 6y agoAwesome! Added to bookmarks and will start reading tonight as it starts off strong.
- twunde 6y agoTangent warning: There's actually a large amount of produce for NYC that is grown locally. Leaving aside the Union Square Greenmarket which gets produce from as far away as Buffalo, most of the Greenmarkets have farms coming up from long island, upstate ny, new jersey and PA. And there's a small subset which is actually grown in NYC (the first time I saw the chickens in Harlem was quite confusing).
- mtalantikite 6y ago> And for cities of a certain size, "buying local" is an impossibility anyways. I live in New York City. The land required to feed us would stretch hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of miles around... where there are already smaller towns and suburbs that mostly fill the space. Which is why we source our food from all over the country and world. I’m also in the city and there are plenty of neighborhood CSAs always looking for new members. When the pandemic hit I found Chef Collective [1] which previously was supplying restaurants and was quickly able to switch to home delivery within a week or two of their commercial supply chain being disrupted. Sure, we’re not going to get, say, local couscous and olive oil. But there is certainly a lot of local farmland that can feed the city. [1] https://chefcollectivenyc.com/ https://chefcollectivenyc.com/
- nine_k 6y agoNYC has greenmarkets. If you visit one, you'll see produce trucked from NY, NJ, PA, MA,.. the furthest I've seen was VT. It's sort of more local than shipping it from Brazil, but still not the same "local" as in a small town.