4 ms·
If you want a raw current events feed just read reuters or AP rss. No need to establish a for profit middle man to do the function of existing technologies alre
by asdff 6y ago
If you want a raw current events feed just read reuters or AP rss. No need to establish a for profit middle man to do the function of existing technologies already in place.
- metrokoi 6y agoExactly, people don't visit Facebook to get unbiased news. They don't want unbiased news. People go there to see news that interests them (and talk to friends and whatnot). The only reason to be against Facebook having a feed based on engagement is if you believe people should not be able to view news that is inflammatory and biased. Perhaps we should force Vice, Buzzfeed, Fox, the Daily Wire, and CNN to shut down and only allow people to read Reuters and AP. That would be even better for the world that Facebook discontinuing the "biased, inflammatory" news algorithm if one is against that sort of algorithm.
- cageface 6y agoOh come on. None of these are collecting user data in real-time and leading the user down engagement rabbit holes they never would have gone down otherwise. I watched a couple of amateur WW2 history videos on YouTube and almost immediately started getting suggestions for some very questionable alt right kinda stuff.
- metrokoi 6y agoIf the algorithms are leading people to alt right sources, (which I suspect is the real issue here, not that the Facebook news is inflammatory or biased, but that right leaning content is more represented) it is leading people to there because that's what they want to see. The algorithm sees that more people click on alt right videos than far left videos. Similar to how browsing reddit leads to rabbit holes leading to subreddits that joke about sending people to the Gulag. Unless you believe people are manipulating the algorithms deliberately to do this, but that sounds like a conspiracy. I use that word not to dismiss it, but because there is not any evidence of it. Again, if one believes serving users content which is exactly what they want to see if that is what users prefer is wrong, then only allowing people to see completely un-selection-biased content is even more right.
- cageface 6y agoSo you're arguing that there's been a massive pent up demand for alt right content that has gone unmet until now? I'm not buying it. People are very easily influenced by what you put in front of them. Until recently there were some moderating influences on what that was.
- metrokoi 6y agoThere was far more alt right content on YouTube several years ago. YouTube has gotten much stricter for what content they allow. I remember seeing recommendations for a rapper called "moonman" who rapped about killing blacks that had hundreds of thousands of views and were more than a year old after I watched a vaporwave album by an artist called Saint Pepsi (they both used the same McDonald's mascot in the videos). I didn't find any such videos today with YouTube's search. What moderating influences were there back then that we don't have today? Ten years ago was the wild west for the internet; I also remember major controversies over subreddits called r/watchpeopledie and r/fatpeoplehate being banned, which were exactly as you would imagine. I don't mean this as an insult or to dismiss your views, but I can only imagine you haven't been on the internet very long if you believe it used to be more moderated and less radical.
- cageface 6y agoI've been on the internet since it was called Gopher and there was no such thing as the WWW. It's far far more influential now than ever before and that influence seems much more negative now than ever.
- basch 6y agoThe problem I have with reuters and ap is that they are for literal news events. Reporting of what happened now. There's a need for longform journalism, synthesis of information, bias and persuasion. It's hard to consume just that without also consuming the daily noise. Longer stories will look less engaging unless facebook also tracks how long you spend reading each site.
- loughnane 6y agoNo source is perfect but the Economist checks a lot of these boxes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- newbie789 6y ago>There's a need for longform journalism, synthesis of information, bias and persuasion. What? It's important that Facebook curates biased information and intentionally persuasive content for you because you're otherwise unwilling/unable to seek that out yourself? I may have misread this entirely, but I'm pretty sure you can find RSS feeds for most news sources outside of AP/Reuters. Whatever content you'd prefer with any sort political or ideological slant you'd like is freely available outside of Facebook by definition. If RSS isn't available for Breitbart or Daily Beast or KCNA or Patribotics or whatever, surely there must be an easy way to consume that outside of the Facebook platform?
- basch 6y agoI absolutely said biased and opinionated journalism is important. On one hand, you can have a story that says "3 people cut their grass today" and on the other hand you can have a story that says "3 people cut their grass today, their reason for doing so, and why you should join them in grass cutting unity." The latter is much more important to a functioning democracy than the former. The crucial part you missed is: >It's hard to consume just that without also consuming the daily noise. RSS is filled with noise. It's filled with stories that are stories because space needed to be filled, that capture your attention for the sake of capturing your attention, not to educate you on things you "need to know." The whole point of something like Facebook's algorithm is to identify a signal from noise. It is very hard to consume the news without consuming noise, and that is an opportunity for Facebook to actually do something morally right (as opposed to agnostic) and identify what is important for people to learn. That by definition is going to involve a level of bias. Its going to involve them going against everything they believe in, NOT using engagement data to rank content, something I dont think their organization is really capable of. Drudge tells you "heres what important to know for the day." Techmeme tells you "heres what important to know for the day." Wikipedia Current Events tells you "heres what important to know for the day." Reddit and Facebook tell you "heres what the most people with short attention spans clicked on today." The world needs better aggregation of important stories.