3 ms·
> But today Ellsberg is celebrated as the patron saint of whistleblowers while Assange is locked in a cell in London’s Belmarsh maximum security prison for 23 a
by jedberg 6y ago
> But today Ellsberg is celebrated as the patron saint of whistleblowers while Assange is locked in a cell in London’s Belmarsh maximum security prison for 23 and a half hours a day.
Ellsberg was charged with a bunch of crimes too, which would have resulted in 100+ years of jail time. He's considered a good person now because he defended himself and won. It should also be noted that he very much supports Wikileaks.
It should also be noted a big difference in the cases is that Ellsberg leaked documents he already had legal access to, and was therefore a whistleblower. Assange leaked documents that he had to illegally acquire first (either with help or without, but either way he was in possession of stolen goods). You can't get whistleblower protection for leaking information you didn't have legal access to.
I totally understand why Assange is fighting extradition -- it's highly unlikely he would be treated fairly or get a fair trial. But I doubt he'll ever be broadly considered a hero until he defends himself in court.
- Natsu 6y agoI don't think that's quite correct, unless it can be proved that they somehow participated in the actual hacking of some target, they do have legal access to the docs, because receiving such is not illegal. Otherwise, the entire press to whom such things are leaked should be in jail with them.
- AndrewBissell 6y agoThis is exactly right. The government's case against Assange hinges in large part on alleging that he actively assisted Manning in obtaining the documents that were published.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 6y agoThat is why they are torturing Manning. The problem for her is that the part of America supposed to help her is so tied into the Russian fiasco. No allies really.
- MiroF 6y ago> Assange leaked documents that he had to illegally acquire first (either with help or without, but either way he was in possession of stolen goods). You can't get whistleblower protection for leaking information you didn't have legal access to. Should we charge the journalists who distributed Snowden's leaks as well? This seems like making a distinction to draw a line between the two, but I am missing the explanation for why this distinction has moral import.
- jedberg 6y ago> Should we charge the journalists who distributed Snowden's leaks as well? We don't need to, we know who their source was (Snowden). If Assange wants to claim he's a journalist, that's fine, but then he either needs to accept the consequences of protecting his sources, or out his sources. > but I am missing the explanation for why this distinction has moral import. It's a question of responsibility. When a journalist protects their sources, they accept responsibility for the consequences, and they they chose to reveal their source, they pass on the consequences to their source, but (usually) take a hit to their reputation as a journalist. Assange appears to not want to accept any consequences for his actions, nor pass them on be revealing his sources.
- MiroF 6y ago> We don't need to, we know who their source was (Snowden). If Assange wants to claim he's a journalist, that's fine, but then he either needs to accept the consequences of protecting his sources, or out his sources. Journalists are legally required to put their sources or they are on the hook? I suggest you revisit the case history on this subject.
- jedberg 6y ago> I suggest you revisit the case history on this subject. Can you point me at some links? I'm not a lawyer but my understanding is that shield laws are state by state, and there are no federal protections.
- Doubl 6y agoBroadly? I thinks that's a very American centric perspective. About the last system of justice I'd like to find myself at the mercy of outside those in totalitarian countries is the American one. It has earned itself an awful reputation, in Europe, at least. It's such a shame that countries like the UK appear to be behaving like client states of America.
- jedberg 6y agoI agree with you. That's why I said, "it's highly unlikely he would be treated fairly or get a fair trial. "
- mnm1 6y agoIt has earned itself an awful reputation in America too amongst the people who understand it. Unfortunately, most Americans are too stupid to understand it or too hateful to even try.
- american_aurora 6y agoI think this is a ridiculous perspective, especially when virtually every European countries is on the inquisitorial system. (See The Trial.) It is my opinion that the US is probably one of the best countries when it comes to the rights of a defendant ― well, before a guilty verdict. I ask that you actually take a look at some of the kinds of people who run the federal courts in the United States. See something like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXv7anhiIBY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXv7anhiIBY. These are serious legitimate people who are working in and trying to improve a highly developed yet highly imperfect legal system (and country).
- mariuolo 6y ago> It is my opinion that the US is probably one of the best countries when it comes to the rights of a defendant ― well, before a guilty verdict. Perhaps in the ~5% of the cases that actually go to trial.
- Retric 6y agoIn what way is getting sent files illegal? Last I checked the only protection on classified information was for people that had a clearance at some point. Which is why journalists can generally publish classified information.
- jedberg 6y agoIt's illegal to keep something you know was stolen.
- Retric 6y agoThat applies to physical objects not information. One odd corner case in the US it’s legal to buy bootlegs but not make them.
- dependenttypes 6y agoThis is because bootlegs are not stolen.
- dependenttypes 6y agoYou can't steal digital data unless if you copy them for yourself and delete any other copies afterwards.
- jpgvm 6y agoInformation was copied, not stolen. This is about as correct as arguments around piracy equating downloading a film to stealing a car. The other party still has the information, it's not stolen. In the case of a movie it was illegally copied, this is illegal under copyright law but is NOT stealing. Copying classified information you have been granted access to by the military because of your security clearance is illegal and punishable by court marshall but it's NOT stealing. A journalist disclosing classified information IS legal and always has been. If it wasn't then all of the journalists that published the cables in NYTimes and friends would be guilty of the same charges as Assange, i.e copying classified information from some source on the Internet and then disclosing it to their readers/viewers. However there is potentially SOME argument that Assange may be running afoul of the Espionage act because he is ACCUSED of aiding and abetting a member of the US military in exfiltrating classified information. This is illegal but it's definition is so broad that it would most likely need to be heard by the Supreme Court to clarify. i.e he isn't being charged with stealing because he didn't steal shit. He isn't being charged with disclosing secrets because that is legal. He is being charged with helping someone do something illegal and that is entirely different.