5 ms·
> The protests are about systematic discrimination of black people. No one questioned that black people can also be perpetrators - it's just irrelevant to the t
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> The protests are about systematic discrimination of black people. No one questioned that black people can also be perpetrators - it's just irrelevant to the topic at hand.
And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?
There is something to be said for asking someone to start by getting their own house in order.
- csallen 6y agoThank god this rubbish isn't how the legal system functions in any civilized country.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWho is talking about the legal system? This is the political system.
- csallen 6y agoThe political system doesn't work like this either. All governments and political bodies are capable of dealing with multiple issues simultaneously. As far as I'm aware, none will deny you your rights or restitution just because "hey look, some people who look like you have done bad things, too."
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> All governments and political bodies are capable of dealing with multiple issues simultaneously. If that were true there would be equally prominent protests and proposed legislation on both issues simultaneously. > As far as I'm aware, none will deny you your rights or restitution just because "hey look you've done bad things, too." You're talking about the legal system again.
- csallen 6y agoIn what way does being capable of considering multiple issues simultaneously require protest for all of these issues, or equal prominence for all of these issues? I have no idea what point you're trying to make, really.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> In what way does being capable of considering multiple issues simultaneously require protest for all of these issues, or equal prominence for all of these issues? Because that's what considering means. It takes more than just declaring that something is under consideration while not really paying attention to it or doing anything about it. We don't actually consider all issues at once equally. That's why it makes sense to question their relative importance.
- csallen 6y agoYou're assuming that care for every issue is expressed in the same way, and also that whether or not something makes front page news or gets people riled up is a fair measure of how much they care, as opposed to a measure of simply how flashy or exciting that issue is.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> that whether or not something makes front page news or gets people riled up is a fair measure of how much they care That seems like a pretty good metric for whether the political system is grappling with something. What metric are you proposing as an alternative? Does it show a different result?
- csallen 6y agoThe political system is always grappling with lots of things simultaneously. Some of those things will always be getting more publicity and arousing more anger than others at any point in time, but so what? That doesn't necessarily mean anyone's moving the needle on those issues to a higher degree than on other issues.
- arkades 6y agoI'm not sure I understand your comment correctly. Are you saying that black communities should be reasonably crime-free before they can expect institutions not to systematically discriminate them and enact retributionless, extralegal violence upon them?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWhat I'm saying is that when black people kill more than ten times more black people than cops kill black people, somebody is not wrong to ask why the focus should only be on the cops.
- arkades 6y agoBecause one of those groups is a set of criminals that will be prosecuted to the full extent of the law, and the other one of those groups is a set of government agents with a history of not being held accountable for their actions. There's never been a lack of focus on intra-community violence. It's been the go-to "whataboutism" for ... ever. It's also not relevant to the question of why government authorities should be exempt from the consequences of violating the law.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Because one of those groups is a set of criminals that will be prosecuted to the full extent of the law, and the other one of those groups is a set of government agents with a history of not being held accountable for their actions. You could say that about both groups. There is a cultural tradition in the relevant communities of not talking to the police, which causes disproportionately many of those murderers to get away with it, and the murder solve rate in the US isn't all that high to begin with. You tend to get more murders in proportion to how much the perpetrators expect to get away with it, so the numbers are telling a story there. > There's never been a lack of focus on intra-community violence. It's been the go-to "whataboutism" for ... ever. Apparently not to a sufficient extent to actually address the problem. If you don't want people to keep pointing to it then get there to not be something to point to. > It's also not relevant to the question of why government authorities should be exempt from the consequences of violating the law. The officers in question are facing homicide charges, as it should be. You're just begging the question in limiting it to government authorities. If Black Lives Matter then shouldn't all of them?
- dragonwriter 6y ago“Black people” aren't an organization. Police are (well, police departments are organizations), and those organizations act on behalf of the public. Systemic police abuse for which there is no effective public accountability and systemic correction isn't the private acts of individual wrongdoers, it's violence by and with the at least tacit support of the public. That's why the focus exists: responsible citizenship.