7 ms·
> I always question, why does a Black life matter only when a white man takes it?... I mean, Lacy does have a point that this kind of question in the context o
by xg15 6y ago
> I always question, why does a Black life matter only when a white man takes it?...
I mean, Lacy does have a point that this kind of question in the context of the protests is nothing more than distracting.
The protests are about systematic discrimination of black people. No one questioned that black people can also be perpetrators - it's just irrelevant to the topic at hand.
Would nazis running concentration camps be absolved by finding that "well but some inmates commit violence too"?
- flyinglizard 6y agoDo you feel like there are many parallels between being a Jew in 1939 Germany and being a black person in 2020 USA?
- csallen 6y agoThat's not how analogies work, so this is completely missing the point. For example, if you say the Colosseum is to Rome what a roller coaster is to an amusement part, you are not saying that the Colosseum is similar to a roller coaster. No, what you're comparing is the Colosseum's relationship to Rome and the rollercoaster's relationship to the amusement park. xg15's analogy isn't meant to equate Black people in America in 2020 to Jewish people in Nazi concentration camps. Rather, it's meant to compare the irrelevance of intra-Jewish violence in the face of Nazi violence to the irrelevance of intra-Black violence in the face of police violence. Always surprising to me how the basic structure of analogy is so commonly misunderstood.
- arkades 6y ago> Always surprising to me how the basic structure of analogy is so commonly misunderstood. It's what happens when people don't have a rebuttal to the point being raised. It's generally a good sign that they're no longer engaging in good faith.
- naveen99 6y agoThe analogy might be stronger if intra Jewish violence killed 10x more than nazis.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- csallen 6y agoThat's completely irrelevant to the analogy, and you are making the same exact mistake as flyinglizard: treating an analogy as a simple comparison instead of as… an analogy. For example, let's try another analogy: If a plane crashes and kills a bunch of people, we investigate the cause of the accident and demand to know what happens. We don't decline to investigate, fail to assign blame, or neglect to comfort the families because "well, people kill people more than planes kill people." Note that this analogy holds even though homicides account for 1600x as many deaths annually than plane crashes… because that's irrelevant to what's actually being compared in the analogy.
- naveen99 6y agoYes, if planes were killing more people than people, we probably wouldn’t investigate them as thoroughly. But people would probably stop flying, so kind of an unstable reality.
- flyinglizard 6y agoThis was no analogy, as my point illustrated - not any more than name dropping any atrocious historical event into the discussion for rhetorical shock value. The article discussed here specifically builds a significant part of its argument on the way violence inside black communities is silenced because it does not fit the current narrative. The article does not talk about police brutality itself, but about the way reality is bent and picked to fit a minority viewpoint.
- xg15 6y agoNo, it was one, csallen explained that quite well. I was trying to illustrate the point using an event were we should be all in agreement systematic discrimination and oppression happened. In that context, it's irrelevant how the oppressed behave.
- wherewillitlead 6y agoMax from Oakland didn't think it was irrelevant to the topic at hand. Shouldn't he be heard? He belongs to the population being discriminated against. To me that makes his perspective relevant, and I can't see by what logic it wouldn't be, except conformity enforcement, which is scary and not likely to end well. Bringing up concentration camps in that way is just a way of assuming your conclusion.
- dillondoyle 6y agoWriting about the protests, my mom recently told me 'It is a sad fact that most of the crime is black on black' among other things that are SO frustrating that I gave up on trying to reply back. Like to me that statement is a non sequitur, and says either: that the cause of increased violence is systemic adverse conditions and outright theft of wealth/quality of life over 400 years making communities tough to succeed in (doubt my Mom understands this) or that if this is not true, that POC are somehow more violent as a race. Some Stoddard, Günther eugenics BS. All my parents thoughts about the protests have these racist undertones and I don't know how to open my parents to education and understanding - and it's also scary with the election they would never vote Trump but his Reagan esque re-launch next week seems like this is his new strategy. Just googling now I found this PDF, maybe I try sending that https://www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/centers/wiener/programs/pcj/files/PoliceandPublicDiscourseBlackonBlackViolence.pdf https://www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/centers/wien...
- csallen 6y agoSurprised you're being downvoted. Let your mom know that the majority of violence against most races comes from other members of the same race, especially in highly segregated societies. For example, 84% of White victims are killed by Whites, and 93% of African American victims killed by African Americans.
- DenisM 6y agoTry listening to your parents instead of educating at them.
- dillondoyle 6y agodefinitely good advice
- bllguo 6y agoI also strongly believe that the cause is the former - centuries of institutionalized persecution, a vicious cycle of poverty, etc. Why not respond with that? I can understand it being frustrating but we can't just shut off discussion of uncomfortable truths. I have encountered many situations in my own life where liberal-minded people will outright deny claims like that. Unfortunately those are the statistics; denying facts helps no one. There is an explanation for those numbers - that is what the response should be.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The protests are about systematic discrimination of black people. No one questioned that black people can also be perpetrators - it's just irrelevant to the topic at hand. And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye? There is something to be said for asking someone to start by getting their own house in order.
- csallen 6y agoThank god this rubbish isn't how the legal system functions in any civilized country.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWho is talking about the legal system? This is the political system.
- csallen 6y agoThe political system doesn't work like this either. All governments and political bodies are capable of dealing with multiple issues simultaneously. As far as I'm aware, none will deny you your rights or restitution just because "hey look, some people who look like you have done bad things, too."
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> All governments and political bodies are capable of dealing with multiple issues simultaneously. If that were true there would be equally prominent protests and proposed legislation on both issues simultaneously. > As far as I'm aware, none will deny you your rights or restitution just because "hey look you've done bad things, too." You're talking about the legal system again.
- csallen 6y agoIn what way does being capable of considering multiple issues simultaneously require protest for all of these issues, or equal prominence for all of these issues? I have no idea what point you're trying to make, really.