5 ms·
When will this meme die? Zoom is NOT a Chinese company. It is incorporated in and headquartered in the US. Like any American company ever, it follows US laws i
by crazygringo 6y ago
When will this meme die?
Zoom is NOT a Chinese company. It is incorporated in and headquartered in the US. Like any American company ever, it follows US laws in the US, and local laws in other companies where it operates. End of story.
Yes their culture certainly has stronger cultural internal ties to China, due to the number of Chinese employees, but what has that got to do with anything? At the end of the day, they're a public, profit-driven corporation trying to make lots of money across the entire world.
It's not like they're secretly and nefariously doing the CCP's bidding, which seems to be the veiled suggestion people keep making.
Seriously, every time someone brings up that Zoom is "really" a Chinese company, it comes across as borderline racism or conspiracy-mongering or both. And while I'd usually never comment on someone using a throwaway account, in this case when you're pushing these kinds of shady "stronger than the more-commonly-discussed" insituations, I think using a throwaway here is representative of exactly the kind of astroturfing that spreads malicious rumors without evidence.
- augustt 6y agoWhen will the meme that hating an organ harvesting totalitarian government == racism die?
- crazygringo 6y agoSo explain to me -- since Zoom is not a Chinese company, then what's the purpose of falsely claiming that it is? If it isn't meant to tap into some kind of prejudice against Chinese people, then what is the purpose of spreading false rumors like that? You can of course be against the Chinese government. But when you start fearmongering that a public American company is "actually Chinese", "more than commonly discussed"... based on zero evidence except that the company has a lot of Chinese people... then if it's not meant to trigger veiled racism, what is it meant to trigger otherwise? Since, again, Zoom is not part of and has nothing to do with the Chinese government, except for when it obeys the government in its operations within China, like every other American company has to do too.
- Medicalidiot 6y ago>Zoom's product development team is largely based in China The main players are under CCP command. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoom_Video_Communications#Workforce https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoom_Video_Communications#Work...
- crazygringo 6y agoA company's "main players" are its board and senior management. "Under command" means they report to someone. Can you please explain how you think the board members and management of Zoom -- an American publicly traded company -- report to the CCP? Because that is certainly not what your Wikipedia link says.
- redis_mlc 6y agoThe CCP has access to most of Zoom's developers, so they can direct them to do anything at any time. Zoom's filings disclose that in fact.
- Medicalidiot 6y ago>A company's "main players" are its board and senior management Ah I see that we have different definitions of main players. I'm thinking of developers who are able to mess with the code. But the Wikipedia does support what my definition of main players means. Just because the board doesn't report to CCP doesn't mean that someone significant in the 700 isn't an assent of the CCP and able to do significant damage.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> It's not like they're secretly and nefariously doing the CCP's bidding Yes, Chinese citizens do the bidding of the CCP or they or their families will be disappeared. The courts are not independent of the CCP, so there is no recourse to whatever the CCP demands. Can you explain why you think otherwise? Are you just engaging in false equivalence of Chinese and US governments, or do you have another reason for your defense of the CCP?
- crazygringo 6y agoWhat the hell? In no place did I defend the CCP, so please don't put offensive words into my mouth. It's insulting and you should be ashamed of yourself for making false accusations. And you are aware that Zoom's founder, Eric Yuan, is an American citizen? He grew up Chinese, but he acquired American citizenship, and therefore lost his Chinese citizenship. He and his family live in California where they're not going to be "disappeared". So explain to me again why you think Zoom's founder and CEO, or its board members representing prominent venture capital firms, are doing the "bidding of the CCP"? I'm not engaging in any kind of false equivalence or defending China. I'm pointing out that Zoom and China are totally different things. Using Zoom doesn't mean you're supporting China or being spied on by China. It's an American company, not a Chinese one.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> Using Zoom doesn't mean you're supporting China or being spied on by China. Yes, using Zoom 100% means you're being spied on by China.
- crazygringo 6y agoYour first comment was already flagged by other users. Why don't you stop making false statements? Zoom allows you to specifically choose where your servers are located, e.g. to avoid China specifically if you want: https://blog.zoom.us/wordpress/2020/04/13/coming-april-18-control-your-zoom-data-routing/ https://blog.zoom.us/wordpress/2020/04/13/coming-april-18-co... I don't dispute China might compel Zoom to reveal user activity within the country. But there's no legal mechanism for China to do so for communication that doesn't pass through China. And Zoom's entire business reputation hinges on that. Please stop spreading disinformation on HN.