2 ms·
As I understand it, research shows there is some bias in favor of women in the court system. Eg, see chapter 7 of "Women's Crimes, Criminology, and Corrections"
by eesmith 6y ago
As I understand it, research shows there is some bias in favor of women in the court system. Eg, see chapter 7 of "Women's Crimes, Criminology, and Corrections" at https://books.google.com/books?id=zZZeAwAAQBAJ&lpg=PR1&ots=hUIwpuSbdO&lr&hl=en&pg=PA169#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=zZZeAwAAQBAJ&lpg=PR1&ots=h... as "The Chivalry Hypothesis", starting on p. 168.
Here's one quote, from p174:
> Their data were from the 1980s, and included larger numbers of cases than many of the other studies, but addressed only two types of charges -- theft and assault. They found that African American men, but not African American women, were less likely than other defendants to get charge reductions. They found that women were 15 to 17 percent more likely than men without a record to receive probation and 11 to 16 percent less likely to receive a jail sentence. These authors also found that white women were about twice as likely as minority women to have assault charges at arrest changed to non-assault charges at final sentencing. They concluded that there are sex effects, at least for these two crime categories, that exist apart from any influence of offensive seriousness.
Intersectionality helps explain why (black or Latino) + male is even worse.
So when the anonymous author writes "we characterize criminal justice as a systemically misandrist conspiracy against innocent American men" .. well, leaving 'conspiracy' aside, .. yes, it seems there is a bias against men in the criminal justice system, and a bigger bias against black men.
Why then shouldn't we think about the criminal system as being misandrist? The essay present no evidence that the 'Chivalry Hypothesis' is invalid, and seems to scoff at the possibility that it might be.
The author writes "Black people are not incarcerated at higher rates than their involvement in violent crime would predict."
I'll now quote from https://www.sentencingproject.org/publications/color-of-justice-racial-and-ethnic-disparity-in-state-prisons/#IV.%20Drivers%20of%20Disparity https://www.sentencingproject.org/publications/color-of-just... :
> Analyses of more recent data all come to similar conclusions: a sizable proportion of racial disparities in prison cannot be explained by criminal offending
Just how accurate are the rest of this professor's observations?
The author writes "If we claim that the criminal justice system is white-supremacist, why is it that Asian Americans, Indian Americans, and Nigerian Americans are incarcerated at vastly lower rates than white Americans? This is a funny sort of white supremacy. "
That's .. a pretty well known story. US law prevented immigration from Asia until the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965. Eg, the Chinese Exclusion Act (1882) and the Immigration Act of 1924. The lack of a large Asian population for several generations weakened the rather violent American attitudes from the late 1800s.
The 1965 act gave priority to professionals and other individuals with specialized skills, so the people that came were from a different economic class than the manual laborers of a century before, and not representative of the general American population.