3 ms·
Why is it unfair? I think SO should care more about the quality of questions and answers than about the reputation score of individual contributors. This is a
by the_af 6y ago
Why is it unfair? I think SO should care more about the quality of questions and answers than about the reputation score of individual contributors.
This is a downside of gamification though: it becomes all about ego and earning points, which I don't think should be the goal of a site like SO. If keeping the quality of the content means some people must lose rep points, then so be it. If they have 14K rep they won't notice, anyway.
- detaro 6y agoA "this is outdated" flag thats independent of downvotes would achieve both goals.
- the_af 6y agoMaybe. It should be coupled with a mechanism to encourage more up to date answers, if possible a link to a better answer if it exists. Also a way to encourage organic searches from finding more up to date answers. The flag should act so that it isn't ripe for abuse (e.g. people flagging out of spite, without evidence). Downvoting does have the side-effect of poking the original author into action, because gamification often means (regrettably) that people do care about rep points. edit: an argument against down/upvoting: I think there is a sizeable "bandwagon" effect. People upvote what already has upvotes, and downvote what already has downvotes. I can't prove it but I'm pretty sure this happens. If so, obsolete answers will never go away by downvoting alone.
- pelasaco 6y agoit is unfair, because the answer isn't necessarily wrong. It's just outdated. If somebody asks "How to do X in rails", and your answer isn't valid in Rails 6 anymore it's not necessarily wrong if it still works with Rails 2.3.8.