4 ms·
There doesn't seem to be any remedy to the problem of poor, obsolete, or outright wrong answers being selected as the checked answer when the asker disappears.
by kevin_thibedeau 6y ago
There doesn't seem to be any remedy to the problem of poor, obsolete, or outright wrong answers being selected as the checked answer when the asker disappears. I frequently have to scroll past the approved one because there's often gold hiding below it.
- Buttons840 6y agoTangentially: It makes sense that the asker of the question gets to choose the answer that worked for them, but by doing so the idea of "duplicate questions" is invalidated. For example, I could very well ask a new question which ends up being flagged as a duplicate of another question whose accepted answer does not work for me. Can two questions be duplicates if they have different answers? Do I only have to claim that the accepted answer does not work to show that the new question is unique?
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThe real problem is the asker isn’t knowledgable enough to select the correct answer in many cases. I’m not sure of the value this feature.
- MrZander 6y agoI ran into this yesterday. I got an upvote on an answer I posted 7 years ago that was marked accepted. There was a much better answer with 3x the upvotes at the bottom of the list and the OP account was no longer active. Wondering if there was a protocol for changing the accepted answer, I searched meta. I found the consensus is: 'Accepted' is at the sole discretion of the OP and shouldn't be mean it's correct, just that it answered the OP's question. Which I think is BS as it elevates the answer to the top of the list and gives it credibility. Why is the OP the czar that chooses the correct solution just because they asked the question first? Honestly, the OP is often the _least_ qualified person to validate an answers correctness.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoSO sometimes puts the highest-voted answer at the top when the accepted answer has fewer votes.
- sgillen 6y agoSort of think there should be two systems, and OP selected answer, and a community selected answer. This is already what happens to some extent, it’s just a matter of UX I think to clearly mark the answers the community thinks are good with something akin to the green check you get (and I guess more importantly move these to the top) I’m not sure this matters too much for experienced devs, it’s really just a noobie trap to only look at a low upvote but chosen answer right?
- MrZander 6y agoI like the two system approach, that is a good idea. Perhaps it is just a matter of properly ordering the answers, maybe giving community votes precedence over the accepted answer? For example, here is the question I was talking about: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/11970586/apl-removing-elements-from-array/12048902 https://stackoverflow.com/questions/11970586/apl-removing-el... My answer should not be accepted, I was brand new to APL when I answered it. The "correct" answer not accepted and buried below two 0 vote questions. The thing is, my answer _works_, just not well. I can easily see myself overlooking a better solution in a case like this. Maybe I'm just lazy though haha.