3 ms·
The decision to do what they did is mind boggling. I can only assume they were caught up in the atmosphere of unknown that was COVID... and somehow decided tha
by duxup 6y ago
The decision to do what they did is mind boggling.
I can only assume they were caught up in the atmosphere of unknown that was COVID... and somehow decided that their actions made sense.
It was poor judgment executed on a huge scale that potentially puts the whole Internet Archive at risk.
I would love to have been able to hear what the discussions were surrounding that decision and if / how they dealt with the obvious objection of "hey guys this is illegal".
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThey published a blog post explaining why they saw this as legal, and at the least it doesn't seem as clear cut as you imagine.
- duxup 6y agoI really don't think that "unprecedented global and immediate need for access to reading and research materials" is a real legal justification, or if their reasoning would even be seen as an obvious fact.
- exolymph 6y ago> they saw this as legal Yeah, that's not really how the law works, as demonstrated by this incident.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThat is exactly how the law works. Having a lawsuit filed against you doesn't prove that you are guilty, the courts hear the case, interpret the written law and rule whether the action was legal.
- exolymph 6y agoWhat you describe is not the same as "we think this is legal so YOLO"
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>"we think this is legal so YOLO" I don't know why you think my post could be summarized like that. There's no real way to show if it's legal other than settle the matter in court, and they presumably consulted a legal team before the program started.
- exolymph 6y agoI said that your post is _not_ "we think this is legal so YOLO," whereas the Internet Archive's actual behavior _is_.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoYou haven't provided any reason why it is, which is why I'm confused.
- kevindong 6y agoThe original model (lending out one digital copy per physical copy held) has merit [0]. It's called "controlled digital lending." The issue is that the Internet Archive is lending out unlimited digital copies if they hold even one physical copy. At best, that's a legally dubious position. The Internet Archive even admits this practice wouldn't qualify as "controlled digital lending." [1] [0]: https://help.archive.org/hc/en-us/articles/360042654251-National-Emergency-Library-FAQs#h_11e65d8d-badc-499a-aa93-8242abbab2e3 https://help.archive.org/hc/en-us/articles/360042654251-Nati... [1]: https://help.archive.org/hc/en-us/articles/360042654251-National-Emergency-Library-FAQs#h_994793fd-f604-4dda-a781-e5571f3ee117 https://help.archive.org/hc/en-us/articles/360042654251-Nati...
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>At best, that's a legally dubious position. Hence the lawsuit. The internet Archive is arguing this as part of the CDL's "fair use" portion. Presumably they view the program as allowing libraries to continue offering their "vital function to society" while being closed. http://blog.archive.org/2020/03/30/internet-archive-responds-why-we-released-the-national-emergency-library/ http://blog.archive.org/2020/03/30/internet-archive-responds...
- mcguire 6y agoEverything the Internet Archive does is legally sketchy. The wayback machine making copies of web sites available without a prior agreement with the copyright owners? Their game and video archives? Edit: I get it, it's an unpopular opinion. But as far as I can see, it's true: IA operates on a very broad definition of fair use that would be difficult to support legally. You can't have it both ways. I just donated $100 to IA and refrained from making a $200 order for new books.
- duxup 6y agoI think web scraping has been trending towards being established as more "legal" as time goes on.
- tzs 6y agoIt has, in the sense that it trending toward web scraping itself is not per se illegal, even if the site has terms of service that says you won't do it. That's orthogonal to the question of whether or not in any particular case it is copyright infringement.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> the obvious objection of "hey guys this is illegal" I figured the same was true for Google Books, but that's still around.