5 ms·
There are certainly bad unions. But I think that often arises as a reaction to poisonous management behavior, a zero-sum mentality that treats workers as a cost
by wpietri 6y ago
There are certainly bad unions. But I think that often arises as a reaction to poisonous management behavior, a zero-sum mentality that treats workers as a cost center, not a value generator. It's a "fuck me, no fuck you" scenario.
Your point about the Hollywood unions is a great one. Like tech, in Hollywood everybody has clear incentives to create a great final product. Positive-sum thinking usually part of the culture. In that context, I think unions can be a big help, especially when there are such large wealth and power differentials between the bosses and the workers.
I also think your former colleagues' seeming lack of agency is weird. The union is something the workers create and run. If they think a union they create would be bad, what are they saying about themselves?
- michaelt 6y ago> The union is something the workers create and run. If they think a union they create would be bad, what are they saying about themselves? They think a union would be a bit like a homeowners association - in principle owned and run by them and never acting against their interests, but in practice a threat as much as an opportunity.
- mcv 6y agoUS homeowners association are another great example that doesn't match European experience. Why do Americans turn everything that's supposed to be in their own interest, into a vehicle for power abuse? That seems to be the recurring story in American unions, as well as homeowner associations. Are there any other supposedly-good organisations that are toxic in the US? Political parties? News? Boy scouts?
- leereeves 6y ago> Are there any other supposedly-good organisations that are toxic in the US? There aren't many supposedly-good organizations in the US. According to Gallup[1], in 2019 there were only three institutions in which more than half of Americans had "a great deal" or "quite a lot" of trust: the military, police, and small business. The police probably lost that trust recently, leaving only small business and the military. Only 29% trusted organized labor, which puts it below the presidency, in 2019. But even fewer trust big business, and trust in organized labor has been rising, so there might be some hope for unions. 1: https://news.gallup.com/poll/1597/confidence-institutions.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/1597/confidence-institutions.as...
- dsjoerg 6y agoAs an American I strongly agree with your insight, and independently arrived at it. It is an underlying cultural issue -- a lack of community spirit that is relatively widespread. It is a universal human tendency that is strongly in effect here at the current time and place.
- toomuchtodo 6y ago> a lack of community spirit that is relatively widespread. How did this happen?
- wpietri 6y agoFor homeowners associations in particular, I think a lot of the history is rooted in American race and class bias. A lot of American suburbs were created due to white flight [1]. And although they're mostly no longer explicitly racist, they're very stratified by income, which can be read as class bias and/or quiet racism. That desire for exclusion and enforced superiority appeals to some more than others. So it's unsurprising to me that HOA boards frequently turn out awful. Happily, as older, first-ring suburbs turn into cities in their own right, we're seeing some reversal of that. E.g., as kids and grandkids stay in the area, we're seeing demographic and income diversification. Some places are realizing that things they've previously excluded, like drug treatment and publicly supported housing, are now necessary. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight
- emilecantin 6y ago> Are there any other supposedly-good organisations that are toxic in the US? Definitely. > Political parties? Check. There are only 2, and cynicism towards both of them is pretty high, as neither really represents the people. > News? Check as well. See Fox News, which actually delivers "entertainment" disguised as news. > Boy scouts? Probably not, but who knows? Disclaimer: Not an American, just a Canadian that follows US new a bit.
- lovegoblin 6y ago> > Boy scouts? > Probably not, but who knows? Just a long history of homophobia there.
- pjc50 6y agoHollywood unions are a slightly special case: while the studios hold a huge amount of power, the staff are pretty much all contractors per-project, and the entity they're contracting with will be a special purpose corporate vehicle for that film. Most software doesn't look like that - except game development, which is notoriously abusive and can get away with it because of a fresh supply of enthusiastic young people.
- triceratops 6y ago> game development...is notoriously abusive and can get away with it because of a fresh supply of enthusiastic young people. Hollywood also has an endless supply of enthusiastic young people. To me this sounds like an argument in favor of unionizing the game dev industry.
- mcv 6y agoAll those game industry horror stories are an even stronger argument in favour of unionising the game industry.
- creaghpatr 6y agoYou don’t get into the Hollywood unions until you put in hundreds of hours of set time, most ADs I know don’t get the corresponding benefits until they are about 30.
- distances 6y agoWhy's that? In the Nordics you can already join an union when you're a student without a job yet, and many people do.
- missedthecue 6y agoNordic union != US union
- 6y ago
- rb808 6y agoHollywood unions are a prime reason lots of movies are made in Vancouver/Georgia/Other Countries now. Hollywood will end up like Detroit.
- Apocryphon 6y agoFavorable tax conditions are more likely the reason for that.
- mushbino 6y agoThis is correct. I know a few producers who shoot in Georgia and Louisiana and the tax credits are exactly why.
- 0-O-0 6y ago> union is something the workers create and run I just assume that it's almost never going to be the case. It might look like it's created by worker, but it's created by a sub group of workers which is unhappy with a status quo. This effort will be led by even smaller sub group of activists that have a drive and skillset to organise and weasel into a leadership positions. Worker run union seems to be even more implausible. It's going to be run by a managerial body composed of said activists, which I absolutely expect to be self-serving, rent seeking and, well, parasitic. Occasionally their interests will coincide with interests of workers they represent, but that will be just some happy accidents.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoUnions are run by the members
- manfredo 6y agoIn theory. In practice unions are run by union leadership. Who are elected. But then again so is Congress and the President - and we know how that works out.
- wpietri 6y agoI think that's quite different. Congress has 435 people representing 325 million. A union local can be just a couple hundred people.
- gpanders 6y agoJust like democracies are run by the voters? True in principle, but rarely in practice.