3 ms·
No one country to 'officially' manage it is likely a big factor, as is the fact that Arabic has a sort of diglossia between Modern Standard Arabic and the "dial
by _delirium 16y ago
No one country to 'officially' manage it is likely a big factor, as is the fact that Arabic has a sort of diglossia between Modern Standard Arabic and the "dialects" spoken in each country. For names in particular, they are sometimes transcribed in a more phonetic way, trying to capture how people actually pronounce them in, say, Libya or Morocco or Egypt; and other times are transcribed in a more structural/etymological way based on the spelling, following one of the schemes for transcribing the Arabic alphabet into English, which are usually based on Modern Standard Arabic.
Greek has a version of the same variation, despite not having modern-day diglossia and being mostly associated with one country, because of the ancient/modern relationship. For example, the large peninsula in southern Greece, Χαλκιδική, is spelled: Halkidiki, Halkithiki, Halkidhiki, Chalcidice, Chalcidiki, Khalkidhiki, Chalkidike, etc. Some of the transliterations attempt to capture how it's pronounced in modern Greek (Halkidiki is close, but Khalkidhiki captures some of the nuance better if you know what the 'kh' and 'dh' sounds are supposed to be), others try to transcribe the Greek alphabet using one of the standard schemes for either ancient or modern Greek (Chalcidice is the classic transliteration), and others do some mixture.
People tend to have strong opinions as well; classicists and etymologists don't like the obscuring of spelling that the phonetic transcriptions produce, but Greeks wince at people pronouncing Halkidiki as if it started with the English word "chalk" and ended with "dice". I imagine many Arabs similarly favor the more phonetic spellings for their names.
- Mafana0 16y agoI totally agree. I'm a native speaker and my Arabic name (ضياء) has no definite, accurate transcription in English for another reason. Arabic language has many letters and sounds western languages don't have equivalents of and therefore foreigners are completely unable no pronounce. Another point is that vowels have different characteristics in different languages; height of the tongue, backness, roundedness, nasalization, ..etc, make it almost impossible to write the correct equivalent for some Arabic vowels in English. For example, we have a word (هيل; means cardamom) whose vowel length is between hail and hell that I can't think of any accurate way to transcript in English.
- DarkShikari 16y agoI don't think vowel differences are sufficient to deem a language impossible to romanize. Japanese has been romanized effectively for decades despite the fact that Japanese vowels are quite different from English ones. I think this comes down to two competing approaches in transliteration: 1. Transcribe the original non-roman text into something that a native English speaker would read correctly without help. This never works well due to vowel differences and accents, but nevertheless it works well enough that it's very popular. An example of this failing horribly: Hiroshima: often pronounced Hih-RO-shih-mah. Actually pronounced Hee-roh-shee-mah (nevermind the Japanese R). 2. Romanization without intent to be pronounceable. Nihon-Shiki romanization seems to use this approach: it's unreadable by English speakers, but unlike other romanization schemes, provides a one-to-one mapping to the original kana, i.e. it loses no information. I think it's important to note as well that "roman letters" != "English"; Nihon-Shiki is an example of this, the creation of roman letters intended to be pronounced by non-English speakers.