3 ms·
The criticism was mainly on the wrong model and wrong data, not the code quality. A good model must be robust and verifiable, this is neither robust nor verifia
by rurban 6y ago
The criticism was mainly on the wrong model and wrong data, not the code quality.
A good model must be robust and verifiable, this is neither robust nor verifiable. Just compare it to a good model, like the Göttingen model with Bayes inference, which successfully predicted results two weeks into the future. Multiple times. https://science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2020/05/14/science.abb9789.full https://science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2020/05/14/scie...
Ferguson's model was always exponentially wrong, you can even say catastrophically wrong given the economic costs.
Nature still defending this catatrophy, interesting. So they also switched to non- science, supporting politics. The political angle is that they want to suppress extreme right-wing shifts as after the last such political/economical crisis 1930, caused by fatefully wrong political decisions. As they happened after and because of the Ferguson study.