5 ms·
I’m also an academic. Hash each paper, then hash the hashes. Publish the result with the proceedings. After year one, include the hash of the prior year(s).
by hedora 6y ago
I’m also an academic. Hash each paper, then hash the hashes. Publish the result with the proceedings. After year one, include the hash of the prior year(s). Problem solved.
Recently I downloaded one of my old peer-reviewed papers. The “archival” service added a spammy logo to the bottom left corner of each page.
I’ve been meaning to find the original and put it on my web page. Honestly, I might just add a list of all my papers with links to SciHub instead.
I’m allowed to post them on my personal web page according to every copyright agreement I recall signing.
- ComodoHacker 6y ago>Problem solved Not at all. There are corrections and amendments. It isn't as complicated as in law, but still.
- sudosysgen 6y agoSigned declarations of amendment, then amended papers being added as new one with proof of amendment and link with the original. Kind of like how a keyserver deals with revoked keys.
- a1369209993 6y agoCorrections and amendments are separate (but related) documents. Preventing them from being retroactively applied to the original version of the source document is the specific thing that a archival-quality document storage is supposed to do (as opposed a non-archival-quality storage, which only needs to protect against data loss (as in turn opposed to a cache, which can rely on a backing storage)).
- ComodoHacker 6y agoLooks like you agree that an archival-quality document storage assumes a bit more than hashing papers. That was my point.
- a1369209993 6y agoIf that was your point, it was very poorly made, since you appeared to be claiming that archival-quality document storage required much more than hashing papers. Archival-quality document storage requires two things: 1, hashing papers; 2, guaranteeing that the preimages of those hashes (ie the papers) remain available despite accidental and deliberate forces toward their destruction. Non-archival-quality document storage already requires thing 2, we just want to add more nines of reliablity to those guarantees, which is a fundamentally technical endeavor that the likes of Springer/Elsevier don't particularly help with.