5 ms·
> A sheet brass disk in front of the fan was acted upon by the air from the fan causing the fan to oscillate back and forth Is this an accurate description? He
by lqet 6y ago
> A sheet brass disk in front of the fan was acted upon by the air from the fan causing the fan to oscillate back and forth
Is this an accurate description? Here is such a fan in action:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cm7DFuGaujg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cm7DFuGaujg
It seems to work because the brass disk is blocking the air stream on one side, so the other side of the fan acts as a jet engine to rotate it, which is actually really clever.
- rrmm 6y agoThe quoted bit seems to take a very neutral stance on exactly how the brass disk is "acted upon". So it's probably correct no matter how things work just due to vagueness.
- jetrink 6y agoWow, that is more violent than I expected! I think both effects are at work. Thought experiment/hypothesis: If you detached the plate and merely held it in front of the fan blades, I think the fan would still rotate due to the decreased airflow on one side of the fan, but it would rotate less quickly since the force that moving air is applying to the plate would no longer be acting on the fan.
- lqet 6y agoYup, I posted the original comment to quickly, the airflow indeed also pushes the brass disk forward, thus rotating the fan! An extremely clever solution that seems to be very easy and cheap to manufacture.
- perilunar 6y ago> the airflow indeed also pushes the brass disk forward The force on the disk is caused by an opposite force on the fan blades, cancelling them out (since they are connected by the frame and the bearings), so it cannot cause the fan to rotate. The rotation is due simply to unbalanced thrust from the fan. The unimpeded side produces more thrust than the impeded side, so the fan turns to that side.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jotm 6y agoThat's some real ingenuity right there!