4 ms·
> "men who get sexual kicks from being treated like women" Many people will not like this, but so-called autogynephilia seems to be a real causal factor behind
by zozbot234 6y ago
> "men who get sexual kicks from being treated like women"
Many people will not like this, but so-called autogynephilia seems to be a real causal factor behind some varieties of gender-dysphoric identity among people assigned-male-at-birth. (To be clear about this, other varieties do exist that involve very different causal paths.) Her language was obviously unkind, but she was pointing at something quite real.
- junke 6y agoThis is Blanchard stuff. Autogynephilia exists (in cis-women too!), but that being a "real causal factor" is disputed: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00918369.2010.486241 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00918369.2010.4...
- CJefferson 6y agoThere might be some basis for truth here, but I was also being polite (you didn't know that from my reply). Let's go full quote, just so people don't get the impression that Magdalen was trying to make a fair and reasoned point: "You are fucking blackface actors. You aren't women. You're men who get sexual kicks from being treated like women. Fuck you and your dirty fucking perversions. Our oppression isn't a fetish you pathetic, sick, fuck".
- zozbot234 6y agoYes, but the reason why that attack is so contentious in the first place is that it hits at a real weakness in trans activism. It was trans activists themselves who first politicized the narrative around things like autogynephilia and rapid-onset dysphoria, by branding these ideas as anti-trans and bigoted no matter how "fair and reasoned" expressed - and this is something that creates real harm, as Rowling obliquely points out by referencing the "detransitioning" trans and contrasting them with folks who took a far more cautious approach to transitioning in the past.
- CJefferson 6y agoFirstly, that attack is conentious because it calls all trans people "sick fucks". That isn't really a conversation topic. Also, I keep hearing about "detransitioning", but can't find any evidence it is actually significantly growing -- numers who regret getting surgery seem to sit around, or below, 1%.