5 ms·
If you want to establish a legal precedent, you can't just go to a court and ask them to. Courts only hear "cases and controversies" -- to establish what the la
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
If you want to establish a legal precedent, you can't just go to a court and ask them to. Courts only hear "cases and controversies" -- to establish what the law is, you have to get somebody to sue you.
The reason this could bankrupt them is mostly because they don't have a lot of money. Their net assets are only a couple million dollars. They have to raise more than that every year just to keep operating.
But it's also because the plaintiffs are vindictive. They know this is about setting a precedent. They don't like the precedent, so they're out for blood. They could have been civilized and only asked for an injunction.
- kyledrake 6y agoCould you site your source for "their net assets are only a couple million dollars"? Knowing the scope of the organization, that number would surprise me.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agohttps://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/943242767 https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/943...
- lowdose 6y agoTotal revenue $20 Million.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoRevenue is not assets.
- nordsieck 6y ago> If you want to establish a legal precedent, you can't just go to a court and ask them to. Courts only hear "cases and controversies" -- to establish what the law is, you have to get somebody to sue you. > The reason this could bankrupt them is mostly because they don't have a lot of money. Their net assets are only a couple million dollars. They have to raise more than that every year just to keep operating. Are you trying to claim that Internet Archive purposely tried to set a precedent, knowing they don't have enough money to actually do it? That sounds like a pretty damning accusation of gross incompetence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- saikia81 6y agoThey can count on support from many. Maybe they have a plan.
- 6510 6y agoWe just pay the bill again and go - meh?
- nordsieck 6y ago> They can count on support from many. Maybe they have a plan. I've looked at the complaint, and I've lived through the Napster trial. It would be one thing if they had a good case and just needed funds to make it through the trial. That's not what's going on here. When you mix statutory copyright violation with digital technology, you get infinite fines. Any money you donate is going to the book publishers at the end of the day.
- salawat 6y ago>Are you trying to claim that Internet Archive purposely tried to set a precedent, knowing they don't have enough money to actually do it? Well, at least there's an implicit admission justice is bought by the highest bidder.
- kerkeslager 6y agoI would rather support organizations that make strategic blunders than organizations which compromise their principles.
- sukilot 6y agoYou can't when organizations make blunders that destroy themselves.
- kerkeslager 6y ago
- bubblethink 6y agoWhat would the precedent be anyway ? It's not a major victory to have some national emergency exception for DMCA.
- abduhl 6y agoSmall point: you don’t technically have to wait until someone sues you. It is possible to seek a declaratory judgment (where a court issues a legal finding) without waiting to be sued. You do have to show that there is an actual controversy before a court will hear you, as you note.
- jacquesm 6y agoCloned from a Monty Python production: you're only making it worse...
- ComputerGuru 6y agoThat’s not a very believable scenario. First, the precedent is not worth much as all it would say is when all libraries in the whole country are closed, they can give away books for free - how often do you see that happening? Second, that’s not how precedent is established: typically a single case is hand-picked to serve as the exception to the rule taking great care to make it as palatable, appealing, and free of recriminations as possible and you take that to the courts. You don’t make available millions of books to billions of people, you make available a book or a hundred books or whatever number that it takes to prove your point without making matters worse for you and opening you up to such a massive liability. Third, you are making my point for me: again, some other website or organization should gamble their entire existence that isn’t worth as much as the Archive to get this precedent: whatever the reason, it’s a massive and hugely irresponsible gamble. It’s not like the Archive doesn’t know what kind of people they are dealing with. They know publishers are out to stop second hand sales, ebook lending, right of resellers to set prices, and a million other things. It’s like expecting the RIAA or the MPAA to settle for an injunction when they have the chance to kill Napster/TPB/IsoTorrent/whatever. If it’s really in order to set a precedent then that’s damn short-sighted.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> First, the precedent is not worth much as all it would say is when all libraries in the whole country are closed, they can give away books for free - how often do you see that happening? You're assuming the country being closed is especially relevant. The point is rather that they had physical books and weren't physically lending them out, in which case they should be able to digitally lend them out. If you're not lending more copies than you have, how is that not a reasonable argument? > typically a single case is hand-picked to serve as the exception to the rule taking great care to make it as palatable, appealing, and free of recriminations as possible and you take that to the courts. It's a well-loved actual library that only wants to lend out its books, what more do you want? And if they'd only lent out a single book, would that have gotten them into court? It had to be enough for the plaintiffs to care. > some other website or organization should gamble their entire existence that isn’t worth as much as the Archive to get this precedent Why? It has to be a real library. You would rather some other library take the risk, or that nobody ever do it? > It’s not like the Archive doesn’t know what kind of people they are dealing with. And that's the point. The people they're dealing with are the bullies and the Archive is supposed to back down? Somebody has to fight the fight.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoThere's no controversy here though. What IA did was plainly on the "not legal" side of the line. (I mean, there are surely some people who believe otherwise, but you can find someone who believes almost anything.)
- waheoo 6y agoLast i checked rosa parks did something illegal too. Not all laws need to be followed. And just because some people will beleive anything doesnt make this belief any less relevant or important.
- phkahler 6y agoRosa Park took a personal risk. People at IA are risking the archive.
- sukilot 6y agoNo, she didn't! Rosa Parks launched a boycott to protest a bus system that was so racist that even the horrific Jim Crow laws weren't enough for bus drivers who kicked off black people (and police officers who arrested them) who had a legal right to their seats. Other protests broke the law with sit-ins.
- mburns 6y agoRosa Parks was arrested and convicted for breaking a city law.
- waheoo 6y agoDont bother, these people have no intention of coming back and changing their minds. They made them up long ago.
- justincredible 6y agoI agree with what she did, so it couldn't have been illegal.
- ori_b 6y agoIf you want to keep providing an important service, you don't try to establish precedents if you can avoid it.
- Spooky23 6y agoYou probably want to be sure you can win. Actual Libraries buy materials and loan them. I don't think that is what archive.org was doing. I don't think the content owners are being bad guys here. I found this initiative really irritating, as there are almost certainly better ways to accomplish the objective legally.