3 ms·
Hitchens is one of the leading intellectuals of our time, as well as a great wit and a master of the English language. Referring to him as "Vanity Fair writer"
by gruseom 18y ago
Hitchens is one of the leading intellectuals of our time, as well as a great wit and a master of the English language. Referring to him as "Vanity Fair writer" is like referring to Orwell as "Former restaurant worker".
- ajross 18y agoDude, he's a pundit. A big name pundit, to be sure, but hardly the second coming of Benjamin Franklin.
- gruseom 18y agoPundits are largely hacks. Hitchens seems to me more in the tradition of the public intellectual (I think Orwell's a fair reference point). He's in the media game but not nearly as much of it as, say, David Brooks. He's also pretty fearless about breaking the rules. Pundits don't do that. I'm really not as big a fan of Hitchens as my comment made it sound. There's just one thing that makes me giddy and that is his fabulous English style. That exquisite combination of literacy and wit really does belong to a great lineage, and I love it. That's probably why the reference to "Vanity Fair writer" got my goat. Todd Purdum is a Vanity Fair writer. Christopher Hitchens is Christopher Hitchens. Since I'm already going on and on about this (and well into baitland for the !HN crowd), I have a couple questions. I'd love to hear some credible answers if anyone's game. So: among the pundit and journalist classes, 1. Who else would have the integrity or the balls to have himself waterboarded in order to be able to write meaningfully about torture? 2. Who else would, or could, ever write something like this: Stone earned himself constant surveillance from an already hostile F.B.I. until the foul racist and pervert J. Edgar Hoover finally turned into carrion on a full-time basis in 1972. Doesn't sound like punditry to me!
- andreyf 18y agoDoesn't sound like punditry to me! Sounds like Christopher Hitchens, one and only :)
- mynameishere 18y agoHitchens is one of the leading intellectuals of our time Sorry, I couldn't downmod that hard or fast enough. Hitchens is a warmed-over Trotskyist. The fact that he ever had doubts about water torture's status as torture should give you a clue into his mental state.
- gruseom 18y agoReally? I'm curious why you say that, and also why you think the two ("warmed-over Trotskyist" and "leading intellectual") must automatically be incompatible. I certainly don't admire him in every respect. But he changed a lot since 1968, and even then had an individualist streak that was a little deviant for the hard left. Edit (responding to your edit :)) - I don't know of any evidence that he doubted it before. I would guess the point of the experiment was more to be able to write about it from experience.
- mynameishere 18y agoI guess I've just recoiled against everything he's said. For a sample, look under the heading "On the 2003 invasion of Iraq". http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Christopher_Hitchens http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Christopher_Hitchens It doesn't warrant much elaboration. I mean, I, for one, will not have [the Vietcong] insulted by any comparison to the forces of Zarqawi, the Fedayeen Saddam, and the criminal underworld now arrayed against us. These depraved elements are the Iraqi Khmer Rouge. Well, whatever. The vietcong [1] are still great heroes to him, I suppose. Fine. But the motivations of ordinary men don't change from place to place, and the various arab defenders and the vietnamese communists are almost surely identical morally. His defense of the Iraqi war is pure mind-fuck. I'm not completely against the war, but I understand its grand strategic purpose: To secure vast and necessary oil reserves from encroachment by Russia and China (the latter has been securing incredible resources in Africa, for example. This is no small threat.) But what's his motivation?--it's impossible to say. He just seems inspired by dead ideology. [1] There was no shortage of atrocities or terrorist acts committed by the vietcong. I understand this as asymmetrical warfare. Hitchens understands this as good vs. evil. Specifically, good.