5 ms·

Please get rid of the flow where it shows me other threads when I click on the comments of a current thread. I'm never going to switch to a new thread from the

by leesec 6y ago

Please get rid of the flow where it shows me other threads when I click on the comments of a current thread. I'm never going to switch to a new thread from the comments. I just want to read the comments.

apatters 6y ago
Why don't we just tell it like it is? The majority of comments here reflect the fact that Reddit is a garbage site run by a garbage company. Used to be great, more garbage every day. They leverage network effect to abuse their users and to suck. I look forward to the day they fail and the free market replaces them.
- 0xy 6y ago
  The quality of engineering is certainly either just totally incompetent or willfully bad. The new site is a mess. It's mind-bogglingly slow, and it feels like it was built by 10 junior React engineers who were given 3 weeks to complete it. It's worse in every way. Significantly slower, less information, more ads, more distractions, dark patterns everywhere and it just looks bad. When you see the behavior of the leadership of the company it's no surprise they manage this level of incompetence. The manipulation by power mods, advertising agencies and political shills is unparalleled.
- MrJagil 6y ago
  I have quite an intricate system build up to get the most quality out of reddit as poossible —it’s still quite bad, but it’s better. I have been thinking of making a blog post or soemthing about it. - I have a multireddit with select magic the gathering subs - I have a multireddit with select tech subs - I have a multireddit with general high quality subs - My “all” feed has HUNDREDS of subs filtered off. This is a life long excersice. Whenever I see a meme on “all”, i filter that sub away. I have customized FB as well, removing every CS element on the site except the shortcuts list for groups on the left, where I can acess a few important groups. My main problem is Twitter now. Why the fuck is every american news in the form of a tweet? The site is awful to use, and I really don’t want anothet SoMe account.
  - mistermann 6y ago
    I would love to read such a blog post!
  - divslinger 6y ago
    Muting words on Twitter might help
    - whywhywhywhy 6y ago
      I mute 3000+ accounts and 300+ words. It doesn't really help, every time something happens in America theres a new word you have to mute, also Twitter doesn't respect certain hashtags mutes if they have a custom icon and people retweeting things bypasses the mutes sometimes. Twitter could easily just solve all this by adding a huge "Politics On/Off" switch in their preferences and then people who for mental health reasons or just because they're not there for that (e.g brand customer support workers) but they'd never do that because I suspect they ideologically think its more important to control the flow of political information that is broadcast to their users even if its at a great detriment to their users mental health. I don't want to be on Twitter, I was forced on Twitter because RSS was killed by Google Reader and all the journos/bloggers said "Just use Twitter, whats the big deal" now the only way to get the information I used to get before is with an unwanted side order of politics.
  - MultusSalus 6y ago
    Depending on what exactly you want, nitter.net is a fairly good twitter client, although you need to use an rss reader to follow particular accounts.
    - MrJagil 6y ago
      wow, thanks. EDIT: here are ways to automate https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Extensions https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Extensions
- ianamartin 6y ago
  Oh come on. Reddit was never great. It has always been the taint of the internet. There are worse places to hang out, but not by much.
- dang 6y ago
  I feel you, but alas it's by no means guaranteed that the "free market" would replace it with anything better. The same pressures would exist on any replacement, and those pressures all point to what you're calling garbage. We're lucky that something as quirky as Reddit got to succeed as well as it did. It would be awesome if we could collectively get to the point where growth didn't have to trump everything else, so exploiting people's attention didn't have to dominate everything else, so more interesting and long-term satisfying things could flourish. It's unfortunately not clear what the path from here to there might look like. I think about this a lot because Hacker News, for all its problems and fractiousness, is in sort of a blessed position where we're not subject to those same pressures and can optimize for other things. But it's also two orders of magnitude smaller than Reddit, which means we're not facing the same problems at all. If I think about facing those problems at that scale, the phrases 'sheer terror' and 'passing out' come to mind.
  - apatters 6y ago
    You do an incredible job with Hacker News! For those of us interested in the subject matter I feel this place is in the top 5 sites on the Internet. The irony here is that while Hacker News is not growth-driven and that's surely part of what makes it great, the bills are paid by a firm that couldn't be more focused on growth. Here's a thought, which is probably far too political for its own good but oh well. The characteristics of the software industry (both the ones we love and hate) boil in great part down to IP and business law... why not get behind legal reforms that would mitigate the growth at all cost environment. For instance if America had a better antitrust framework then some of the more predatory business plans out there might never have been written. And Stallman, the FSF etc. have been out there for many years pushing us to think about IP in a way that has had enormous societal benefits.
  - ceilingcorner 6y ago
    I’ve often thought that the only way a reasonable media source / online forum can survive and maintain its values is as an add-on project to something else. The profit motive doesn’t seem to function well when it comes to information.
- ansTQLLA 6y ago
  You can find any number of comments on Reddit but also on Slashdot (at least up to 2015 or so) whose quality is higher than many comments here. They are drowned in the noise, but on Reddit it is very easy to read past the noise. Here the noise is usually someone trying to sell you something while pretending to be innocent or defending his employer while pretending to be innocent. Much harder to read past that, also since the moderation claims it never happens.
jabroni_salad 6y ago
I'm not logged in to reddit on my work machine but sometimes end up there during research. Using one of the old reddit redirect extensions is the only way to have a decent experience while logged out. Whoever decided to only show two comments with no children for the current post for logged-out users is scum. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-reddit-redirect/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-reddit-re... https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirect/dneaehbmnbhcippjikoajpoabadpodje https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirec...
DoingIsLearning 6y ago
I am almost unwilling to advertise this, out of fear that they might disable it if it gains a lot of traffic. But... reddit has older versions still online. Desktop: old.reddit.com Mobile: reddit.com/.compact In fact you can just append the '.compact' to any reddit link on mobile and it will render it more sanely. The day either of these features get disabled, is the day I will stop using the platform. edit: typo
- swarnie_ 6y ago
  old.reddit.com along with the RES plugin and an ad blocker almost make the site usable. I have no idea how people use the new layout with a standard browser.
- 0-O-0 6y ago
  For now you can opt-out from redesign in reddit settings.
  - worble 6y ago
    I leave this turned off just so their analytics show me bounce to old reddit every time I get the new one. Luckily I don't browse it enough for this to be a large inconvenience for me.
  - cmdshiftf4 6y ago
    There's also browser extensions that will redirect all traffic to reddit.com to old.reddit.com, for those of you who want to browse the site in its ok-to-use form and not create an account.
whywhywhywhy 6y ago
>I'm never going to switch to a new thread from the comments. I just want to read the comments. You might not, I might not but someone must be? I guess... because even Twitter is choosing to just show random tweets from elsewhere under a tweet now instead of the replies.
conradfr 6y ago
The Twitter mobile site does this and it's infuriating. You read the thread and suddenly the content does not totally makes sense in the conversation, until you realize the dark pattern and that you actively have to click a link above to see the rest of the thread.

by leesec 6y ago

apatters 6y ago

Why don't we just tell it like it is? The majority of comments here reflect the fact that Reddit is a garbage site run by a garbage company. Used to be great, more garbage every day. They leverage network effect to abuse their users and to suck. I look forward to the day they fail and the free market replaces them.

0xy 6y ago
The quality of engineering is certainly either just totally incompetent or willfully bad. The new site is a mess. It's mind-bogglingly slow, and it feels like it was built by 10 junior React engineers who were given 3 weeks to complete it. It's worse in every way. Significantly slower, less information, more ads, more distractions, dark patterns everywhere and it just looks bad. When you see the behavior of the leadership of the company it's no surprise they manage this level of incompetence. The manipulation by power mods, advertising agencies and political shills is unparalleled.
MrJagil 6y ago
I have quite an intricate system build up to get the most quality out of reddit as poossible —it’s still quite bad, but it’s better. I have been thinking of making a blog post or soemthing about it. - I have a multireddit with select magic the gathering subs - I have a multireddit with select tech subs - I have a multireddit with general high quality subs - My “all” feed has HUNDREDS of subs filtered off. This is a life long excersice. Whenever I see a meme on “all”, i filter that sub away. I have customized FB as well, removing every CS element on the site except the shortcuts list for groups on the left, where I can acess a few important groups. My main problem is Twitter now. Why the fuck is every american news in the form of a tweet? The site is awful to use, and I really don’t want anothet SoMe account.
- mistermann 6y ago
  I would love to read such a blog post!
- divslinger 6y ago
  Muting words on Twitter might help
  - whywhywhywhy 6y ago
    I mute 3000+ accounts and 300+ words. It doesn't really help, every time something happens in America theres a new word you have to mute, also Twitter doesn't respect certain hashtags mutes if they have a custom icon and people retweeting things bypasses the mutes sometimes. Twitter could easily just solve all this by adding a huge "Politics On/Off" switch in their preferences and then people who for mental health reasons or just because they're not there for that (e.g brand customer support workers) but they'd never do that because I suspect they ideologically think its more important to control the flow of political information that is broadcast to their users even if its at a great detriment to their users mental health. I don't want to be on Twitter, I was forced on Twitter because RSS was killed by Google Reader and all the journos/bloggers said "Just use Twitter, whats the big deal" now the only way to get the information I used to get before is with an unwanted side order of politics.
- MultusSalus 6y ago
  Depending on what exactly you want, nitter.net is a fairly good twitter client, although you need to use an rss reader to follow particular accounts.
  - MrJagil 6y ago
    wow, thanks. EDIT: here are ways to automate https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Extensions https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Extensions
ianamartin 6y ago
Oh come on. Reddit was never great. It has always been the taint of the internet. There are worse places to hang out, but not by much.
dang 6y ago
I feel you, but alas it's by no means guaranteed that the "free market" would replace it with anything better. The same pressures would exist on any replacement, and those pressures all point to what you're calling garbage. We're lucky that something as quirky as Reddit got to succeed as well as it did. It would be awesome if we could collectively get to the point where growth didn't have to trump everything else, so exploiting people's attention didn't have to dominate everything else, so more interesting and long-term satisfying things could flourish. It's unfortunately not clear what the path from here to there might look like. I think about this a lot because Hacker News, for all its problems and fractiousness, is in sort of a blessed position where we're not subject to those same pressures and can optimize for other things. But it's also two orders of magnitude smaller than Reddit, which means we're not facing the same problems at all. If I think about facing those problems at that scale, the phrases 'sheer terror' and 'passing out' come to mind.
- apatters 6y ago
  You do an incredible job with Hacker News! For those of us interested in the subject matter I feel this place is in the top 5 sites on the Internet. The irony here is that while Hacker News is not growth-driven and that's surely part of what makes it great, the bills are paid by a firm that couldn't be more focused on growth. Here's a thought, which is probably far too political for its own good but oh well. The characteristics of the software industry (both the ones we love and hate) boil in great part down to IP and business law... why not get behind legal reforms that would mitigate the growth at all cost environment. For instance if America had a better antitrust framework then some of the more predatory business plans out there might never have been written. And Stallman, the FSF etc. have been out there for many years pushing us to think about IP in a way that has had enormous societal benefits.
- ceilingcorner 6y ago
  I’ve often thought that the only way a reasonable media source / online forum can survive and maintain its values is as an add-on project to something else. The profit motive doesn’t seem to function well when it comes to information.
ansTQLLA 6y ago
You can find any number of comments on Reddit but also on Slashdot (at least up to 2015 or so) whose quality is higher than many comments here. They are drowned in the noise, but on Reddit it is very easy to read past the noise. Here the noise is usually someone trying to sell you something while pretending to be innocent or defending his employer while pretending to be innocent. Much harder to read past that, also since the moderation claims it never happens.

jabroni_salad 6y ago

I'm not logged in to reddit on my work machine but sometimes end up there during research. Using one of the old reddit redirect extensions is the only way to have a decent experience while logged out. Whoever decided to only show two comments with no children for the current post for logged-out users is scum. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-reddit-redirect/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-reddit-re... https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirect/dneaehbmnbhcippjikoajpoabadpodje https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirec...

DoingIsLearning 6y ago

I am almost unwilling to advertise this, out of fear that they might disable it if it gains a lot of traffic. But... reddit has older versions still online. Desktop: old.reddit.com Mobile: reddit.com/.compact In fact you can just append the '.compact' to any reddit link on mobile and it will render it more sanely. The day either of these features get disabled, is the day I will stop using the platform. edit: typo

swarnie_ 6y ago
old.reddit.com along with the RES plugin and an ad blocker almost make the site usable. I have no idea how people use the new layout with a standard browser.
0-O-0 6y ago
For now you can opt-out from redesign in reddit settings.
- worble 6y ago
  I leave this turned off just so their analytics show me bounce to old reddit every time I get the new one. Luckily I don't browse it enough for this to be a large inconvenience for me.
- cmdshiftf4 6y ago
  There's also browser extensions that will redirect all traffic to reddit.com to old.reddit.com, for those of you who want to browse the site in its ok-to-use form and not create an account.

whywhywhywhy 6y ago

>I'm never going to switch to a new thread from the comments. I just want to read the comments. You might not, I might not but someone must be? I guess... because even Twitter is choosing to just show random tweets from elsewhere under a tweet now instead of the replies.

conradfr 6y ago

The Twitter mobile site does this and it's infuriating. You read the thread and suddenly the content does not totally makes sense in the conversation, until you realize the dark pattern and that you actively have to click a link above to see the rest of the thread.