8 ms·
Genuine question: why? I completely understand acquisitions that create value by providing economies of scale, monopoly power or network benefits, or diversify
by crazygringo 6y ago
Genuine question: why?
I completely understand acquisitions that create value by providing economies of scale, monopoly power or network benefits, or diversify or complement a company's activities.
But for a European market leader to buy an American market leader in what is ultimately an extremely local business... I see no real added benefit here.
Few further economies of scale when you're already at continent-size for an ultimately "local" business, no monopoly or network benefits, and zero diversification.
If this were manufacturing or retail then benefits are pretty obvious.
But in this case, what am I missing? How on earth does this justify a 27 percent premium on GrubHub? It is purely a strategic defensive move to prevent Uber from buying it, and nothing more?
- saos 6y agoCompetition... monoply. Ubers Eats and Deliveroo have massive control. I think what many of the players are concerned about is Amazon entering the market via Deliveroo investment of $500m. https://www.gov.uk/cma-cases/amazon-deliveroo-merger-inquiry https://www.gov.uk/cma-cases/amazon-deliveroo-merger-inquiry
- JAlexoid 6y agoFYI Amazon already left the "hot" food delivery market. Amazon Restaurants was killed
- saos 6y agoYes, I did mention that in my own comment. I can only imagine Amazon are desperate to re-enter... I mean they seem set-up for this to happen eg infrastructure. Hence, why they are investing in Deliveroo, who are also setup pretty well. In fact I reckon the investment in Deliveroo and potential acquisition of Grubhub by Uber is what shook Takeaway.com (Just Eat) into this panic buy haha
- allworknoplay 6y ago* They may expect to achieve efficiencies with the business that will throw off more profit. * They may be protecting their own territory from grubhub's eventual entry. * They may simply have extra cash (or stock purchasing power) and want to use it to secure greater future cash flows rather than just sit on it. * They may feel more able to enter other markets via grubhub than their own brand/company. etc. Edit: Also, acquisition premia reflect benefits that derive from taking a business business private, including control over the timing of dividends, no worries about control/governance, a larger-than-expected reduction in hard costs of compliance, and other factors, in addition to some of the benefits I mentioned above.
- koolba 6y agoThe economics of food delivery can’t be solved with efficiency. There’s not enough pie to split.
- cordite 6y agoHave you tried pizza pie? But really, the economics are all in operations and scale. Some people may complain that they can’t get delivery 10 miles away from a restaurant.. but they aren’t willing to tip or pay higher for the back and forth a driver must do to earn more than it costs to pay them. Cutting to 5 or even 3 miles for delivery ranges makes a big difference for orders per hour.
- _jal 6y agoThe economics are that when you insert a multinational between a local restaurant and a local hungry person, revenue to the restaurant drops, prices paid by the customer rise, and service gets worse. This is why after a couple orders right at the start of lockdown, I started calling restaurants directly. Some of them are delivering in breach of their contracts on the side, the rest I just walk over and pick up.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago
- bradleyjg 6y agoMergers and acquisitions rarely work out for the entities as such. To understand why they nonetheless continue to happen so often it’s necessary to peer beyond the corporate veil and look at the incentives of the individual players.
- granzymes 6y ago>Mergers and acquisitions rarely work out for the entities as such. Could you provide a source for that?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- twunde 6y agoAn oft-cited HBR article, https://hbr.org/2016/06/ma-the-one-thing-you-need-to-get-right https://hbr.org/2016/06/ma-the-one-thing-you-need-to-get-rig..., states that 70-90% of acquisitions are considered failures.
- Closi 6y agoOne of the things that article overlooks though is that almost all multinational companies wouldn’t be what they are today without acquisition and inorganic growth. Even that article says it: if Google avoided acquisitions they wouldn’t have Android and YouTube. Disney wouldn’t have Pixar and Fox. The biggest companies in the world would be different - and for the surviving multinationals often their acquisitions defined their current business. Some of this is successful, some of this is a failure, but it’s a game that a lot of companies needed to play to achieve their current market position. In fact, in some markets not touching M&A means not growing your core business (eg some retailers), and some big businesses may not exist anymore if they didn’t do the acquisitions they did.
- megablast 6y agoHow different would Disney be without Pixar? Not different at all. And fox? Too early to tell.
- vsareto 6y agoFirst step to becoming a global company maybe?
- rajangdavis 6y agoOne broad thing I can think of is that there aren't strict GDPR requirements in the United States. Might be the case the value of user data alone might make the sale worth it, but I am speculating here.
- vikramkr 6y agoJust Eat Takeaway seems to be a recent creation through the takeover of just eat by takeaway. With another acquisition so soon, I think you'd find some answers if you look at how management there is compensated. If you have a willing/uninvolved board (or a board that still loves the idea of rollup companies that grow through M&A), and aquisitions help you hit a few targets (total revenues, total market cap) that get you a bonus, well, you can see where that goes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dehrmann 6y ago> providing economies of scale Developing a single platform counts as that. I guess it depends on how big fixed costs are compared to variable costs more than if you're the market leader. If they're a large component of them, then an acquisition could really help. Looks like their 2019Q4 total revenue was $1.3B, cost of revenue was $790M, and opex was $530M. I assume the hope is to save a lot on opex. > diversify or complement a company's activities. A US business similar to the European one fits here.
- mmmBacon 6y agoI’m not convinced that unifying the tech stacks here really buys much in the way of value for a food delivery business. The real value is the business relationship with the delivery network. A deal that expands the delivery network and adds value to customers through reduced delivery times and improved overall service is the thing that scales.
- replyguy912 6y agoThis is an all stock deal, so valuations are about as realistic as a televised poker tournament. No one is paying a 27% premium in cash; they're spending their own ridiculously valued stock. There is no business model in the world that makes grubhub a 7B company. If proven wrong I will gladly eat a hat delivered by them.
- martin_bech 6y agoJust Eat had a very nice profit of 101m GBP, so the business model works. However Grubhub is not that impressive, with a 12% YoY Growth, Compared to Just-Eats 43%. From Grubhub "Revenues: $363.0 million, a 12% year-over-year increase from $323.8 million in the first quarter of 2019."
- franczesko 6y agoIt's a winner takes all niche. Either you reach a point of scale or never see a break even. Takeaway wiped out the competition in EU and it was a billion € marketing budgets battle.
- ciceryadam 6y agoTax optimization - easier to funnel out money if all your subsidiaries are lending IP belonging to the same company in the Cayman Islands. Bigger the market, more "lending" from the tax-free IP holder, and less taxes payed on both sides of the Pond.