5 ms·
I'd go a step further and suggest that all of the new gTLDs are pointless and idiotic: - .aero: if IATA airport codes were all registered domains here, it migh
by duskwuff 16y ago
I'd go a step further and suggest that all of the new gTLDs are pointless and idiotic:
- .aero: if IATA airport codes were all registered domains here, it might be useful, but they aren't, so it isn't.
- .asia: asia is definitely a country </sarcasm>
- .biz: sufficiently stupid that SpamAssassin has a rule for it
- .cat: meow? seriously, I've only seen this used for vanity joke domains
- .coop: there isn't a .llc, why is this any different?
- .info: happy fun SEO land
- .jobs: pity they won't take my registration for Blow, Inc.
- .mobi: as noted
- .museum: 1138 registered domains in 10 years is a sign of true irrelevance
- .name: personal names are hardly unique identifiers
- .pro: stupid hierarchy makes this one even more useless than you'd think
- .tel: as noted
- .travel: because .aero just wasn't enough
- .xxx: as noted
Perhaps I'm just not seeing the possibilities, but I suspect that there's no future for any of the gTLDs beyond com/net/org, and possibly a few of the up-and-coming IDN gTLDs. The future of domain names is really in better unique names, not a more complex hierarchy.
- light3 16y agoHey come on there has to be uses, such as lol.cat(taken), malay.asia(taken), steve.jobs(not taken).
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jarin 16y agoI agree that pretty much all of those are dumb, but I still think there should be a .app TLD, if only because there are so many perfectly good .com names just sitting on parking pages (and I would totally use .app domains). Plus it just rolls off the tongue and there's no weird confusion on the spelling.
- laktek 16y agoI too think .app would be a good fit as a gTLD, compared to dumb gTLDs exist today..
- duskwuff 16y agoThat would actually make sense and solve a real problem. As such, I'm pretty sure it'll never happen. ;)
- jarin 16y agoI'm really, seriously considering the idea of raising some money to cover the registration fee ($50,000). Trying to figure out now if there are more fees involved. I'm confident I can build a complete registrar and global DNS setup in 5 years (or however long it takes to get through their process).
- citricsquid 16y agowhoa there, slow down, there's .cat?!
- die_sekte 16y agoCatalan culture. A regional-cultural TLD. If small countries get TLDs, why shouldn't a tightly connected culture of ~5 million get one too?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- anghyflawn 16y agoI'm all for .cat, but I can see the arguments against. People are already campaigning for .cym for Wales, so where do we stop? Do all the regional communities on Spain get one (Basque country, Asturias, Galicia, the list goes on). Do the Saami in Scandinavia get one? (They have their own parliaments, so why not TLDs?) What about Native Americans / First Nations? At least being a country is a criterion that works 95+ percent of the time
- heyitsnick 16y ago>> People are already campaigning for .cym for Wales, so where do we stop? Wales is recognised as a country, not a "regional community"
- anghyflawn 16y agoUm, actually the constitutional status of Wales is a murky topic, and even if that were to be cleared up unambiguously, how do you compare statuses across constitutions?
- heyitsnick 16y agoIt's really not that murky. I'm hard pushed to find any organisation that doesn't classify Wales as a country.
- lsc 16y agoThey are operationally useless, yes. However, they are not meant to be operationally useful. They are meant to be vehicles for extracting money from domainers. So yeah, something useless is getting sold to "investors" - what else is new? and in this case, it takes money from those "investors" that would otherwise be used squatting on useful .com and .net domains, causing those of us who actually want to /use/ a domain to use longer and less-memorable names. So, as far as I'm concerned, this is a net win.
- duskwuff 16y agoMost of them aren't even accomplishing that, though. Many of the new gTLDs (like .cat, .aero, and .jobs) have restrictions on ownership and usage which make them worthless to speculators; the rest just don't have the name recognition that the Big Three do.
- hsmyers 16y agoOh come on--- I kind of like .museum. Be even better if a few more folks actually used it...
- gaius 16y agoMuseums probably belong in .edu (or .ac.uk here), but some haven't bothered with all that TLD malarkey (e.g. the British Library is simply www.bl.uk)
- wladimir 16y agoI think the idea of .museum is to group all museums on a global level, instead of an arbitrary per-country or local level. It does make (some) sense.
- duskwuff 16y agoIt might have made a bit of sense at that level when the TLD was created in 2001, but the wide availability of excellent web directories and search engines has long since made that a moot point.
- ldite 16y agoI quite like their http://the.british.museum/ http://the.british.museum/ url
- the_imp 16y ago... which redirects to http://www.britishmuseum.org/ http://www.britishmuseum.org/ .
- tommorris 16y agoThe UK has some interesting ones: http://bl.uk/ http://bl.uk/ (British Library) http://nhs.uk/ http://nhs.uk/ (National Health Service) http://police.uk/ http://police.uk/ (takes you to a page which links to all the individual police forces) http://mod.uk/ http://mod.uk/ (Ministry of Defence)
- ahi 16y agoIn defense of .coop, .com and .org are rather poor fits for many cooperatives. However, I think TLDs are rather pointless and idiotic in general.
- lawnchair_larry 16y ago> - .jobs: pity they won't take my registration for Blow, Inc. They did take RIM... (http://rim.jobs http://rim.jobs is Research In Motion's careers site)