8 ms·
Someone paid $2.6M in fees to move $134 worth of cryptocurrency
- Hamuko 6y agoCryptocurrency won't work as a general use currency as long as this is possible and irreversible. So basically, it won't work.
- aeternum 6y agoI'm not convinced that is true. Tools can be written to validate amounts carefully. Wire-fraud is also relatively common and often not reversible but people and businesses still wire money frequently. Also happens with HFT: https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-19214294 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-19214294
- google234123 6y agoA general use currency != HFT.
- crimsonalucard1 6y agoIt is reversible. If you make a mistake like this oftentimes you can rely on law enforcement/bank to force the money to be given back. Not sure if this is possible with crypto.
- rootsudo 6y agoIf anyone read, it was reversed at 50% the cost.
- Hamuko 6y agoIt wasn't reversed. The beneficiary just agreed to give half of it back.
- everfree 6y agoOften it's not reversible in practice, if the destination bank/jurisdiction is not cooperative. This is why you hear people losing their life savings to scammers in Nigeria, instead of just successfully suing them to get it back.
- crimsonalucard1 6y agoYeah but usually that's not the case. Usually you can get it back. I would say more often than not it's reversible.
- smachiz 6y ago> Can a Transfer Be Reversed After Being Accepted? Once a wire transfer has been accepted by the recipient's bank, there are only a few circumstances that allow for the reversal of the wire transfer under the Uniform Commercial Code. > The only available options for reversing a completed transfer are if the sending bank made a mistake, if the payment order was a duplicate of a previous order, or if the order is for an amount greater than the beneficiary was entitled to receive under the transfer. In those cases, the beneficiary's bank will recover the funds improperly paid to the beneficiary. https://budgeting.thenest.com/time-frame-reversing-wire-transfer-33881.html https://budgeting.thenest.com/time-frame-reversing-wire-tran...
- lucd 6y agohttps://etherscan.io/tx/0xca8f8c315c8b6c48cee0675677b786d1babe726773829a588efa500b71cbdb65 https://etherscan.io/tx/0xca8f8c315c8b6c48cee0675677b786d1ba...
- m3kw9 6y agoCan is a large word, you need to standardize it, which is what’s needed and it’s a long way to go.
- everfree 6y agoBank wires let you send money to the wrong place and are largely irreversible. The solution is for your bank to double check your transaction and refuse to send a wire with a typo'd destination. Likewise, the solution for crypto is for your wallet software to check your transaction and refuse to send it if it has an exorbitant transaction fee.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoI trust my bank and the legal framework more than wallet software and a loose band of SWEs running a blockchain or DLT. If funds are wired to the wrong person in your jurisdiction, you can sue to recover it if the sending and receiving institutions can't claw it back. With crypto, you're SOL. Technology doesn't fix trust and legal issues, and a judge is going to laugh an immutable ledger out of a courtroom (or hold you in contempt). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15RTC22Z2xI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15RTC22Z2xI [HBR: Blockchains Are a Bad Idea (James Mickens)]
- anamexis 6y agoWhy couldn't you sue to recover the crypto?
- toomuchtodo 6y agoLack of KYC (Know Your Customer [1]) and AML (Anti Money Laundering processes [2]) makes it more difficult to know who to pursue legally. Your US bank account or brokerage account is tied to your social security number and other PII. Who and where to process serve is much more accessible. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-money_laundering_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-money_laundering_software
- camjohnson26 6y agoWhy would you send currency to an address if you haven’t verified its identity. The tools are young, if there aren’t enough controls for you yet then don’t use them. I don’t, but I respect the power of the technology and it’s future potential.
- nwsm 6y agoThis doesn't seem drastically different from your bank working with you to get back money you wired to the wrong account.
- Hamuko 6y agoIn what way?
- FalconSensei 6y agoIt wasn't a wire to the wrong account. In ETH, you set the fee yo are going to pay the miner for the transaction. Imagine this: you want to transfer $1000 to your your friend. You put your friend's correct account, $1000 as transaction fee, and $10 as transfer. Your friend receives $10, the miner receives $1000. Never going to happen with a bank, as you don't offer a transaction fee to someone.
- schoen 6y agoWell, you do offer a transaction fee to the bank (if you're in the U.S. where these transfers aren't free of charge), but presumably the bank has a fixed fee schedule for that and you don't specify a fee of your choice. A closer analogy might be a service where you can offer a tip by typing or writing a tip amount. In restaurants, if paying by credit card, you have to manually add the tip amount to the total in order to guard against mistakes in your intention (both through fraud and through your own error). Some online services like food delivery may let you specify an arbitrary tip just by typing it in, and I'm sure people make mistakes in the amount all the time (e.g. $44 instead of $4, or $80 instead of $8.00), though the web sites probably also have a limit on the tip value, so you'll usually only see mistakes of one order of magnitude rather than six.
- FalconSensei 6y agoThey are not free of charge, but it's not up to YOU to type in the value, right? At least in Canada and Brazil, the fee is set up/calculated by the bank, depending on the type of transaction and value. So you choose the transfer type, input value, and they tell you the fee. And it's NOT going to be $2 million (at least for $100 transfers)
- nix23 6y agoThe future of Crypto's are in free transactions, like IOTA and brothers.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoI have never seen anyone able to explain why IOTA isn't nonsense and a scam. They seem to claim that trinary encryption and trinary processors are going to be revolutionary for some reason. They have been claimed decentralization is coming since it was created, but there has never been an explanation for how that will even work.
- nytf3 6y agoIOTA is vaporware and gives all blockchain projects a bad reputation by association. You are right on your points and forget that they rolled their own elliptic curve so you cant use a wallet twice.
- nix23 6y agoComplete BS, of course you can use your wallet twice, but not the receiving seed, that's why you have to generate for each transaction a new seed. EDIT: In other words every seed could just be used for one transaction...but that has nothing todo with your wallet-seed EDIT2: And its not a elliptic-curve but a direct acyclic graph https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directed_acyclic_graph https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directed_acyclic_graph
- nytf3 6y agoelliptic curve is a type signing algorithm (like blake2b or sha). if you dont understand what an EC is i dont think you also understand why rolling your own would be a bad idea. the wallet/account seed (your post is semantics in my opinion, whichever seed it is you can only use once, which is a flaw) is directly related again to this issue.
- 6y ago
- gremlinsinc 6y agoIf you hand someone a million in cash. Then find out they gave you bad goods or an empty container, how do you get $$ back if they're long gone? want safety here? you'd probably use escrow or something. Not a bitcoin fan, more because of its fluctuating values, but this specific reasoning doesn't set itself apart from cash.
- koolba 6y agoSounds like vanilla money laundering.
- refurb 6y agoThat was my first thought. “Where did this money come from? I made it trading cryptocurrency and paid taxes on it.”
- gruez 6y agoIs this something that happens a lot? If you're a miner and this happens to you once every few years, that might be plausible, but if it's happening multiple times a year the IRS/FBI might get suspicious.
- dezmou 6y agoI am not expert in blockchain but how can you wash money with transaction fees, you can't know where the fee are going, right ?
- brokensegue 6y agoYou can if the miner is doing the laundering
- itake 6y agoHow would you know which miner would get the fee?
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoBy only giving the transaction to one specific miner.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lostmyoldone 6y agoI don't know the specifics of etherum, I actually do think they are somewhat robust against the more trivial attacks. However, in some blockchains it is absolutely feasible to become a majority miner for a short period of time by simply renting cloud resources. If the network is further temporarily reduced due to internet connectivity flapping/segmentation, it might be cheap. 1) Situate yourself in a country with poor connectivity. 2) Trip a breaker to zap most of the connectivity 3) Spin up a gazillion cloud instances 4) Compete more-or-less only with national miners.
- abbadadda 6y agoThis seems like an easy thing to test for? "Like, are you sure you wanted to pay 19,403x in fees over what you're transferring? Please submit again if yes." Unreal.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Kiro 6y agoWhere would this test happen? There's no official interface. Sure, it can be (and probably is) implemented in different wallets but if you're interacting with the blockchain directly no-one can prevent you from doing stupid things like this.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoA smart contract wallet like argent could easily prevent this.
- gruez 6y agoIt is. For instance, bitcoin core will refuse to broadcast transactions with unreasonably high fees. https://bitcoin-rpc.github.io/en/doc/0.16.0/rpc/rawtransactions/sendrawtransaction/ https://bitcoin-rpc.github.io/en/doc/0.16.0/rpc/rawtransacti...
- duxup 6y agoWho is the fee paid to in this case?
- schoen 6y agoIn Bitcoin it would be paid to the miner of the individual block where the transaction appears; I assume the same is true for Ethereum. (The miner, as part of the mining process, specifies an address where the network mining reward as well as the fees in the block are deemed to be sent.) Edit: yes, Ethereum uses the same concept here and there is a field in the block header for the miner's address, which is how the miner gets paid for mining. Edit 2: In this case a parsed version of the Ethereum block in question, linked to from the article, is at https://etherscan.io/block/10237208 https://etherscan.io/block/10237208 and shows that the miner was "Spark Pool" (a mining consortium based in China, https://www.sparkpool.com/en/ https://www.sparkpool.com/en/). Mining pools aren't required to identify themselves, but identifying themselves may create goodwill, for example by slightly assuaging fears that one entity secretly controls mining on an entire chain, and might help pools to market themselves to prospective members or investors.
- duxup 6y agoThank you.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> Coindesk reported at the time that the South Korean blockchain firm behind the error admitted to the mistake, contacted the mining pool that had benefitted, and worked out a deal where the firm got half of the accidentally sent ETH returned. Notably, that partial happy ending 100 percent relied on the goodwill of the mining pool, as ETH transactions are non-reversible by design. If cryptocurrency use increases it will eventually approach how real currency is used with defacto Know Your Customer and reversibility.
- lgl 6y agoFrom the article: > In February of 2019, someone accidentally paid 2,100 ETH in fees to move .1 ETH. Coindesk reported at the time that the South Korean blockchain firm behind the error admitted to the mistake, contacted the mining pool that had benefitted, and worked out a deal where the firm got half of the accidentally sent ETH returned. Who wouldn't want to live in a cryptocurrency powered world economy, right? No mistakes allowed, no insurances, so many nice guys like these. What could go wrong?
- pxeboot 6y agoLike cash, these properties are also desired in many cases.
- EGreg 6y agoI disagree. You can build conflict resolution on top of the database. Can we say the same about voting or other data? That we don’t want consistency in the database? The flipside is anyone can change your vote or your balance as long as they get access to the keys.
- m3kw9 6y agoYou want decentralized you get these “issues”. Even if the protocol had features to reverse some situations, there are way too many that is complex and need human intervention to resolve for many cases, which becomes some what centralized again. They need to solve these things where your life savings can be lost by accident, guarantees etc. Banks do that either you believe it or not.
- TrackerFF 6y ago"The market will regulate itself, by rewarding the honest players and punishing the dishonest ones"
- gremlinsinc 6y agoNo drug lord ever lost a case of fiat? What about pirate treasure? Bank fraud? Nothing is fully secure. Better option is some time limit for accidents or buyers remorse built into ther protocol...
- smaili 6y agoIt's strange that with major currencies having these high fees, people haven't moved to Nano since their entire premise is around being feeless.
- nytf3 6y agothe lack of awareness around nano is puzzling to me. I assume its because nano became known around the end of 2017 along with many scam coins, and thus became associated with them. but today if you described implementing a gossip protocol with nanos features (permissionless decentralization, 0 fees, <1s tx), many people would say it is impossible, but here we are with a 4 year mainnet with no serious issues
- _bxg1 6y agoWhy do you manually enter your own transaction fee at all? Is it not just a percentage of the transaction amount? What happens if you enter too small a fee?
- sprokolopolis 6y agoThe article states: "Ethereum users can dictate the terms of their transactions, setting both the amount of ETH they want to send and the amount of fees they are willing to pay. The higher the fee, the thinking goes, the more likely their transaction will be included on the next block — i.e. it will go through more quickly."
- DSMan195276 6y agoI'm not entirely sure if you've used Bitcoin before, but the transaction fee is basically a way to pay a miner to put your transaction into the block they're mining. A higher fee gives miners a higher incentive to add your transaction. But it's generally just a flat value, not tied to the amount being transferred in the transaction - don't think of it as a tip, think of it as paying the miners to take your transaction. Depending on the digital currency you're using, adding too small of a fee may mean your transaction is never added to a block and thus never actually happens. For Bitcoin in particular I haven't been paying too much attention recently but I do know transaction fees have been getting much higher the past few years, like 5 to 10 dollars or so (Which means you have to pay 5 to 10 dollars to transfer any amount of Bitcoin from one address to another).
- _bxg1 6y agoI have not used it before. I just assumed that - whether a percentage or a flat fee - the amount would be... deterministic at least? That the entity being paid the fee would at least state their price somehow, instead of the user having to just, like, guess what their tribute should be and hope it's accepted. What you describe sounds incredibly bizarre to me.
- DSMan195276 6y ago
- YetAnotherMatt 6y agoWould the following theoretically work? 1. Monitor all transactions in the public pool for their fees. 2. As soon as their is a public transaction in the pool that has over 1M$ in fees, spin up as many cloud resources as possible and mine for the block. 3. As soon as the block is mined, stop mining and go back to step 1.
- schoen 6y agoYes, but you have to worry about several things, at least: * what's your latency for noticing and spinning up those resources (especially in chains where the average time between blocks is very short)? * can you cost-effectively confidently outcompete ASIC miners with rented GPUs, even given a reward that's much larger than normal? (probably, given this very extreme anomaly, but you have to do the calculation) * can you actually rent enough GPUs in practice to outcompete the ASIC miners? * will it be worth it to ASIC miners who know or speculate that you're doing this to speculatively mine for a while on a shorter chain in which they receive the reward instead of you, in the hope that they can make it longer than yours? Edit: Finally, do some of the ASIC miners have offline capacity (e.g. old equipment, or equipment located in places where electricity got more expensive) that is physically present in a datacenter but just powered off that they can also spin up quickly in response to these conditions?
- saalweachter 6y agoGiven that this was apparently a "switched two fields" error, does anyone want to comment on them apparently intending to spend $134 in transaction fees to move the money?
- FalconSensei 6y ago> Ethereum users can dictate the terms of their transactions, setting both the amount of ETH they want to send and the amount of fees they are willing to pay. The higher the fee, the thinking goes, the more likely their transaction will be included on the next block — i.e. it will go through more quickly. It's possible, therefore, that someone attempted to send $2.6 million worth of ETH with $134 in fees and simply reversed the two fields. Having to set up the fee for the transaction to hope the transaction would happen faster? Yeah, I don't see crypto replacing banks. edit: forgot the quote
- biolurker1 6y agoSounds like a developer error with Truffle and gas denominations Wei gwei etc